- This topic has 42 replies, 15 voices, and was last updated 10 years, 6 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
[adrotate group="5"]
RumplesGirl wrote: Said this in a few places, but talismans are a HUGE part of this season. By loving the JR and equating it to Emma, Hook has transferred some of his love to the ship itself. Sacrificing it would be like sacrificing a heart if you go with the talismans theory.
Yep. The “heart of the ship” could be the steering wheel of the ship. The point is what it represents that counts.
RumplesGirl wrote: However, there is very little reason to have Aurora and Philip back so it’s probably them.
I highly doubt this. Aurora and Philip love each other the most, so neither of them could’ve enacted the curse. (Otherwise, one of them would be dead by now, which maybe one is, but that is a bit dark, even for this show. I can’t see either Aurora or Philip murdering one another to enact the curse. They are one another’s true love, as confirmed when Philip awoke Aurora with TLK. It would be like Snow murdering Charming, which she’d never do).
"That’s how you know you’ve really got a home. When you leave it, there’s this feeling that you can’t shake. You just miss it." Neal Cassidy
“and things begin to heat up between Regina and Robin Hood.”
Oh God….That alone!!! AH! YES! PLEASE!
"If you go as far as you can see...you will then see enough to go even further." - Finn Balor
“and things begin to heat up between Regina and Robin Hood.”
Oh God….That alone!!! AH! YES! PLEASE!
"If you go as far as you can see...you will then see enough to go even further." - Finn Balor
I admit, the Hook Conspiracy Theorists got me thinking during last nights “sorry that was just me crossing my legs” weirdo line.
His bumping the table felt very deliberate IMO, like he was worried that whoever came through from the other side might somehow know his secret and reveal it. If the murder weapon and murderer need to be present to contact someone specific, and if he killed someone(/thing if they do attribute a soul to the ship in some way) and he did it with something that was still on his person, he would have been really wanting that seance to not be happening.
He’s clearly been keeping secrets, and there is no secret bigger than if he was the one who cast the Curse.
I don’t know how I feel about Hook using his ship if Regina can’t use her horse. I think the curse calls for the actual heart of a human.
Another thought I’ve had about it is maybe whoever cast it, did it to protect everyone from Zelena. However, she has the silver shoes, so she just followed everyone else and that’s why she has her memories.
I don’t know how I feel about Hook using his ship if Regina can’t use her horse.
Regina loved her father more than she loved her horse, she killed the horse to avoidkilling her father, but only the sacrifice of the thing you love most will make the Curse work. Hook loved the JR above all else and all others. He valued being with his ship more than he valued preserving the lives of others, he spoke about her like she was a person, he took pride in knowing every floorboard of her deck. (Flook, CaptainFloor, whichever you call it, the love is true. ;-)) IMO the ship would qualify as the thing he loves most which could be sacrificed in order to cast the Curse.
I always just thought it was Z that cast the curse. But now it dawned on me that ofcourse it must be Hook. Thats why he is the only one with memories intact and could leave Storybrook to get Emma. And why we had to see his backstory and be told he loves his ship like it was his lady.
And yes the seance bit was weird with him. Why in the name of Medusa would anyone feel forced to cross their legs in the middle of a seance, when there is a twirling blue hole of nothing above their head? Wouldnt you, even if you were a daredevil Pirat, sit kind of still, you know in “defence mode” and wait for what was coming?
I think he must have cast the curse to get everyone away from Z, but that didnt exactly Work.. thats also a reason why he is so mopey. He feels responsible for putting everyone in this jam where they cant get away from the witch.
Regina loved her father more than she loved her horse, she killed the horse to avoidkilling her father, but only the sacrifice of the thing you love most will make the Curse work. Hook loved the JR above all else and all others. He valued being with his ship more than he valued preserving the lives of others, he spoke about her like she was a person, he took pride in knowing every floorboard of her deck. (Flook, CaptainFloor, whichever you call it, the love is true. ;-)) IMO the ship would qualify as the thing he loves most which could be sacrificed in order to cast the Curse.
Well, then, Hook couldn’t have used his ship to cast the curse. He loves his ship but he loves Emma far more. He confirmed this much – he was hoping his love for his ship could replace his love for Emma after they returned to the EF but it couldn’t. So…ok, now I’m back to Hook didn’t cast the curse. Whew! 😉 Hook’s hiding something, but I’m definitely back on the ‘he traded his ship to get back, not to cast the curse’ team. haha
Well, then, Hook couldn’t have used his ship to cast the curse. He loves his ship but he loves Emma far more.
His relationship with the ship spans a couple of centuries, almost every moment spent together, on countless escapades and adventures, it was his home. He’s known Emma for a couple of months, (not including the year spent apart), half that time they were adversaries, and they were never actually in a relationship. No contest which one he’d love more IMO.
The topic ‘319 Press Release’ is closed to new replies.