- This topic has 30 replies, 22 voices, and was last updated 10 years, 7 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
Last year, AFTER THE SHOW EPISODE was completed, I always enjoyed coming to the forum to read this thread and see what everyone thought about the show. There were some lively discussions here… So what ARE your favorite and least favorite moments IN 3×15 “ QUIET MINDS ”
.
.
[adrotate group="5"]I have been seeing promos that have me super excited… …
edited…
AFTER seeing the entire show I am tired …. ONCE will string us a long til the finale… and in the mean time we have to put up with http://WWW. Not sure if I am going to watch next week …
This isn’t about my ship.
This is about a little girl who lost her father when she was 18 to a horrible disease that slowly robbed him of everything he had once been. This is about getting a phone call at noon that while I was sleeping in my bed, my father died, far away from me, with me never seeing him. This is about how he never saw me gradaute college or grad school. This is about how he never saw me off to prom.
This is about how everyday I wake up with a hole in my heart.
I have no words.
This isn’t about my ship. This is about how they just killed a good, honest, kind, courageous man. A father, a son, in the middle of the woods, without his son ever getting to see him or even knowing him.
What is the message of ONCE? Is that you must be an anti-hero to get a happy ending? Is it that you must be loved by millions to have a life?
I thought it was about more.
This isn’t about my ship.
This is about terrible writing and terrible contrived convoluted magical handwaving. And it’s about how a little boy didn’t get to see his papa one final time.
I don’t know how much I’ll ever care about this show again
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"The only good thing I found in this episode was that Rumple had a choice again between the dagger and Neal and this time he chose his son and let the WWW have the dagger.
Otherwise I’m sickened. I had a feeling it might be Neal, but they didn’t do it right. It felt rushed and out of place. It wasn’t fair to the character. I’ll still keep watching, but I’m so disappointed.
Little girl lost. 7 years old. I don’t really understand what it means when they say my father has died. He’s my hero. You adults don’t understand. He would never leave me. I look for him in the stores. I look for him in cars as my mother drives me to school. I look for him everywhere. I know I’ll find him. He never even said goodbye. Why wouldn’t they tell me I would never see him again.
And 50 years later, he’s still my hero, but I never even got to say goodbye. No hug. No tender goodbye. If they had only told me that he was sick. I would have told him so much if I had only known.
This episode broke my heart all over again. It’s not true that hope reigns supreme. It’s not true that the good guys win. It’s not true that fairy tales can come true. Not on this show.
If there’s a twist, it won’t matter. The damage has been done. Little boy lost? I feel for you. Your mother was wrong. She lied to you. She’s not a hero anymore.
I hate episodes like this, especially when it is not an evil character. I have the tendency to think what ifs. I feel horrible that Neal died and even worse for Henry. The pain in Rumples eyes was horrendous. No parent should ever lose a child. My MIL has lost two and it is the worst thing ever.
I loved that they mentioned Tallahassee, they touched on the Hook/Bae past, and they even acknowledged that Emma and Bae were TLs. That is what made this episode for me. Without these touches I would have been just as upset as everyone else.
I get what you all are saying – I truly do. But s*** happens in life – and to try to portray nothing but happy endings isn’t really realistic. My dad died when I was five, and I begged my mom to let me see him one last time before they took him away. But I was asleep and the stupid social worker wouldn’t let my mom wake me up. Almost 20 years later, that still makes me tear up. But you know, things like that do happen…
I certainly wasn’t happy about what happened to Bae. I cried my eyes out. I’m not really a ‘shipper’ and I didn’t know about the spoilers and I don’t hate the show for the way it happened. It was shocking and sad. I felt horribly for Rumple, Henry and Emma. I’m trying to see it as a form of closure for Rumple and Bae in that Bae finally got to witness with his own eyes how much his papa loves him. He may have ‘chosen the dagger’ once, but he got it right this time. No it’s not a happy ending, but it did have meaning.
Rest in peace Bae
I really don’t know what to say about this episode… seriously…. I don’t know why it makes me so sad watching this show tonight…………………. I feel so bad for Emma, Henry and Rumple…………… And I know that this is just a show, yet I just feel so bad and sad, and I have tears in my eyes, just thinking of Tallahassee :'(
I’m getting more sad reading RumplesGirl and Cinders’ posts. I’m so sorry for your lost. I know how it feels to don’t have the chance to see or even a chance to say good bye to persons that we hold dear and love the most. 🙁 A warm hug to you.
The topic ‘3×15 “QUIET MINDS ” FOR FAVORITE AND LEAST FAVORITE MOMENTS’ is closed to new replies.