9/15/2014: The Third Sister (Casting Call for Elsa and Anna’s Middle Sister???)

Okay, if Elizabeth Mitchell is a third sister, there’s something really wrong with this. Especially if she’s the middle sister.

Elizabeth Mitchell is 44 years old. Georgina Haig is 29. Elizabeth Lail is probably in her 20s as well. Point being, Elizabeth Mitchell as a middle sister is a HUGE stretch. The woman is old enough to be their mom, but definitely not as a middle sister. Adam and Eddy would have to work some serious magic in order to suspend our belief that she is a middle sister.

Edit: Okay, I like the theory that this is Belle’s sister.

It’s a new character, none of the regular guest stars they already have cast, and a character for one episode. Calm down, that’s not Elizabeth Mitchell. And I highly doubt they would add a third sister into the picture of Frozen, that would completely change the sister dynamic between Elsa and Anna. Not to mention: why should such a sister show up this late in the story arc for some fancy ball fairy flashback?

Three sisters going to a fancy ball… maybe the dumb spoiler fairies thought of Cinderella there, aside that they didn’t go the ball together, were only stepsisters and only Cinderella was blonde. Not to mention Anastasia was the younger of the two stepsister, though turned blonde in the Once-ivers, and became Queen in Wonderland… Or, oh, maybe they want to hint she’s coming. I hope not. Whatever.

Honestly, the first thing that came to mind when I saw this was Cinderella. We’ve met Ashley (was that her name?) and Anastasia but we’re missing the third. And they’re going to a ball. Hmmmm………

Don’t think they’re planning on messing with the Elsa and Anna story that much by bringing in a third sibling.

@callmeLola Good to know I was not the only one thinking of Cinderella.

@WickedRegal I agree that Cinderella’s connection is unlikely, but think these dumb spoiler fairies don’t think so. Or is there any other popular fairy tale movie with these keywords: three – sisters – ball? They like to throw keywords at fans, creates attention, gets clicks, brings ad-revenue. Who cares that Cinderella already has been done on OUaT.

We have Belle’s mother in episode 6 – and I know Belle fans would be madly happy if we get two consecutive episodes with huge Belle background / story / connection, but I doubt that is what we will get. So don’t think the Belle connection makes that much sense either.

@obisgirl headlines are leading 😉 And in the excitement of spoilers we often rush to ideas.

Frozen power is genetic. But then, how come Anna doesn’t have it?

No headaches there, it very much depends. Siblings don’t inherit always all features. Look at the difference in hair and eye color possible, different build, one has a heritable sickness, the other not. Genetics is a lot more complex. If you would meet my sister and me you would probably not guess at first we’re sisters at all, maybe after a time when seeing us together.