ABC MediaNet S3B Description

[awoovo]

Can I just say what the HECK ? First how can they forget everything in the last year in the EF ? How can Hook evade this memory loss of the year in the EF and he remembers everything unless he is working for the WWW who I have no doubt is the one who can’t be trusted I hope Adam is prepared for people being upset

Hook is not working for the Witch. OMG why would the witch want Emma to come back to SB. She’s the curse breaker. There are other  methods Hook could have used to escape the curse. Like his enchanted ship for instance.

Adam and Eddy even said the answer is not why Hook escaped it’s when and how he did. He escaped before the witch cast her curse which would send everyone to SB.

The one whom can’t be trusted is likely Rumple seeing as the witch has him under her control with the dagger.

I think you guys expecting Hook to be this ultimate betrayal are in for a very rude awakening.

[RumplesGirl]

Adam and Eddy even said the answer is not why Hook escaped it’s when and how he did. He escaped before the witch cast her curse which would send everyone to SB.

I agree but there is still the HOW.

The JR itself cannot move between worlds. It needs something to create a portal. It’s enchanted to be super fast but not to move between them. So the question then becomes how did Hook get a portal maker? I started a list a page back. I’m not saying that he’s working for the witch, I’m saying there needs to be an answer for the how.

Also, I don’t know if Emma is the breaker of this curse. If she were–it’s obvious. Go kiss Henry and be done with it. So it’s possible that Emma isn’t the savior of THIS curse.

"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"

[3princesses]

HappyEndings wrote: Or did Hook find the slippers

That’s so ridiculous that it’s obviously how it happens.

Now, I can’t get the image of Hook wearing ruby slippers out of my head! Hillarious!

[awoovo]

awoovo wrote: Adam and Eddy even said the answer is not why Hook escaped it’s when and how he did. He escaped before the witch cast her curse which would send everyone to SB.

I agree but there is still the HOW. The JR itself cannot move between worlds. It needs something to create a portal. It’s enchanted to be super fast but not to move between them. So the question then becomes how did Hook get a portal maker? I started a list a page back. I’m not saying that he’s working for the witch, I’m saying there needs to be an answer for the how. Also, I don’t know if Emma is the breaker of this curse. If she were–it’s obvious. Go kiss Henry and be done with it. So it’s possible that Emma isn’t the savior of THIS curse.

How did Hook find Emma and transcend realms, maybe that’s where Tink came in. Fairy dust could have been used. As ludicrous as this is he could have found the slippers.

This was clearly them all deciding for him to go there are the pics of only Hook on a horse in FTL with everyone else and he’s the only one there and according to people whom witnessed it Hook is filmed riding off on the horse away from them so this to me suggests this is when they realize he has to go now.

I think Hook’s story over the year is how and when he found Emma. He’s the only one that remembers everything and no I do not at all think Hook is working for the witch. I think that’s ludicrous and honestly IMO the only people that share this opinion are the people either hoping Hook is gonna die or the ones that don’t like him and still view him despite everything as a backstabbing villain.

I have been a very patient and allowing individual of opinions but this bias does not fly well with me at all.

The person whom can’t be trusted is IMO clearly Rumple going from the spoilers we know.

[angiebelle]

Curiouser and curiouser!  I’m more intrigued than ever.  Let’s please wait and see how it plays out before getting upset about anything.

[betsypaige24]

I don’t ever buy anything from this source because the people at ABC putting this together don’t watch the show, clearly. For one thing, this is a mash up of previous seasons press releases. Most importantly,  UM…. Gold did NOT bring magic to SB to escalate his feud with Regina; he brought it so he could find his son.

I’m so done with ABC

[theoniongirl]

But that IS an opinion. And just as valid as other opinions.

Storywise, I could see it happening. It would be an interesting turn of the story.

Hook has a thing for Emma; I could totally see him making a deal with the dev … err, WWW … if it meant he thought he could save her. He doesn’t care nearly so much for any other resident of SB. (Why should he?)

---
“Though lovers be lost love shall not;
And death shall have no dominion.”
-- Dylan Thomas

[RumplesGirl]

How did Hook find Emma and transcend realms, maybe that’s where Tink came in. Fairy dust could have been used. As ludicrous as this is he could have found the slippers

Both possible. Though, we don’t know how much pixie dust Tink has left after she…did whatever she did in 3×11

I think that’s ludicrous and honestly IMO the only people that share this opinion are the people either hoping Hook is gonna die or the ones that don’t like him and still view him despite everything as a backstabbing villain. I have been a very patient and allowing individual of opinions but this bias does not fly well with me at all.

Ok.

Well. You have a bias that Hook is fully redeemed. People are allowed their individual opinions about a character–in fact, it’s sorta makes this show go ’round. Interpretation is just that–interpretation. We all have them. It used to be an ok thing when we were discussing this show way back in S1, now we can’t have a conversation about anything concerning this show without someone becoming angry that their favorite character is being attacked.

A lot of people don’t like Belle. I don’t get enraged. I just go, “ok. that’s your opinion and you’re welcome to it.” A lot of people don’t like Rumple or Neal, my two favorites. But I don’t feel the need to call them out for it.

All theories (crack theories, ship theories, off the wall theories, researched theories) are welcome in the forum. You are welcome to argue against them so long as it is done politely and in a civilized manner. No theory is laughable or ludicrous just because you may not agree. That’s why it’s called discourse.

"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"

[awoovo]

I am sick however of just the claim that oh it’s Hook because he’s a backstabbing villain. I’m fine with opinions but I would hope people would honor every single thing that has happened in canon. Neverland happened, that’s allowed Hook’s character to really grow. Why won’t people honor that? Why do people still believe he’s the same person he was in S2? It makes no sense to me.

[RumplesGirl]

I am sick however of just the claim that oh it’s Hook because he’s a backstabbing villain. I’m fine with opinions but I would hope people would honor every single thing that has happened in canon. Neverland happened, that’s allowed Hook’s character to really grow. Why won’t people honor that? Why do people still believe he’s the same person he was in S2? It makes no sense to me.

if you wish to continue discussing this, this is our Captain Hook character discussion thread.

let’s focus on the crazy press release in the mean time.

"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"

[Author]

Posts