- This topic has 9 replies, 7 voices, and was last updated 10 years, 1 month ago by
.
-
Posts
-
Anna and Charming met in the EF!
What did you think of this friendship?
What did you think of Charming’s story about his father being an alcoholic who died in a drunk driving accident?
Do you think charming and Anna ever met again?
[adrotate group="5"]"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"I liked Anna in the flashbacks. Charming felt somehow…off. I’m not even sure how to describe it. And I really didn’t like the back story for his father. That felt like the writers stuck it in the episode because fans keep asking and they had no other story planned for Charming’s father. I’m also a bit sick of everyone needing to have one less than stellar parent.
How does Charming knows Kristoff?
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"Where I am struggling with the Anna/Charming scenes (which were fantastic) is how long before the scenes we see in 1×06 The Shepherd they take place. At this point based on the character ages in Frozen and the timeline there Anna is about 20 at this point, so how long was there before the curse?
Also Anna is the master swordwoman whom introduced David to dueling what is there not to love.
“The truth isn't easily pinned to a page. In the bathtub of history the truth is harder to hold than the soap and much more difficult to find.” - Terry Pratchett
I liked how it linked up to present day and Charming getting through to Elsa because of Anna.
But something about the flashbacks, I just dunno. Maybe it’s because I’m so used to seeing Josh playing Charming as older and braver, and Elizabeth’s just so young and fresh and I don’t have that older association with her character, so seeing her be the older, wiser, braver one in that relationship, the balance was just off and I found it hard to buy that version of David. Or something like that?
The story about his dad left me cold. It felt like, “Meh we don’t have a story for him, and we need a sob story for David, so we’ll just have him be already dead so we never have to deal with him, two birds, one stone.”
I wasn’t overly impressed by the Anna/Charming scenes. I found Anna to be a bit annoying this episode and I think that’s because they made her come across as a little Mary-Sueish. Mainly it was the whole sword fighting scenes. Unless Anna has actually practiced sword fighting, there’s no way she could’ve picked it up that well just watching her family’s soldiers. That’s like saying someone who has watched lots of fantasy movies and sword and sandal epics is really good at sword fighting.
I don’t like how they’re suggesting that Charming is only the way he is now because he met Anna.
I liked the Charming/Kristoff friendship. I could see Charming wanting to protect Anna because she was his friend’s fiancée but to make it seem like Charming was a wimp until Anna helped him to see the light is a bit much IMO.
Charming’s story about his father just seemed a bit off in general especially the part about how his parents fought all the time. I was under the impression in The Shepherd that Charming’s parents had a happy marriage and it was the secret of giving up James that drove the father to an early grave, not that he was an alcoholic.
All magic comes with a price!
Keeper of FelixCharming’s story about his father just seemed a bit off in general especially the part about how his parents fought all the time. I was under the impression in The Shepherd that Charming’s parents had a happy marriage and it was the secret of giving up James that drove the father to an early grave, not that he was an alcoholic.
Well, losing James might have been the cause of their father’s alcoholism.
Charming’s story about his father just seemed a bit off in general especially the part about how his parents fought all the time. I was under the impression in The Shepherd that Charming’s parents had a happy marriage and it was the secret of giving up James that drove the father to an early grave, not that he was an alcoholic.
Well, losing James might have been the cause of their father’s alcoholism.
True but the shepherd seem to imply that Ruth and Charming’s father had a reasonably happy marriage until his death.
All magic comes with a price!
Keeper of FelixTrue but the shepherd seem to imply that Ruth and Charming’s father had a reasonably happy marriage until his death.
I have to agree. Charming’s story about his father in 402 didn’t quite seem on par with what we were led to believe in The Shepherd.
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"
The topic ‘Anna and Charming’ is closed to new replies.