Baelfire

[tiara_rose]

Hook goes to Neverland to not age again, because he needed a weapon to kill the Dark one for revenge. He knew already that he would not age there, that could mean that he was doing that before. So this is a hint that he could be Peter Pan, because he want to stop aging.

It would be no problem to give him a backstory a s Peter, when he was a child.

[gypsy]

I’m not saying it can’t happen…ya never know, when it comes to K&H 🙂

I’m just trying to understand the theory.

So, Hook is in Neverland as a child, leaves for some reason, ages 8 or 10 years, then goes back, in order to not age anymore, so that he has time to try to figure out how to get his revenge on Rumplestiltskin.

It just seems unecessarily complicated.

I’m not sure, obviously, if Neal is even Bae, let alone, also PP.
It’s just a theory that I have been on board with for many months now (since my friend TGK came up with it).

I haven’t seen any clues/evidence strong enough to discredit it (imo, anyway).
By the same token, I haven’t seen as many clues/connections pointing to another possibility as there are pointing to Neal/Bae/PP.

[tiara_rose]

Yeah it is a complicated idea, but yours is it too, because when Neal is Peter Pan. What was his reason to go back to our land? Why he come to our world to be a common thief and not live with the lost boys in Neverland, to hunt Pirates.
Would it not more a Peter Pan to seek adventure on a boat to laugh, tell stories and make a sword fight. He has much in common with Emma and he look so kind, when he spoke about the lost boys.

But of course please do not hesitate try to convince me. I love to speculate and maybe I will change my mind. I know there are lots of hints for Peter Pan. The line in New York which reference to PP and the clues you wrote about his name and lots more, but when you wrote about the wherabouts of Neal in New York. I found a Alice Tea Shop, and since then Neal is the White Rabbit for me.

Maybe I will change my mind. It will depend on the content of the box. Is it a heart, he is the White Rabbit, cause the heart refers to Wonderland, but is it a really angry tinkerbell, who is glowing red, like in the movie of Peter Pan. It could be that I change my mind.

If it is something others who will know. Of course Horowitz & Kitsis.

Heros don't get their Happy Ending!

[gypsy]

I know, I guess all theories tend to seem complicated 🙂

And there are so many good one’s out there about so many different aspects/characters.
I have thought to myself so many times, when reading them, how clever some of these ppl are to come up with such interesting ideas.

I love to speculate, too.

I had a theory last year about August being Robin Hood…and there were sooo many clues and connections.

Guess we both know I was way off :/ lol!

So, yeah, I don’t rule anything out..even if I am committed to a certain theory or not, I know in the end, it’s just a theory until proven.

[tiara_rose]

Last year with August was the same by me. I always thought he would be Bae and I realized it only when he look so suspicious at the knife in the forest and 30 sec later, he tried to summon the Dark One there it was clear, but I want to find Bealfire so desperately, because he is one of my favorites, that you can cloud my judgement so easy.

I was off too!

Today I looked Peter Pan again from the old Disney movie and one thing is there too, that would it in the theory that not Neal is PP, but Hook. In the old movie Peter Pan get the ship of Hook and was the pronounced as Captain Pan by Wendy and take them Home with the ship to England.

Heros don't get their Happy Ending!

[faux pax]

@ Gyspy. Yes, Hook went to Neverland after Millah’s death so he could not age while he plotted revenge, BUT he already knew about Neverland before he threw the bean. Perhaps because he’s been there before? And honestly, I don’t see how they could PP story othewise. Wasn’t the bigest part of the story his rivalry with Hook because he cut off his hand? But in OUAT Rumple filled that role. Their’s not really much for a “peter” to do.

Besides, haven’t they done something similar with Red being both the wolf and Little Red? It doesn’t seem unnecessary complicated to me. It would just shine more light on Hook’s character, especially since K&H did something in the Crocodile that they don’t usually do: gave us the FTL character’s backstory BEFORE we see them in storybrooke. There has to be more there. I mean if you listen to the way he talks about the lost boys in Tallahassee, it sounds more nostalgic then as part of a rivalry.

Also, remember the blonde patient mentioned in the FB game? Their’s an idea that it could be Tink. If it is, i would love to see the dynamic between her and Hook. Maybe she had to leave Neverland for some reason (BF maybe?) and that’s why he had to grow up–he had no choice. Their could be a lot of resentment there to play out.

But you are right. Right now all they are are theories…but isn’t theorising half the fun of the show? 😆

[tiara_rose]

Faux Pay: Honestly, can you read my mind.

Ii don’t play the FB game. Can you say more about the blonde patient?

Heros don't get their Happy Ending!

[faux pax]

All it says is that there is a blonde patient locked in the psyc ward of the hospital that they wouldn’t let Archie talk to. Daniel in the podcast pointed out that the spelling of the word is for a girl (but i’m not sure how sure we can be of that–almost no English word has ‘genders’ like french or Spanish and if this is one of the few i’m not sure enough people know it, that it wouldn’t just be a coincidence).

[tiara_rose]

Thanks for sharing.

Heros don't get their Happy Ending!

[gypsy]

Faux Pax –

I have been wondering about the blond/blonde patient since the app came out.

It very well could be Tink 🙂

[Author]

Posts