Character Battles- Pin your favorites…(or least favorites) against each other

[Twice Upon A Time]

Ohh can we do Felix vs Baelfire (not Neal but NeverlandBae)

[RumplesGirl]

Alright. Well that’s young Bae?

He was living in a cave, but clever enough to stay out of Pan’s way and get OUT of NL.

Felix is a brute. But Young Bae got brains.

Bae.

"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"

[Marty McFly]

I’d say Bae. he’s not a boy and sure as hel not lost

Emma against Regina: I say Emma. Regina may have been Gold Best Magic Student, but Emma is powerful from within. the hat that took Emma to the EF only worked because Emma touched Regina’s arm. The diamond was stopped only by Emma

[RumplesGirl]

Emma vs anyone really isn’t fair cause it’d be Emma. She’s the most powerful magical creature that ever existed. No one can go against her.

"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"

[Marty McFly]

but she doesn’t yet KNOW her powers… and she didn’t learn from Rumpelstiltskin. which is why Regina was able to blast her and Cora was able to poof her out of the way. I wonder if Emma would be more powerful than Pan. I doubt it

[RumplesGirl]

She may not know how to use her magic 100% yet but she when she does use it, it’s always something super impressive that no one else could do–blast Cora back from Cora was trying to take her heart, which *no one* can take. Peter Pan wasn’t actually that powerful–he used games and manipulation to get what he wants, but as far as raw magic, we never really saw him do anything extraordinary. And any magic he did have was tied to his belief in himself. But Malcolm–actual Malcolm–is just  a man, no powers at all.

Emma wins against anyone.

"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"

[Marty McFly]

so why did the great and all powerful Rumpelstilskin, the one who created the power within Emma fail to even apprehend him? let alone kill him without getting killed himself?

[RumplesGirl]

so why did the great and all powerful Rumpelstilskin, the one who created the power within Emma fail to even apprehend him? let alone kill him without getting killed himself?

Well first. Rumple isn’t all powerful. He is incredibly power as the Dark One, but Rumple doesn’t have magic himself. That’s the big difference. Regina and Cora had some sort of spark that let the talent be nurtured within them. But Rumple never had any sort of magic. Emma simply IS magical. It’s the very foundation of her being. She is pure true love magic. And that’s the most powerful magic of all.

Rumple didn’t create the power within Emma. He just made sure that her parent got together to create her. And then he added a drop of their true love to the Curse scroll to ensure that Emma was the Savior of the Curse But–even if Rumple hadn’t been pulling the strings–and somehow Snowing got together, Emma would STILL be the most powerful creature in all the realms. She’d still be the daughter of True Love, Rumple or no.

And Rumple didn’t apprehend Pan because he underestimated him. He never expected that Pan would trick him with a second Pandora’s Box (or real one..I guess). He was all set to put Pan in that box but then was tricked. He later put what he thought was Pan in the box, though in 309. Peter Pan was all about mind games, not raw magical power. Just because Rumple got tricked doesn’t mean PP was more magically powerful, just that Rumple didn’t think through everything.

"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"

[Marty McFly]

I disagree on two fronts:
Rumpel did have magic pre-darkone, the cake appeared on his hand just cause he thought it. no other lost boy was able to do that.

and Emma is not the only product of true love, so in order to make her powerful Rumpelstiltskin had to add some magic to her parents somehow. they are both the purest of hearts and have pure and true love, so that IS powerful in itself, but it isn’t magic until a potion was made of it and bottled. so yeah, Gold did not MAKE Emma, but he did give her magic. because SHE could handle it without going dark. because he has power. love power that will protect her soul the way he wasn’t protected. while he was the savior, he went dark, but she doesn’t have to. he got a good replacement savior

you may be right about Pan though, the only place he was truly powerful was in never land. in story brooke he needed reginas vault and the cuff. I bet if Rumpel wouldn’t have the cuff he’d be able to kill him without dying

[Marty McFly]

but wait, if Pan can create such magical items like the cuff and the Taser and he doesn’t fall asleep even from Rumpel’s powerful sleeping spell…. me thinks Pan WAS powerful

[Author]

Posts