- This topic has 7 replies, 7 voices, and was last updated 7 years, 11 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
The Charming David wished for the EvilQueen to get exactly what she deserved.
What was/are the consequences of his wish?
He said “The only one that is going to pay the price is her” meaning the Evil Queen. But as I see it, his wish is what brought Gideon to this world, because Gideon turned EQ into a snake (and Charming called EQ a snake a minute before he made his wish) So is Charmings wish what inadvertently is going to cause Emma’s “death”?
[adrotate group="5"]Also, as they established again that Regina and the EQ are one in the same, does it mean that the wish actually effected Regina as well/or instead? Could that be why Robin showed up?
No idea….but I forgot Charming called her a snake….so that can’t be a coincidence.
I definitely think it was heavy foreshadowing. But I’m not sure it’s the result of David’s wish because is this what she deserves? To be a snake…? Magic is funny in that way so it’s possible.
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"Also, as they established again that Regina and the EQ are one in the same, does it mean that the wish actually effected Regina as well/or instead? Could that be why Robin showed up?
Good point. I was wondering why Regina wasn’t turned into a snake. Then I remembered that it was because she was in another ”realm”’. She didn’t turn into a snake in WWW, and she probably won’t turn into a snake in SB because the wish would be done and dusted by the time Regina got back. Because I don’t think the wish affected Regina at all, I think them meeting was fate, rather than the wish.
Not only that but Charming (as far as I can recall) wished for the EQ specifically to get what she deserves. Regina is currently Regina, not the EQ.
Keeper of Regina's bravery
So here’s what I think. Charming made the wish with the intent of EQ getting punished for all her crimes, but his wording “to get what she deserves” is so vague that he probably should have been more specific. So the EQ is going to get what she deserves, which in OUAT logic is going to be….a happy ending….redemption…and love. This is where fake RH is going to come in as well as fake FTL and even fake henry. EQ, I speculate, at some point in this story is going to be forced to help the heroes and turn over a new leaf. She will reunite with Robin and go to live in the newly made FTL where she and he will raise Prince Henry and be rulers of the EF. I think this will happen because it would not be right to have real Regina live happily ever after with Fake!Robin. He’s not the real RH, not the one she knew and went through so much with, he is a copy. At least with EQ going off with him, its okay because shes not really real either. There has to be a reason for the scene at the start of the episode to take place with EQ at RH’s grave, talking about how she *used* to love him. I think its all foreshadowing. The fake realm being created, RH popping back up, Henry being alive in the realm despite all logic.
"I could have the giant duck as my steed!" --Daniel Radcliffe
Keeper Of Tamara's Taser , Jafar's Staff, Kitsis’s Glasses , Ariel’s Tail, Dopey's Hat , Peter Pan’s Shadow, Outfit, & Pied Cloak,Red Queen's Castle, White Rabbit's Power To World Hop, Zelena's BroomStick, & ALL MAGICThere has to be a reason for the scene at the start of the episode to take place with EQ at RH’s grave, talking about how she *used* to love him. I think its all foreshadowing. The fake realm being created, RH popping back up, Henry being alive in the realm despite all logic.
I wonder if this will have something to do with the two halves of Regina reuniting….
EQ starts the episode visiting RH’s grave. EQ claims she is basically honouring his memory, because if wasn’t for his death, EQ wouldn’t have been created. (That is, Regina wouldn’t have felt so badly after his death, that she wouldn’t have wished away half of herself). EQ further claims she loved RH, not loves. First of all, I don’t believe that one. We have been shown repeatedly, in many ways, that Regina feels very deeply, for example, not even removing her heart stops her from feeling and loving. Secondly, the EQ loves Henry.
So, if the EQ both loves RH, but realizes his death liberated her, what happens when that hurt is healed, or at least the grieving process completed? Even in just Regina? Is there a reason for EQ to exist after that?
Matt: “Also, as they established again that Regina and the EQ are one in the same, does it mean that the wish actually effected Regina as well/or instead? Could that be why Robin showed up?”
I was thinking about that too. It is an interesting idea (Only I think it wasnt Robin who we met in the AU, I think its going to turn out to be Roland,, and if so, I dont see how that fits in with it being because of Charmings wish) But if it really is Robin then it MUST be the wish- since he didnt age.
sierraleone: “So, if the EQ both loves RH, but realizes his death liberated her, what happens when that hurt is healed, or at least the grieving process completed? Even in just Regina? Is there a reason for EQ to exist after that?”
Good questions. I dont know if EQ loves Robin anymore, but as I see it, EQ is so undetached from her real feelings, she most definitely BELIEVES she doesnt love him anymore, she doesnt know what it means to love. Maybe if she was in proximity of him she would feel something for him.. When Regina is “healed” there is no need for Evil Queen, because she will be back inside Regina- its the only way she will truly be able to heal, imo.
theWatcher: The writing you put under the spoiler block, I hope that doesnt happen, but you never know…
The topic ‘Charming's Wish’ is closed to new replies.