Could Tinkerbell be a villain/on Pan's side?

[shack1212]

I saw this theory posted on imdb and I liked how it fit

– Pan and Tinkerbell have never had a scene together

– Blue Fairy didn’t give Tinkerbell her wings back. Could she sense something to distrust about her?

– We know Pan is into his “switching” deception game, which is also called “lady”. Expect him to have one more switch up his sleeve. Such as Pan getting killed by having a switch leading to the curse going off without him.

– If the curse actually happens it’s hard to imagine it happening via Pan. Who does he love most? He’s not getting Rumplestiltskin’s heart. Could it be Felix? Is it believable Felix would be the thing he loves most? The reverse makes more sense, Felix using Pan’s heart as the thing he loves most. Or this theory: Blue Fairy would be the thing Tinkerbell loves most right? Tinkerbell could sneak out Blue Fairy’s heart while nobody’s looking, believably. I would bet on either Felix or someone else like Tinkerbell doing the curse in the end, after Pan is dead.

– That would also explain why the shadow killed Blue Fairy, because it was setting this up all along. (Although it was also a diversion to send Regina to her vault and to wipe out a powerful opposition.)

– The scene with Hook and Tinkerbell would end up being a red herring. Making it look like ‘oh, this is the next storyline’, but then BAM, she’s a villain.

– If the curse hits and they go back to Enchanted Forest or Storybrooke, would there need to be an equivalent to Regina? Either the Mayor or a Queen back in Enchanted Forest? Would Tinkerbell’s reward for the curse, to be the queen in Regina’s place? Would it be to be the new Queen Fairy?

– Although it may seem hard to explain why Tinkerbell would be doing all the Neverland stuff if on Pan’s side, note that Pan wanted Rumplestiltskin to find him to give him the offer to join him. Most of what happened in Neverland Pan wanted, until Regina had no regrets at the tree and he got captured. I think it’s explainable if she’s a mole.

 

[RumplesGirl]

Wow great question! When Tink was first cast I had her pegged as being a double agent. So far we know that PP trusts Tink but we don’t know why. I really want some backstory on those two.

My gut tells me that she’s on the “right” side with our heroes, given her relationship with Regina. But it would be nice to now why specifically PP trusts her. He doesn’t seem to trust anyone outside of Felix and that is because Felix is super loyal to him.

"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"

[Slurpeez]

I think Tinkerbell could be a double-agent, in the sense that PP thinks she’s loyal to him, but she’s really on the side of Regina, the Charmings, Neal, etc…

"That’s how you know you’ve really got a home. When you leave it, there’s this feeling that you can’t shake. You just miss it." Neal Cassidy

[RumplesGirl]

I think Tinkerbell could be a double-agent, in the sense that PP thinks she’s loyal to him, but she’s really on the side of Regina, the Charmings, Neal, etc…

Hmmm. But now PP knows that she’s not right cause she was on the boat with the Heroes. Or does PP think that is part of their plan?

"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"

[Author]

Posts