ONCE - Once Upon a Time podcast

Reviews, theories, and talk about ABC's Once Upon a Time TV show

Does anyone else find this slightly, ummm, creepy?

Home › Forums › Once Upon a Time › Season Two › General Season Two discussion › Does anyone else find this slightly, ummm, creepy?

Viewing 8 posts - 21 through 28 (of 28 total)
1 2 3
  • Author
    Posts
  • January 31, 2013 at 1:44 am #170992
    Josephine
    Participant

    Okay, Emma would be NO relation to Rumple no matter what happens. He would be her son’s grandfather and that’s it. Not even father-in-law as her and Neal were never married.

    Henry’s
    Bioligical Family:

    Mother:
    Emma Swan

    Henry’s Maternal Grandparents:
    Prince Charming (son of Ruth, short-term fake son of King George)
    Snow White (daughter of King Leopold, stepdaughter of Regina)

    Father:
    Neal Cassidy

    Henry’s Paternal Grandparents:
    Rumplestiltskin
    Milah

    Henry’s
    Adoptive Family:

    Mother:
    Regina Mills (aka Evil Queen)

    Maternal Grandparents:
    Cora (aka Queen of Hearts)
    Henry (aka in fandom as Henry Sr.)

    This is all dependant on Neal being Bae for the Rumplestiltskin side of the family.

    Regina would be:

      Snow’s stepmother, Emma’s step-grandmother, Henry’s step-great grandmother and adoptive mother. None of them blood related.

      If by some wild chance that Rumple is her father, then she would be blood related to Neal, who would be her brother and would make her Henry’s biological aunt. Cora would be nothing to Henry blood-wise.

    Rumple would be:

      Neal’s father, Henry’s grandfather.

      If he’s Regina’s biological father, then that would be just that…Regina’s biological father.

      Not technically Emma’s father-in-law or in-laws with the Charmings as they were never married. However, they would be co-grandparents to Henry.

    Not really that complicated. I have a much more complicated family tree that I don’t even try to explain to people. In a nutshell, my grandfather married my grandmother and then all his siblings married all of her siblings. Sort of the uniting of two different families.

    [adrotate group="5"]

    Keeper of Rumplestiltskin's and Neal's spears and war paint and crystal ball.

    January 31, 2013 at 1:59 am #171000
    nonnie
    Participant

    Emma, Snow and PC is not related to GOLD/ RUMPLE or Mihla by blood. Thru marriage maybe but there are 100s of years between them.

    Neal is Henry’s father but if he is BAE too there is no direct blood relationship between, Neal, Bae and Emma. ( As shown up until now)

    If I am wrong please post how they are related.

    thank you
    .
    .

    January 31, 2013 at 3:01 am #171009
    timespacer
    Participant

    As others have pointed out, there is no relation between Emma and Rumple, even if Neal is Baelfire. If Emma and Neal were to marry, Rumple and Milah (posthumously) would become Emma’s in-laws. As for great-grandparents, Rumple and Milah would be the great-grandparents of Henry’s children (but I doubt the show will run long enough for us to see them – August did say that Henry is precocious, but I don’t think he’s THAT precocious!) 😆

    Even if Neal is not Bae, the relationships can get complex. I’ve drawn up a crude family tree which I’ve attached to this post as a PDF. Notice that Henry is not only the grandson of Snow, he is also her step-brother. Which means Henry is Emma’s uncle and therefore he is his own great-uncle! It reminds me of the old song, I’m My Own Grandpa which may be seen at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q0s5Kn9QXtU (which I posted long ago, but we have a lot of new people now so I’ll repost it – with apologies to any who may not have even liked it the first time,)

    January 31, 2013 at 4:41 am #171021
    CrownedWithLaurels
    Participant

    @TimeSpacer wrote:

    Notice that Henry is not only the grandson of Snow, he is also her step-brother. Which means Henry is Emma’s uncle and therefore he is his own great-uncle!

    Wow! Nice job! I read the first few parts to my husband and we were discussing the whole step-brother/uncle thing. After a few minutes I read the rest, “he is his own great-uncle” and laughed hysterically! 😆 I find that so amusing and funny! I get the funniest picture in my head! 😆

    Keeper Nealfire's/Bae's scarf, Henry and Neal's bribery ice cream sundae, Baelfire's sword, the coconut map, and more.

    January 31, 2013 at 6:09 am #171025
    Grimmsister
    Participant

    Please 🙄 most family trees these days are muchmore complicated then our little Storybrook familys. I see no problem with this.
    Like some people have pointed out royal families often intermarried certainly in the past. But there really is non of that going on here as far as I can see.
    Have anyone seen ‘Game of thrones’ ? The Lannister family relations- that’s where we can start talking creepy..

    January 31, 2013 at 3:20 pm #171056
    beastwhisperer
    Participant

    @Josephine wrote:

    Okay, Emma would be NO relation to Rumple no matter what happens. He would be her son’s grandfather and that’s it. Not even father-in-law as her and Neal were never married.

    Regina would be:

      Snow’s stepmother, Emma’s step-grandmother, Henry’s step-great grandmother and adoptive mother. None of them blood related.

      If by some wild chance that Rumple is her father, then she would be blood related to Neal, who would be her brother and would make her Henry’s biological aunt. Cora would be nothing to Henry blood-wise.

    Rumple would be:

      Neal’s father, Henry’s grandfather.

      If he’s Regina’s biological father, then that would be just that…Regina’s biological father.

    He would never be a blood relation, but if he were Regina’s father he would be Snow’s stepgrandfather. Lots of kids have stepgrandparents. That would make him Emma’s stepgreat-grandfather. Again not a blood relation.

    January 31, 2013 at 9:42 pm #171101
    evilqueen
    Participant

    @medchen wrote:

    Have anyone seen ‘Game of thrones’ ? The Lannister family relations- that’s where we can start talking creepy..

    Or the Targaryens! 😆

    February 21, 2013 at 7:01 am #174616
    Killian Jones
    Participant

    @TimeSpacer wrote:

    As others have pointed out, there is no relation between Emma and Rumple, even if Neal is Baelfire. If Emma and Neal were to marry, Rumple and Milah (posthumously) would become Emma’s in-laws. As for great-grandparents, Rumple and Milah would be the great-grandparents of Henry’s children (but I doubt the show will run long enough for us to see them – August did say that Henry is precocious, but I don’t think he’s THAT precocious!) 😆

    Even if Neal is not Bae, the relationships can get complex. I’ve drawn up a crude family tree which I’ve attached to this post as a PDF. Notice that Henry is not only the grandson of Snow, he is also her step-brother. Which means Henry is Emma’s uncle and therefore he is his own great-uncle! It reminds me of the old song, I’m My Own Grandpa which may be seen at https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=q0s5Kn9QXtU (which I posted long ago, but we have a lot of new people now so I’ll repost it – with apologies to any who may not have even liked it the first time,)

    Now that’s pretty funny lol

  • Author
    Posts
Viewing 8 posts - 21 through 28 (of 28 total)
1 2 3

The topic ‘Does anyone else find this slightly, ummm, creepy?’ is closed to new replies.