- This topic has 61 replies, 20 voices, and was last updated 8 years, 1 month ago by
.
-
Posts
-
Who knows with these writers? I think the online OQ fandom is more vocal about Robin’s death than the SF fandom was when Neal died
I dont think so, are you forgotting Hope for Neal and the most missed character nom? In neal case there are internal causes, that u and me know what they were, confirmed by JMo on a video interview after 315 aired, but moving on to RH thing.
I dont think Robin is going to be in a mirror, 1st bc would mean he can stay in lot of epis in that condiction, also for that they would have to get his soul and again that would mean talking about a elephant in the room called Neal, i mean if according to Hnery, RH moved on and is on a better place, how is that he would be helping Regina in some form, especially when regina had worst moments show wise and Daniel never came to her to help that would mean that for example Hnery as the truest believer, in case if he needed help his father would appear to help him, which he cant, they dont need plot holes that can lead to people asking, so means Neal can return to talk with Rumple( ok in this case, more yell at him than talk) and henry everytime they need help.Finally why mirror makes no sense is bc Sean said he would only return to ouat if he had a major storyline, not seing a mirror with probably having one 1minute scene talking with Regina being a major storylinei especially bc they call it RH is back for a new arc.
And if Adam thought he would get positive things on his twiter after this he is wrong, OQ fans want RH back for real, not as a flashbacks or ghost, SQ fans are pissed they ruined Regina arc for a man and SF /neal fans and from other parts of the fandom are saying if RH may be back for sereral epis to get closure or flashbacks, bring Neal to talk with Hnery, Rumple, Belle and even make him get closure with Milah, so yep, he was probably better before this was out.
Another theory i saw was that EQ could be projecting images of a fake Robin to try to break Regina, those visons can occur in several epis, like, she is walking in the street and she sees him at distance, like make everyone think she is crazy, that she sees Robin when everyone doesnt see him, i can actually see them do this.
Or maybe RH has a twin, that is the real RH, while the 1st that we say was impersonating his brother, and they say that this twin is in fact the real Regina soul mate, so they recast the character using the same actor, and no connection to zelena /marian characters, i mean is possible, they did brought back Marian , that later became Zelena, or rumple and neal merging, so a RH twin, would be more normal than the other 2 things.
[adrotate group="5"]Whilst the mirror theory does make sense – I don’t see why they would announce his involvement at this point if he was just going to be doing green screen work. This is the sort of return that they could have hidden and thrown in as a genuine shock for the audience, because Sean wouldn’t be doing street scenes and potentially having pictures taken of him. This alone makes me think that he will not be confined to the mirror.
I think the online OQ fandom is more vocal about Robin’s death than the SF fandom was when Neal died.
Mainly the Regina fandom (and non SQers) but yeah the vocal outcry post Robin’s death was harsher.
So the reason A&E say “we are NOT bringing him back from the dead” so directly could may be because he’s not dead, but just lost somewhere in time and space.
But they do keep saying dead is dead in regards to Sean/Robin when asked.
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"Whilst the mirror theory does make sense – I don’t see why they would announce his involvement at this point if he was just going to be doing green screen work. This is the sort of return that they could have hidden and thrown in as a genuine shock for the audience, because Sean wouldn’t be doing street scenes and potentially having pictures taken of him. This alone makes me think that he will not be confined to the mirror.
True but it’s not just mirrors that Sydney that project himself on to. It was any reflective surface–so a shop window in SB for example. And that would require outdoor work if they needed a genuine outdoor scene (as opposed to the recreated Steveston on a sound stage).
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"Uhhh, classic catering to the fandom. They just couldn’t let him go. This better be worth it. I’m thinking it’s an impostor. Perhaps Jafar. Although the whole I’ll be Your Mirror thing is just so obvious at this point. Perhaps Regina finally lets Sydney off the hook and let’s him be free. And Robin somehow willingly takes on the role bc he’s dead anyway? Who knows. I’m thinking impostor still. They can’t bring him back to life. And it’s a multi-episode arc. So it’s gotta be Jafar or the EQ.
I could be so wrong, but here’s a thought!
What if Robin Hood is dead, but there’s a way for him to come back….
We’re delving off into “Untold Stories” this season, and there is definetly one story we haven’t heard yet…Page 23, the Author’s Experiment Writing. What if A & E have Regina somehow transported into the storybook, and she brings out Page 23’s Version of Robin Hood?! Not only would the dead is dead technically stick because it wouldn’t be the Robin we knew, but it’s also a sneaky way to bring back the character….this way, they could technically have their cake and eat it too. And it’d also allow us to really see Henry’s capabilities as an author if he helped his mother reunite with her soul mate this way.
"If you go as far as you can see...you will then see enough to go even further." - Finn Balor
I could be so wrong, but here’s a thought! What if Robin Hood is dead, but there’s a way for him to come back…. We’re delving off into “Untold Stories” this season, and there is definetly one story we haven’t heard yet…Page 23, the Author’s Experiment Writing. What if A & E have Regina somehow transported into the storybook, and she brings out Page 23’s Version of Robin Hood?! Not only would the dead is dead technically stick because it wouldn’t be the Robin we knew, but it’s also a sneaky way to bring back the character….this way, they could technically have their cake and eat it too. And it’d also allow us to really see Henry’s capabilities as an author if he helped his mother reunite with her soul mate this way.
They might bring him back to life it it is the final season, otherwise I don’t see him returning to be a regular cast member.
"All your questions are pointless"
They can’t bring him back to life.
Well, isn’t that the thing though? They could. They’ve already gone back on “he was obliterated” and if they really wanted to, they would. Have Zeus snap his fingers or have there be another magical object that can bring him back or have it be a reward for Regina for defeating her evil self.
They might bring him back to life it it is the final season, otherwise I don’t see him returning to be a regular cast member.
Pretty much agree with that.
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"Who knows with these writers? I think the online OQ fandom is more vocal about Robin’s death than the SF fandom was when Neal died
I dont think so, are you forgotting Hope for Neal and the most missed character nom? In neal case there are internal causes, that u and me know what they were, confirmed by JMo on a video interview after 315 aired, but moving on to RH thing.
What are the internal things? What interview? If you don’t want to respond here then respond in the Emma + Baelfire thread.
Well, isn’t that the thing though? They could. They’ve already gone back on “he was obliterated” and if they really wanted to, they would. Have Zeus snap his fingers or have there be another magical object that can bring him back or have it be a reward for Regina for defeating her evil self.
I just think they can barely get away with bringing someone back from the dead once. If they do it again, death will literally mean nothing on this show. I will bet my life on it that Robin Hood will not be brought back to life.
The topic ‘EW 9/27 – Sean Maguire returning as Robin Hood’ is closed to new replies.