- This topic has 61 replies, 20 voices, and was last updated 8 years, 7 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
Alright folks…this looks like it won’t be an easy season no matter which direction it goes! So whose going to be bringing the gin every Sunday night because I feel like we’re all going to need it!
Lord. All of that sounds quite plausible.
[adrotate group="5"]"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"So whose going to be bringing the gin every Sunday night because I feel like we’re all going to need it!
we saw Robin’s soul literally explode, disappear, or whatever it did
I think you hit the nail on the head though–we don’t actually know what Robin’s soul did and because A and E never really explain the mechanics of it, they can say that his soul did pretty much anything. Maybe it reformed in some sort of nether realm. Maybe it flew into a mirror-verse and he’s trying to make contact (Slurpeez already pointed out the feather from above). Because this is completely uncharted for the show, and because their world is already so shaky, they can kinda go in any direction.
Absolutely….at this point, you really can’t put anything past this show. However, if this is in fact the final season…as much as I don’t want it to end like this, I can see Adam and Eddy pulling a stunt like this theory now floating around on twitter:
Alright folks…this looks like it won’t be an easy season no matter which direction it goes! So whose going to be bringing the gin every Sunday night because I feel like we’re all going to need it!I don’t see them killing Regina after her speech about starting a new story with the hope and belief that it’ll have a better ending than the first one.
The only hitch with the mirror thing for me is…we saw Robin’s soul literally explode, disappear, or whatever it did…and he doesn’t have magic, so his spirit can’t just be traveling around Storybrooke like Zelena’s did. Adam and Eddy would have to have a pretty solid plan of restoring his soul in order to make sense of him being trapped in the mirror this whole time.
There actually is something potentially in the writers’ favor. When the crystal hit Robin, we just saw his soul leave his body, and then disappear. His body remained behind intact, and his soul could have just gone literally anywhere. But when Zelena uses the crystal on Hades, it turns him into ashes. So Hades was truly obliterated, while Robin wasn’t.
I hadn’t thought about that. Perhaps it bears some resemblance to Harry Potter, in the sense that by stepping in front of Regina (which is a heroic, loving, selfless act) the crystal didn’t work in the same way on him?
Archie, Blue Fairy, Rumple, Charming, Zelena, Hook (3 times)… Sorry to tell you but death already means nothing on this show, especially after we know that they basically live the same life in a red Storybrooke after they die and it doesn’t help that resurrection has no post traumatic effect on them.
Only three of those are even comparable though. Rumple, Hook, and Blue Fairy. They all were dead for a longer period of time. Not just one episode. We found out in the same episode that Archie was fine, and you saw his “death” through a dog’s memories. A little different than getting obliterated by a crystal right in front of us. Zelena, although somewhat shocking that they brought her back, she turned into dust, floated away, and opened the portal, so it was sort of implied that she wasn’t completely dead. And Hook, well, he’s such a huge cast member and fan favorite…we all kinda knew he wasn’t completely dead. And Charming was dead for like 5 seconds before Snow shared her heart. Robin was obliterated into dust and we haven’t seen him since. And then his exit interviews were pretty brutal towards A&E. And he said he wouldn’t come back. I just don’t think some of the other characters are comparable. To me, death still means SOMETHING (barely) on this show. But if they actually bring back Robin Hood to life, it’s over for me, and I honestly may stop watching the show.
Hook is not a fan favorite. He is easily the most disliked character on the show.
False. His character is divided in the fandom but the people that love him, LOVE him.
Hook is not a fan favorite. He is easily the most disliked character on the show.
False. His character is divided in the fandom but the people that love him, LOVE him.
You’re both right. He’s a base-breaker. Those who like him, LOVE him. Those who dislike him, HATE him. And he has only become more divisive over the years.
Excited to head back to @OnceABC but how, why, dead or alive?……We'll see. #hoodies
— Sean Maguire (@sean_m_maguire) September 29, 2016
Hook is not a fan favorite. He is easily the most disliked character on the show.
Oh I disagree a bit. He’s the most polarizing, to be sure, but that stems from his overwhelming popularity back in his introduction and how people viewed him with Emma. I think in more recent years the dislike has become more vocal because more fandoms (ie: not just SQ and SF) have joined in but those those who loved Hook only love him more now and they are still a large portion of the fanbase.
You’re both right. He’s a base-breaker. Those who like him, LOVE him. Those who dislike him, HATE him. And he has only become more divisive over the years.
Pretty much that.
Also, Sean’s tweet is….interesting.
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"
The topic ‘EW 9/27 – Sean Maguire returning as Robin Hood’ is closed to new replies.