Eww CaptainSwan shippers

[nonnie]

Reasons I do not care for the character Hook:

Yes I enjoy the actor and think he is doing a good job…. but that said …

1/ Hook acts like a school yard bully picking on kids smaller and weaker of stature. ( I still do not think Gold was coward for not wanting to be cannon fodder for the GLORY of his fudal overseer.)

2/ Hook and Mihla are like the Jock and the cheerleader who pick on the nerds. I find Rumple / Gold more intelligent than either of them. Hook got Mihla to abandon her child. He probably would have been an abusive step dad … He sure does not relate well to the LOST BOYS.

3/ I truly dislike the sexual innuendos in a family show.

4/ He is remorseless and blinded by his revenge, willing to hurt innocent people.

I am sure there are other reasons but at 4 am / insomnia has not let me think of them …. good night…

Nonnie..
.
.

[eastofthesun]

I think Hook is SO pretty to look at 😉 and as an actor he is brilliant!!! For me I LIKE Hook and Emma , they have a fun interesting dynamic, they understand and respect each other and maybe even fancy each other a bit, BUT I wish for them to remain just friends…Like other people said, MAYBE Hook will be redeemed in the long run, but as of now he seems pretty villainous and two faced. So I can’t see Emma truly falling for him ( I agree that the sexual innuendos are getting OLD 🙄 ) …..

ALSO my personal opinion is that Emma & Neal have more intense romantic star crossed lovers chemistry that just breaks my heart and makes me LOVE THEM , and if Neal=Bae, then that storyline has SO much potential for amazing scenes: OTP material!!! imagine all the angst from both parts, also the fact that Henry is in the picture, I would love it for them to become a family… Don´t get me wrong I really like Hook, and want him to find peace & happiness (maybe with Regina, Aurora or Ariel?? 😉 ) BUT I just can´t see it with Emma….But Its pretty obvious the writers want a Emma-Neal-Hook triangle 😥 I HATE/LOVE triangles, they are interesting but frustrating…. I want it to be Sunday already!! 😆

[Phee]

@NONNIE wrote:

He sure does not relate well to the LOST BOYS.

Actually, the time we saw him mention the Lost Boys, (when he and Emma were climbing the beanstalk), he appeared to have a look of fond nostalgia for them. I’m looking forward to seeing what the history is there, (one of the reasons I hope Bae ended up in Neverland is because I’d love to see Hook meeting Milah’s son and bonding with him).

I’m on the team that sees Hook as being redeemable. All the detrimental things people say about his character are spot on, but I see that that all stems from a place of extreme hurt, and I think that once he finally acknowledges that, he’ll start on the path to being a better man. His present day actions are understandable to me, given his heartbreak, and I’m hoping we eventually see what happened in his life that drove him into piracy. Considering all of that, that’s why I can see him having a relationship with someone in the future. I don’t think that someone will be Emma though.

I get a kick out of their flirtations, (and love the innuendos ;)), and think that Emma can relate to him more than she’s willing to admit. That tension makes them interesting to me, though I’m not a shipper who sees them together in anything resembling a functional relationship. Each of them needs someone different in the long run IMO, but I’ll enjoy their flirtation for however long it lasts.

The family tree entanglement doesn’t turn me off, I guess because there’s a 200 odd year gap between Milah and Emma, and Hook doesn’t know how the two ladies are (most likely) connected, so it’s not like he knowingly jumped straight from one to the other. I do wonder though, if Neal is revealed to be Bae, if that will do Hook’s head in a bit, and it’ll make him cool things with Emma. Especially if, as I suggested earlier in this post, Hook knew Bae as a child, and they didn’t hate each other. If so, then Hook probably wouldn’t want to get in the middle of Neal and Emma sorting their stuff out, and may take a step back, out of respect for Milah’s son.

[gypsy]

I agree with Nonnie.

Hook’s sexual innuendos make him come off as sleazy.

Seems like they purposely wrote his character to be a predictable playboy with a Cassanova Complex who is in love with himself.

As far as easy on the eyes…meh…He’s ok. I’ve seen better…but, that’s just my opinion.

[Phee]

@Gypsy wrote:

Seems like they purposely wrote his character to be a predictable playboy with a Cassanova Complex who is in love with himself.

It’s interesting how people can interpret things so differently, (would be boring if we all saw everything the same way). Personally, I see it all as false bravado because he hates himself.

[swanhook]

I’m getting really sick and tired of all the hate against CS. How do I delete my account?

[sarah_tn]

@SwanHook wrote:

I’m getting really sick and tired of all the hate against CS. How do I delete my account?

SwanHook, I wish we had a “like” button we could click on for posts. I don’t like the CS hatred either.

I really, really like Captain Hook, and I just can’t imagine the show without him anymore. I’ll agree Emma might be better off with Neal, but there are other women in Storybrooke (like Red or Regina). The Captain Swan hatred is really overdone, though. Who was it that said “Can’t we all just get along”? I know the guy who said it was doing it to be funny, but I’ll go ahead and ask everybody: Can’t we all just get along?

If you don’t like Captain Hook, don’t put him on a rotisserie, just post and comment about the stuff you do like! That way, we Hook fans will feel free to talk about who we like.

[swanhook]

@Sarah_TN wrote:

@SwanHook wrote:

I’m getting really sick and tired of all the hate against CS. How do I delete my account?

SwanHook, I wish we had a “like” button we could click on for posts. I don’t like the CS hatred either.

I really, really like Captain Hook, and I just can’t imagine the show without him anymore. I’ll agree Emma might be better off with Neal, but there are other women in Storybrooke (like Red or Regina). The Captain Swan hatred is really overdone, though. Who was it that said “Can’t we all just get along”? I know the guy who said it was doing it to be funny, but I’ll go ahead and ask everybody: Can’t we all just get along? 😀

If you don’t like Captain Hook, don’t put him on a rotisserie, just post and comment about the stuff you do like! That way, we Hook fans will feel free to talk about who we like. 😉

I love you 😀 lol. I think people just do it out of spite though-they know its gonna happen and they’re scared.
I feel the same way too-scared to bring him up. Because people always put him down and attack us when there is absolutely no need to. Its ridiculous.

But I really do want to delete my account because I’m getting sick of all the attacks at Hook or CS. Nothing is being done about it, so I’ll just leave. Do you know how to do it?

[sarah_tn]

Sorry, I sure don’t. Daniel might be able to help with that. I do ask that you wait before leaving, though.

If pushing out the Hook fans has been the idea, then it must be working pretty well. I used to see a lot more here about Captain Hook, but not lately, and I think the reason why might be because the hostility has intimidated people into either not talking about him, or leaving. If you leave, I might too. I don’t like the idea of being the only fan of Captain Hook here. I think I might feel like being fresh meat in a den of hungry wolves. It wouldn’t be such a fun place to be anymore.

[swanhook]

Awww..alright I’ll wait- I always look out for my fellow shipmates 😀
Are you on Tumblr? Because theres a Captain Swan tag on there, and everyones so nice and welcoming, its the best place to discuss CS 😀

[Author]

Posts