Favorite to Least Favorite Episodes Ranking

[MatthewPaul]

Since some of us were discussing in the chat, we thought it’d be fun to rank down the episodes from favorite to least favorite. First we’ll do it by Season, and then we’ll have a ranking for the entire series so far. For me:

Season 1

A Land Without Magic
Snow Falls
Pilot
Skin Deep
7:15 A.M.
The Heart Is a Lonely Hunter
Hat Trick
The Thing You Love Most
Desperate Souls
The Stable Boy
An Apple Red as Blood
Heart of Darkness
Red-Handed
The Return
The Price of Gold
The Shepherd
The Stranger
True North
That Still Small Voice
Fruit of the Poisonous Tree
What Happened to Frederick
Dreamy

Season 2

Second Star to the Right
And Straight On til’ Morning
Queen of Hearts
The Miller’s Daughter
Manhattan
Lady of the Lake
The Crocodile
Tallahassee
Broken
We Are Both
Into the Deep
The Doctor
The Queen is Dead
The Outsider
The Cricket Game
The Evil Queen
Lacey
Welcome to Storybrooke
In the Name of the Brother
Child of the Moon
Tiny
Selfless, Brave and True

Season 3

Snow Drifts/There’s No Place Like Home
Going Home
New York City Serenade
Witch Hunt
Lost Girl
The Heart of the Truest Believer
Think Lovely Thoughts
Quite a Common Fairy
Nasty Habits
Ariel
A Curious Thing
Kansas
The Jolly Roger
Good Form
It’s Not Easy Being Green
Dark Hollow
The New Neverland
Save Henry
Bleeding Through
The Tower
Quiet Minds

Series Overall

A Land Without Magic
Snow Falls
Pilot
Skin Deep
7:15 A.M.
Snow Drifts/There’s No Place Like Home
Second Star to the Right
And Straight On til’ Morning
Queen of Hearts
The Miller’s Daughter
Manhattan
The Heart Is a Lonely Hunter
Hat Trick
The Thing You Love Most
Going Home
New York City Serenade
Witch Hunt
Lost Girl
Desperate Souls
The Stable Boy
An Apple Red as Blood
Lady of the Lake
Heart of Darkness
The Crocodile
Tallahassee
The Heart of the Truest Believer
Think Lovely Thoughts
Red-Handed
The Return
The Price of Gold
Quite a Common Fairy
Nasty Habits
Ariel
The Shepherd
A Curious Thing
Kansas
Broken
The Jolly Roger
We Are Both
Into the Deep
Good Form
The Stranger
The Doctor
The Queen is Dead
The Outsider
True North
It’s Not Easy Being Green
Dark Hollow
The New Neverland
Save Henry
Bleeding Through
That Still Small Voice
Fruit of the Poisonous Tree
The Cricket Game
The Evil Queen
What Happened to Frederick
Lacey
Dreamy
Welcome to Storybrooke
In the Name of the Brother
Child of the Moon
The Tower
Tiny
Quiet Minds
Selfless, Brave and True

[RumplesGirl]

I can do season so far. Series is harder.

Season 1

Skin Deep
Land Without Magic
Desperate Souls
The Return
Pilot
Apple Red as Blood
7:15 Am
The Thing You Love Most
Snow Falls
The Price of Gold
Red-Handed
The Heart is a Lonely Hunter
The Stable Boy
The Stranger
Heart of Darkness
Hat Trick
Fruit of the Poisonous Tree
What Happened to Frederick
The Shepherd
That Still Small Voice
True North
Dreamy

Season 2

Manhattan
The Crocodile
And Straight On Till Morning
Second Star to the Right
Tallahassee
Lacey
Miller’s Daughter
The Outsider
Broken
Lady of the Lake
Queen of Hearts
We Are Both
The Queen is Dead
The Evil Queen
The Cricket Game
Welcome to Storybrooke
Into the Deep
The Doctor
Child of the Moon
In the Name of the Brother
Tiny
Selfless, Brave, and True

Season 3

Nasty Habits
Going Home
Ariel
Think Lovely Thoughts
The Heart of the Truest Believer
Lost Girl
Quite a Common Fairy
The New Neverland
Dark Hollow
Save Henry
Good Form

Series Over All

Skin Deep
Manhattan
Land Without Magic
Desperate Souls
Nasty Habits
The Crocodile
The Return
And Straight on Till Morning
Second Star To The Right
Tallahassee
Pilot
Apple Red as Blood
Lacey
Going Home
7:15 AM
The Thing You Love Most
Snow Falls
Ariel
The Price of Gold
Red-Handed
The Heart is a Lonely Hunter
Miller’s Daughter
The Stable Boy
The Stranger
Heart of Darkness
Hat Trick
The Outsider
Think Lovely Thoughts
The Heart of the Truest Believer
Broken
Lost Girl
Lady of the Lake
Queen of Hearts
Quite a Common Fairy
The New Neverland
We Are Both
Dark Hollow
Fruit of the Poisonous Tree
The Queen is Dead
Save Henry
The Evil Queen
What Happened To Frederick
The Shepherd
The Cricket Game
Welcome to Storybrooke
Into the Deep
The Doctor
That Still Small Voice
Child of the Moon
In the Name of the Brother
Tiny
True North
Good Form
Dreamy
Selfless, Brave and True.

(that was hard)

"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"

[darkones1fan]

Season 1

1.Skin Deep

2.Heart of the thing you love most

3.Pilot

4.Land without magic

5.Heart of Darkness

6.Price of Gold (One of the best Mr. Gold episodes I think)

7.The Return (Can never watch it again though. THE FEELS!)

8.Desperate Souls

9.Snow Falls

10.The Shepard

11. Apple Red as Blood

12.Fruit of the Poisioness Tree.

13.That still small voice

14.The Stable Boy

15.Hat Trick (Sad ending)

16.Red Handed

17.True North

18.The Stranger

19.7:15 Am

20.The Heart of the Loney Hunter

21.Dreamy

22What happened to Fredrick

Season 2

1. Millers Daughter

2. Manhattan

3.Straight on till morning

4. The Cricket game.

5. Evil Queen

6. Second Star to the right.

7.Broken

8. Lacey (Mostly for Flashbacks)

9. The Crocodile.

10. The Queen of Hearts

11. The Outsider

12. Tallahasee

13. The Doctor (Would have been best of series if it were Doctor Who….Just saying)

14. Welcome to Storybrooke

15. We our both

16.In the Name of the Brother

17. Tiny

18. Child of the Moon

19.Lady of the Lake

20. Selfless Brave and True.

21.Into the deep.

22. The Queen is Dead

Season 3.

1. Going Home

2.The Heart of the Truest believer

3.Nasty Habits

4. Lost Girl

5. Think Lovely Thoughts (Man that ending though)

6.Dark Hallow

7. Ariel

8. Dark Hollow

9. The New Neverland

10 Save Henry

11 Good Form

12. Quiet a common fairy

Series overall list (Coming soon but not likely)

[obisgirl]

Season One

Pilot
Skin Deep
Snow Falls
The Shepherd
The Heart Is A Lonely Hunter
That Still Small Voice
Red-Handed
The Return
Heart Of Darkness
The Stable Boy
7:15 A.M.
An Apple Red As Blood
Hat Trick
What Happened To Frederick
A Land Without Magic
The Price Of Gold
Desperate Souls
The Thing You Love Most
Dreamy
Fruit Of The Poisonous Tree
True North
The Stranger

Season 2

And Straight On til’ Morning
Second Star to the Right
The Doctor
Tallahassee
Lady of the Lake
The Crocodile
Queen of Hearts
The Evil Queen
The Miller’s Daughter
Broken
Manhattan
The Queen is Dead
The Outsider
The Cricket Game
We Are Both
Into the Deep
Lacey
Welcome to Storybrooke
In the Name of the Brother
Child of the Moon
Tiny
Selfless, Brave and True

Season 3 (first half)

Going Home
Good Form
Quite a Common Fairy
Lost Girl
Ariel
The Heart of the Truest Believer
Dark Hollow
The New Neverland
Think Lovely Thoughts
Nasty Habits
Save Henry

[nonnie]

TOO MUCH work and thinking for me … I see the stories as a whole cannot dissect the entire story into little parts … each story adds to the whole.

NONNIE
.

[kfchimera]

I’ll echo what Nonnie wisely said 😛

 

 

 

“If I had a world of my own, everything would be nonsense. Nothing would be what it is, because everything would be what it isn't. And contrary wise, what is, it wouldn't be. And what it wouldn't be, it would. You see?” -- Lewis Carroll, Alice's Adventures in Wonderland & Through the Looking-Glass

[RumplesGirl]

Awwwww. Come on guys!

I really wanna see. It’s like a social experiment. I wanna see how different sets of fans view the TV show without it going debate-y.

For example: does it shock ANYONE that my top 7 episodes are all heavy Rumple?

"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"

[Killian Jones]

Ok I’m done with Season 1

1. A Land Without Magic
2. Pilot
3. Skin Deep
4. Desperate Souls
5. Snow Falls
6. 7:15am
7. Red-Handed
8. Hear of Darkness
9. Hat Trick
10. True North
11. Apple Red as Blood
12. The Heart is A Lonely Hunter
13. The Shepard
14. The Thing You Love Most
15. The Stranger
16. The Return
17. Price of Gold
18. Dreamy
19. The Stable Boy
20. What Happened to Frederick
21. That Still Small Voice
22. Fruit of the Poisonous Tree

I can really be talked into reordering the entire top 20

[Killian Jones]

Season 2 for Me

1. And Straight On ‘Til Morning
2. Queen of Hearts
3. Tallahassee
4. The Outsider
5. The Miller’s Daughter
6. Broken
7. The Crocodile
8. Manhattan
9. Second Start to the Right
10. Lady of the Lake
11. The Doctor
12. Lacey
13. Into the Deep
14. Child of the Moon
15. Welcome To Storybrooke
16. The Queen Is Dead
17. In The Name of The Brother
18. Selfless Brave and True
19. The Cricket Game
20. The Evil Queen
21. Tiny
22. We Are Both

 

Season 3A

1. Going Home
2. Think Lovely Thoughts
3. Good Form
4. Save Henry
5. Ariel
6. Dark Hollow
7. Nasty Habits
8. Lost Girl
9. Quite A Common Fairy
10. The Heart of the Truest Believer
11. The New Neverland

Series

1. Going Home
2. And Straight On ‘Til Morning
3. A Land Without Magic
4. Pilot
5. Skin Deep
6. Queen of Hearts
7. Tallahassee
8. Think Lovely Thoughts
9. Good Form
10. The Outsider
11. Desperate Souls
12. Save Henry
13. The Miller’s Daughter
14. The Crocodile
15. Snow Falls
16. 7:15am
17. Broken
18. Ariel
19. Dark Hollow
20. Nasty Habits
21. Red-Handed
22. Manhattan
23. Heart of Darkness
24. Lost Girl
25. Hat Trick
26. Second Star To The Right
27. The Lady of The Lake
28. True North
29. Quite A Common Fairy
30. The Heart of the Truest Believer
31. The Doctor
32. Lacey
33. The New Neverland
34. Apple Red As Blood
35. The Heart Is A Lonely Hunter
36. The Shepard
37. Into The Deep
38. Child of the Moon
39. The Thing You Love Most
40. The Stranger
41. The Return
42. Welcome To Storybrooke
43. The Queen Is Dead
44. In the Name of the Brother
45. Selfless Brave and True
46. The Cricket Game
47. The Price of Gold
48. The Evil Queen
49. Tiny
50. We Are Both
51. Dreamy
52. The Stable Boy
53. What Happened To Frederick
54. That Still Small Voice
55. Fruit of the Poisonous Tree

That was bloody difficult lol

[Killian Jones]

TOO MUCH work and thinking for me … I see the stories as a whole cannot dissect the entire story into little parts … each story adds to the whole. NONNIE
.

I agree I think that’s what made it so hard 🙁

[Author]

Posts