Favorite to Least Favorite Episodes Ranking

[ready_to_rumbelle]

Okay, since I’m too lazy to do all of it, I’ll make a top 5 and the 5 least favorites for seasons 1 and 2 and my overall ranking. So here we go…

Season 1: 

1. Skin Deep (duh 🙂 )

2. Pilot

3. A Land Without Magic

4. Desperate Souls

5. Snow Falls

… 18. Fruit of The Poisonous Tree

19. The Shepherd

20. True North

21. That Still Small Voice

22. Dreamy

Season 2:

1. Manhattan

2. The Miller’s Daughter

3. Crocodile

4. Tallahassee

5. The Evil Queen (but only because of the FBs)

… 18. Child of the Moon

19. In the Name of the Brother

20. Tiny

21. Welcome to Storybrooke

22. Selfless Brave and True

Doing a list for season 3 A was a bit more tricky. Right after its run Think Lovely Thoughts was my favorite but that changed during the hiatus, so it’s possible that the following list might change after the end of S3B 😛 but for now, that’s it:

1. Nasty Habits

2. Quite A Common Fairy

3. Lost Girl

4. Going Home

5. Think Lovely Thoughts

6. Dark Hollow

7. Save Henry

8. The Heart of the Truest Believer

9. The New Neverland

10. Ariel

11. Good Form

Overall:

1. Skin Deep

2. Pilot

3. Manhattan

4. A Land Without Magic

5. Nasty Habits

… 51. Good Form

52. Welcome to Storybrooke

53. That Still Small Voice

54. Dreamy

55. Selfless Brave and True

[MatthewPaul]

My updated ranking for Season 3 and the show overall, which has been edited into my previous post:

Season 3

Snow Drifts/There’s No Place Like Home
Going Home
New York City Serenade
Witch Hunt
Lost Girl
The Heart of the Truest Believer
Think Lovely Thoughts
Quite a Common Fairy
Nasty Habits
Ariel
A Curious Thing
Kansas
The Jolly Roger
Good Form
It’s Not Easy Being Green
Dark Hollow
The New Neverland
Save Henry
Bleeding Through
The Tower
Quiet Minds

Series Overall

A Land Without Magic
Snow Falls
Pilot
Skin Deep
7:15 A.M.
Snow Drifts/There’s No Place Like Home
Second Star to the Right
And Straight On til’ Morning
Queen of Hearts
The Miller’s Daughter
Manhattan
The Heart Is a Lonely Hunter
Hat Trick
The Thing You Love Most
Going Home
New York City Serenade
Witch Hunt
Lost Girl
Desperate Souls
The Stable Boy
An Apple Red as Blood
Lady of the Lake
Heart of Darkness
The Crocodile
Tallahassee
The Heart of the Truest Believer
Think Lovely Thoughts
Red-Handed
The Return
The Price of Gold
Quite a Common Fairy
Nasty Habits
Ariel
The Shepherd
A Curious Thing
Kansas
Broken
The Jolly Roger
We Are Both
Into the Deep
Good Form
The Stranger
The Doctor
The Queen is Dead
The Outsider
True North
It’s Not Easy Being Green
Dark Hollow
The New Neverland
Save Henry
Bleeding Through
That Still Small Voice
Fruit of the Poisonous Tree
The Cricket Game
The Evil Queen
What Happened to Frederick
Lacey
Dreamy
Welcome to Storybrooke
In the Name of the Brother
Child of the Moon
The Tower
Tiny
Quiet Minds
Selfless, Brave and True

[RumplesGirl]

Updated list with all of Season Three. (the S3 shows are in BOLD for full series)

Season 1

Skin Deep
Land Without Magic
Desperate Souls
The Return
Pilot
Apple Red as Blood
7:15 Am
The Thing You Love Most
Snow Falls
The Price of Gold
Red-Handed
The Heart is a Lonely Hunter
The Stable Boy
The Stranger
Heart of Darkness
Hat Trick
Fruit of the Poisonous Tree
What Happened to Frederick
The Shepherd
That Still Small Voice
True North
Dreamy

Season 2

Manhattan
The Crocodile
And Straight On Till Morning
Second Star to the Right
Tallahassee
Lacey
Miller’s Daughter
The Outsider
Broken
Lady of the Lake
Queen of Hearts
We Are Both
The Queen is Dead
The Evil Queen
The Cricket Game
Welcome to Storybrooke
Into the Deep
The Doctor
Child of the Moon
In the Name of the Brother
Tiny
Selfless, Brave, and True

Season 3

Nasty Habits
New York City Serenade
Going Home
Witch Hunt
Ariel
Think Lovely Thoughts
The Heart of the Truest Believer
Snow Drifts
There’s No Place Like Home
Lost Girl
Quite a Common Fairy
Kansas
A Curious Thing
It’s not Easy Being Green
Bleeding Through
The New Neverland
Dark Hollow
Save Henry
The Jolly Roger
The Tower
Good Form
Quiet Minds

Series Over All

Skin Deep
Manhattan
Land Without Magic
Desperate Souls
Nasty Habits
The Crocodile
The Return
And Straight on Till Morning
Second Star To The Right
Tallahassee
Pilot
Apple Red as Blood
Lacey
New York City Serenade
Going Home
7:15 AM
Witch Hunt
The Thing You Love Most
Snow Falls
Ariel
The Price of Gold
Red-Handed
The Heart is a Lonely Hunter
Miller’s Daughter
The Stable Boy
The Stranger
Heart of Darkness
Hat Trick
The Outsider
Think Lovely Thoughts
The Heart of the Truest Believer
Broken
Snow Drifts
There’s No Place Like Home
Lost Girl
Lady of the Lake
Queen of Hearts
Quite a Common Fairy
Kansas
A Curious Things
It’s Not Easy Being Green
Bleeding Through
The New Neverland
We Are Both
Dark Hollow
Fruit of the Poisonous Tree
The Queen is Dead
Save Henry
The Evil Queen
What Happened To Frederick
The Tower
The Shepherd
The Cricket Game
Welcome to Storybrooke
Into the Deep
The Doctor
That Still Small Voice
Child of the Moon
In the Name of the Brother
Tiny
True North
Good Form
Dreamy
Selfless Brave and True
Quiet Minds

"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"

[Killian Jones]

3B

Snow Drifts/ There’s No Place Like Home

New York City Serenade

A Curious Thing

Kansas

The Jolly Roger

Quiet Minds

Bleeding Through

It’s Not Easy Being Green

Witch Hunt

The Tower

 

[Keb]

If Belle’s in it and nobody dies, I generally like it. If Belle’s a major character and nobody dies, it’s one of my faves.

If Belle’s not in it but Rumple is, it’s probably a decent ep.

If Belle and Rumple are both missing, but the Jolly Roger’s around, it’s tolerable. I like that ship.

If there’s no Rumbelle and no boat…it’s filler. Unless Neal’s in it.

Keeper of Belle's Gold magic, sand dollar, cloaks, purple FTL outfit, spell scroll, library key, copy of Romeo and Juliet, and cry-muffling pillow, Rumple's doll, overcoat, and strength, and The Timeline. My spreadsheet: https://drive.google.com/file/d/0B6r8CySCCWd9R0RUNm4xR3RhMEU/view?usp=sharing

[Author]

Posts