- This topic has 263 replies, 19 voices, and was last updated 11 years, 3 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
Rumple, Emma, Snow
Charming, Hook, Regina
The issue I have with this arrangement is that Rumple, Emma, and Snow are lacking an experienced swordsman, and Regina gets both of them. If you have two swordsmen and two magicians, isn’t it better to ensure that each group gets one of each? Emma can handle a sword but no where near the level of Hook or Charming. She can do magic but not as well as Regina and Rumple. The same with Snow when it comes to fighting (plus she prefers her bow and arrow) and she doesn’t do magic at all. Also, with this arrangement there isn’t a whole lot of room for the type of conflict and drama as you would have if Regina and Snow were in the same group. It does give Charming and Hook the opportunity to be snarky but that’s about it.
[adrotate group="5"]"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"I can’t see Rumple and Hook being in the same group. They may have agreed to not try and kill each other, but that doesn’t mean they’re BFFs who’ll be able to cooperate.
Can’t see Regina working productively if paired with either of the “two idiots”. She doesn’t respect either of them or value their opinion on what should be done in any given situation. Emma she can work with, because they’ve just worked together to deactivate the failsafe.
Regina and Hook have teamed up before, and I can see them willing to work together again, even if he did leave her to be tortured.
Still reckon Hook and Emma will be paired up. PapaCharming might not like Hook getting too close to his daughter, but Emma would insist that she’s a big girl and can look after herself when it comes to Hook. And when it comes to Hook’s perspective, Emma is the only one of them he really knows or trusts at all, so he’d work best with her.
I most definitely think that whoever Rumple ends up grouped off with, he’s gonna ditch them to go on his solo suicide mission.
As for Rumple/Emma interaction to discuss Bae, while I would love some of that to happen, I really don’t think Rumple will be in the headspace to want to have that conversation. CC interviews all suggest that he’s gonna be in full on Dark One mode to get the job done. He won’t have time for emo discussions about his son. If Emma discusses Bae with anyone, I bet it’ll be Hook, who also wants to know what type of man the kid grew into.
I can also see Rumple not wanting to discuss Bae, especially with anyone who isn’t Belle, because it would be too painful for him. Rumple doesn’t deal with his grief and pain straight on, he buries it until it all becomes too much for him to handle at which point someone usually gets a caning.
All magic comes with a price!
Keeper of FelixAll these reasons we keep coming up with for why certain groups wouldn’t work makes me think they won’t be splitting up at all. Except Rumple, something tells me he’s going off on his own.
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"I think if they do split, the grouping that makes most sense is
Rumple, Snow, Charming
Regina, Hook, Emma
Regina and Rumple would be at each other’s throats, as would Rumple and Hook- plus as has been said, it would be best for each team to have someone with magic. Hook likes Emma and Regina tolerates her better than she does any of the others. The Charmings are the ones Rumple is least likely to want to kill. Emma would be included in that, but I think she needs to be there to keep Regina and Hook in check.
As for communicating they could use their guns to signal that they had found someone or since Rumble and Regina and pop in and out they can do that also.
Regina is suppose to show Emma magic so that is why I thought of the 3 teams instead of two.
I agree that the group of 6 will likely divide into 2 teams of 3:
Group 1: Hook – Emma – Regina
Group 2: David – Snow- Rumple
My main reason for thinking so is that spoiler that Lana, Jennifer, and Colin were filming together without the other three. My other reason for thinking so is there is power in numbers. 3 is greater than 2. Finally, I agree with everyone who said Hook and Rumple wouldn’t be on the same team, since they can barely tolerate once another, let alone rely on one another. Also, the Charmings have too much bad history with Regina.
As for Group 1, I think that the writers could be building up a “love triangle” but not necessarily the one most fans are hoping for. I happen to think that while Hook fancies Emma and she is attracted to him, the real love connection will build between Regina and Hook. The reason I think so is that Adam has heavily hinted that Regina will find her new love interest, and that her love possibly is already with her. Who else on the ship is the likeliest candidate? Well, Charming is a happily married man and Rumple’s true love, Belle, is safe and well. We know SQ isn’t going to happen (confirmed by Eddy), so the only eligible bachelor is Killian Jones.
Also, I don’t think Charming and Snow would split up. They’re going to stay together since they’ve been split up too much already over the last 2 seasons. It’s time for them to stand as a united team. However, I think’s it’s highly probably that Rumple would ditch them to go off on his own quest for revenge against PP and GOAT. Going off of what both Robert and Eddy said at CC about Mr. Gold’s quest:
Eddy Kitsis: “Rumple is prepared to die to save Henry, he is on a suicide mission, we will be seeing a whole new Mr. Gold.”
Rober Calyle: “Mr. Gold will be very dark and anyone that gets in his way of saving Henry better watch out.”
"That’s how you know you’ve really got a home. When you leave it, there’s this feeling that you can’t shake. You just miss it." Neal Cassidy
Yes, I agree that Rumpel probably not interested in talking about Bae–but Hook might be. I also think Rumpel would suggest the split Hook, Emma and Regina, so that he could be paired with Snow and Charming–with the plan to ditch them. He might also ditch them the moment they get to NL.
I do wonder though–if this is a suicide mission for Rumpel, does he not care about saving Henry? I mean, who exactly is going to take care of Henry if he says I don’t care about Emma, Regina, Charmings, let everyone else who loves Henry die? Does he think he will send Henry back to Belle? I am a wee bit puzzled there.
If Rumpel ditches them, then I am not sure the others would willingly split up 3 and 2. It might be the JR gets shipwrecked –we never know–or someone gets lost off the ship when it lands.
“If I had a world of my own, everything would be nonsense. Nothing would be what it is, because everything would be what it isn't. And contrary wise, what is, it wouldn't be. And what it wouldn't be, it would. You see?” -- Lewis Carroll, Alice's Adventures in Wonderland & Through the Looking-Glass
Kranen, be careful. I don’t know if that tweet with a picture counts as embedding Vancity’s work or not since it’s a picture that is attached to a tweet. But VCF has asked that no one embed his pictures, they must link directly to VCF’s site.
It’s OK, don’t worry about it 🙂
I do wonder though–if this is a suicide mission for Rumpel, does he not care about saving Henry? I mean, who exactly is going to take care of Henry if he says I don’t care about Emma, Regina, Charmings, let everyone else who loves Henry die? Does he think he will send Henry back to Belle?I am a wee bit puzzled there.
Even if Mr. Gold were to peel away from the others to save Henry, I think Henry would still be okay. For example, if Mr. Gold were to go head-to-head with PP and his minions, then it might give Henry just enough leeway to escape. Also, even if Mr. Gold were to go ahead of the group, the others would still be in pursuit of Henry, meaning the Charmings and/or Emma and her group would eventually find Henry. After all, the Charmings always find one another.
If Rumpel ditches them, then I am not sure the others would willingly split up 3 and 2.
I’m not sure that the Charmings would have much of a choice in that case. For instance, if the group of 6 first split into 2 teams of 3, then group 1 (Emma, Hook, and Regina) would go one way while group 2 (David, Snow, and Rumple) go another way. It could happen later that Rumple splits away from David and Snow, leaving them without their knowledge. Mr. Gold is unpredictable and acts on his own accord without the consent of others.
It might be the JR gets shipwrecked –we never know–or someone gets lost off the ship when it lands.
I suppose anything is possible in NL, according to Adam and Eddy (though Hook is an expert captain and has been sailing around NL for centuries).
"That’s how you know you’ve really got a home. When you leave it, there’s this feeling that you can’t shake. You just miss it." Neal Cassidy
The topic ‘First Day of Filming’ is closed to new replies.