Is "HER" using Greg because of "HIM"

[Snickerdoodle]

Here is my craziest crackpot theory ever. We know Tamara is HER. We know the producers have told us she is not magical. I have read many people write the idea that Tamara is Tiger Lily. Tiger Lily was in love with Peter Pan. If we assume PP is the “HIM” talked about tonight, and we know the shadow could bring boys or girls to Neverland, what is to keep us from thinking that perhaps he brought Tamara to Neverland? If Tamara is Tiger Lily and in love with PP or “HIM”. Perhaps the shadow is how she communicates with “HIM” and the “home office” in Neverland. That might explain the quick nature in which she received answers and instructions.

Of course, that would mean she is also playing Greg (which wouldn’t bother me). It also begs the question of whether or not Owen might have been taken to Neverland where he joined up with Pan and the Lost Boys and has basically been used by them all these years to bring us to where we are now. Perhaps the “HIM” saw his best chance of finding whatever he is looking for, was to keep Owen in the world where he was born and could grow up and be completely dedicated to finding this magic town he had seen and finding a way to get in. Perhaps the “HIM” found out he just had to wait 28 years. I mean how did he know about the trigger? no one knew about that, except HOOK. Perhaps there is more of that story too, since he seemed to want to appease “HIM” when turning Bae over.

So to sum up, if the “HIM” is PP and he found Owen as a young boy, and has been using Greg all these years just in hopes of finding Henry… wow, mind blown!

It will be blown even more if “HIM” is the original Dark One actually seeking out Rumple to get his powers back… and is related to the BF 😀

I would love to sit in on one of their writer’s sessions

[onceabeliever]

Here is my craziest crackpot theory ever. We know Tamara is HER. We know the producers have told us she is not magical. I have read many people write the idea that Tamara is Tiger Lily. Tiger Lily was in love with Peter Pan. If we assume PP is the “HIM” talked about tonight, and we know the shadow could bring boys or girls to Neverland, what is to keep us from thinking that perhaps he brought Tamara to Neverland? If Tamara is Tiger Lily and in love with PP or “HIM”. Perhaps the shadow is how she communicates with “HIM” and the “home office” in Neverland. That might explain the quick nature in which she received answers and instructions.

U have made me a believer, I think your on to something, if anything from your said should turn out, I love the theory that the shadow is the in between between Greg/Tamara and the home office .

Bravo!

[eastofthesun]

I think I love this theory!!

The only thing that makes me not sure about it is that Greg/Tamara claim magic is unholy and they want to cleans the worlds of magic, so either Tamara is lying and actually loves magic and collects it, because Peter is magical or “Him” is playing her to get what he wants…mmmm interesting

[Snickerdoodle]

If they hated magic so much, why would they use it themselves?

If “HiM” is playing “HER”, well then there is a lot of “playing” going round.

Haha, weirdest theory I have ever had. Came late last night in the excitement of reading the forums and a comment made in the chat room (don’t remember who that was.) 🙄

[LisaFromOH]

I really like this theory! It’s a little out there, but so is a lot of stuff that ends up happening on this show.

[Author]

Posts