- This topic has 18 replies, 8 voices, and was last updated 9 years, 6 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
Here’s my final question of the night for this thread:
Why didn’t the Apprentice go to Emma as well?
[adrotate group="5"]"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"Here’s my final question of the night for this thread: Why didn’t the Apprentice go to Emma as well?
I also was wondering about this. Lily is told pretty much everything but the location of Storybrooke, which in itself is odd. Meanwhile Emma is left to hopefully one day figure out who she is and stumble across the town in Maine where her parents have been all these years? Hm. Yeah, telling Emma may have changed the entire story, or at least a few good sized parts of it. Still, seems a bit muddled.
Keeper of Regina's book of magic
Here’s my final question of the night for this thread: Why didn’t the Apprentice go to Emma as well?
Two reasons come to mind.
1) He needed to go to Lily because she was absolutely alone and her fate had drastically changed as she was never meant to be sent out into our world. He was her course correction.
2) He did to go to Emma but indirectly by way of August. The DC had pretty much guaranteed Emma’s fate as the Saviour, but seeing as August had lost his way, that’s where The Apprentice had to intervene with a course correction.
Keeper of Pandora's Box & The Yellow Brick Road.
Regarding all the OP’s questions, I have no idea.
I hope they are answered within-show!
Keeper of Regina's bravery
2) He did to go to Emma but indirectly by way of August. The DC had pretty much guaranteed Emma’s fate as the Saviour, but seeing as August had lost his way, that’s where The Apprentice had to intervene with a course correction.
Seems plausible! Now we just need to see it…
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"Nitpick: Where did Lily get the necklace? Had the Apprentice snuck into our world and given it to her at some point? Because the last time she was near her mother, she was inside a freaking egg, so she didn’t take that necklace with her down the portal. (It’s a nitpick because I don’t expect we’ll ever get an answer, if they were gonna clarify it, they’d have done so in this ep.)
So her name is Lilith Page.
Her banishment was the reason the Author was placed inside the book.
That screams to me that she is instrumental in the Apprentice righting the Author’s wrongs.
Maybe she is the anti-savior because she is there to destroy the mess the Author created.
I have some major issues with the apprentice (who I am just going to refer to as SA = Sorcerers Apprentice, until we have an actual name) telling Lily her whole life story.
First, I understand he was probably trying to heal his own conscious. We saw at the beginning of the episode that he was upset and distraught by what Isaac forced him to do to baby dragon. However, telling a troubled young child that they are destined to be problematic and that they can’t fix themselves because they were magically charmed to be that way was probably not the best approach. We really should have gone more with a “u’re a wizard, Lily” moment with a simple explication of why she was different, rather than telling he she was doomed. Hagrid didn’t tell Harry he was doomed when he busted into the cabin on a rock! He kind of put this idea in her mind that she shouldn’t even try to fix herself because she was programmed to be this way. No wonder she wanted revenge.
Secondly, WHY DID YOU NOT FILL IN EMMA?! You can go find the anti-savior and set her on a path of distruction and revenge but you can’t stop by and say hey to the girl who is going to save everyone?! It’s like you want the villains to win.
Nitpick: Where did Lily get the necklace? Had the Apprentice snuck into our world and given it to her at some point? Because the last time she was near her mother, she was inside a freaking egg, so she didn’t take that necklace with her down the portal. (It’s a nitpick because I don’t expect we’ll ever get an answer, if they were gonna clarify it, they’d have done so in this ep.)
I was wondering that as well
So her name is Lilith Page.
Yes the last name is really not so subtle
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"
The topic ‘Lily and the Apprentice’ is closed to new replies.