Mermaid?

[Grimmsister]

They already have had Ariel on the show- Tiny is Ariel 😀 there is a post about that somewhere in here. Not to say there couldn’t be a nother one.

piratesmermaid: a question for you. How do we know that Tamara is not a mermaid ??
I think we have to keep this in spoiler bars, because she hasn’t been on the show yet and we’re not in a spoiler discussion forum.

[PriceofMagic]

Tiny and Ariel certainly have a lot of parallels. Perhaps Timy and Ariel will be true loves on this show.

All magic comes with a price!

Keeper of Felix

[aconite]

I agree with the Hook/Eric parallel and I think it could make an amazing flashback for Hook’s past. I really think they would follow the original story were Ariel falls in love with a prince/pirate(Hook) and pays her voice (or maybe some rare octopus ink?) to a mysterious “sea witch” which would totally be replaced by Rumple. Hook would get her up on his ship and they’d become friends. This could be a little before Killian and Milah meet so her running away with him could replace the Prince in the original story falling in love with another woman. Rumple would then come back and try and make a new deal for Ariel to kill Hook to become a mermaid again, but she decides against it and ultimately kills herself by throwing herself into the ocean, turning to foam. This would sort of distress Hook that she suddenly disappeared but would now have Milah exclusively…

*Corrected

Plus Holland Roden would make a perfect Ariel

[AtlanticaDream]

I think Britney Snow would be an awesome Ariel (I loved her with her red hair in Pitch Perfect)

Proud Keeper of the Dinglehoppers

[piratesmermaid]

So excited we got more info on the mermaids in the finale! And it looks like they’re evil too. I might like that twist, what do ya’ll think?

[MysteryKat25]

Seeing that snippet of information about Queen Athena (which I totally never noticed or have completely forgotten) I think it would show more why Hook has a thing against mermaids. If a pirate ship was even accidentally blamed for killing one you would think Ariel would hate him and have a more antagonistic approach toward him and all pirates and with good reason.

I have FishHook as my backup pairing because of the idea they’re both ruled by the sea, should both be from Neverland etc etc but a) now I’m thinking CS has a much bigger chance and that’s my first choice by a long shot and b) Hook was in NL for who knows how long – but a very long time – and if the mermaids hate pirates and Ariel has a good reason to do so, they could be enemies rather than anything remotely positive. If it does go the romantic route it would be a bit too romeo & juliet for me (not one of my faves) but could still be interesting.

I like the idea that they will tie Ariel into Mermaid Lagoon in Neverland. There are a couple of red-headed mermaids in Peter Pan lol. I just think that if they go with the Queen Athena killed by pirates, Ariel is most likely to join up with whoever is against Hook rather than with him. Otherwise they’ve had a couple hundred years (will seem even longer in Neverland) and in all that time Hook wasn’t able to give up his love of Milah or his desire to avenge her by killing Rumple. He gave all of that up to help Emma save her family and friends and immediately offered to help find Henry, even thought it meant going back to Neverland (he didn’t look overly happy about that) and allowed Rumple onto his ship with nothing more than a glare, even though he’s spent forever trying to kill him. He called a truce on that putting everything else first and that is HUGE. So I’m not sure how they could justify him spending a lot of time in NL potentially around Ariel and then say it’s a pairing that’s meant to be. Waiting to see how it plays out but I think she’ll either hate him or not have a lot to do with him not sure. She could pine for him but as I said above, but he had sooo much time there and didn’t give up Milah/revenge on Rumple for her in all that time so that would kinda bug me a little. Plus I still want Eric.

Keeper of Hook's Trenchcoat.

[AtlanticaDream]

I’m thinking now that if Ariel meets hook than it might be in present day neverland and they just knew of each other before, I think if they make Ariel go against the tendency of the other mermaids to be evil (sirens anyone?) it’d be really interesting but making Ariel evil too has the potential to be an awesome twist!

Frankly I’ll just be happy to see her finally, no matter what way, shape or form

Proud Keeper of the Dinglehoppers

[Author]

Posts