- This topic has 98 replies, 15 voices, and was last updated 7 years, 4 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
So what kind of new enchanted Forest is this? We’ve had wish realm ef but how did this new EF come into existence?? I’m not sure I understand their answers and it seems like Hook, Regina, and rumple are from new!EF??
Yup from new EF.
I fully believe JMO’s one episode is a quick shot of what’s going on in SB and it’s her with Hook and CS baby girl and then we rush forward to the new EF and what happens there.
Then it’s revealed that the baby girl is Rose’s character in the present and Henry’s half sibling and she’s away from her parents in SB.
So it’s kind of like the Hook from this EF is not her father the same way RH in WR was not Roland’s father.
[adrotate group="5"]So are there multiple versions of every single realm? Is there one for instance where Cora never took out her heart? With the wish realm there was an explanation for how it came to be, but are they saying that New!EF always existed and is just now intersecting our world because of whoever Anwar is playing?
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"So what kind of new enchanted Forest is this? We’ve had wish realm ef but how did this new EF come into existence?? I’m not sure I understand their answers and it seems like Hook, Regina, and rumple are from new!EF??
Yup that’s what I got. The only legit family Henry will have is Lucy and his wife. The other characters are not his family. They just look like it.
The only legit family Henry will have is Lucy and his wife. The other characters are not his family. They just look like it.
And that is the most confusing if this is real Hnery, how he is ok with all this, bc when he went to this new EF, he had his memories, so how is that is totally ok with him to marry a copy of a character he knew from SB and never return there? unless the seatle is the SB Hnery, but the new EF hnery is not the SB one, is his other version???
Which also again, bring the thing, Rumple has still to be connected to him in all versions, so that he can exist, Emma and Neal/Bae have to still be his parents and Rumple and Snowing still be grandparents, bc he would not look the same if they weren`t.
This is so confusing, although have to say would be less confusing, if since these are new versions, they would not show SB ever again and just left that version of those characters there, bc in that case what would happen, if this cinderella wre to meet SB cinderella, or SB hook meet this hook, or Rumple Sb meet this one and same with regina.
"I offended you with my opinion? Ha, you should hear the ones I keep to myself".
I still think you guys have it wrong. I really think Hook, Regina and Rumple in Seattle ARE the same ones we knew, but cursed. The new Cinderella isn’t a carbon copy of the old Cinderella, but an entirely different version altogether. It’s like how there are different adaptations of all these stories throughout the centuries, and they even compared it to the Disney animated films vs. their live action remakes. They even said they would explain what happened to Hook in episode 2.
I think this would also explain one of the biggest questions in the entire series: How were the events of stories Snow White occurring concurrently with 1970s/1980s Land Without Magic, when those stories had already existed in the Land Without Magic for a long time prior? The answer is that it wasn’t necessarily the 1st versions of those stories. Stories are retold and changed several times throughout history, after all. It’s a convoluted confusing mess, but I think there is some logic behind this.
I’d prefer the new versions, at least it would protect the happy endings instead of screwing with them.
I’d prefer the new versions, at least it would protect the happy endings instead of screwing with them.
That also would explain why they look the same age that they had in the past and what they were doing on the new EF to be caught by the new curse and be taken to Seatle, would not make sense the new curse get to SB and only take those 3 and at same time deage them.
"I offended you with my opinion? Ha, you should hear the ones I keep to myself".
Don't tell #MickeyMouse, but looks like @colinodonoghue1 made a new friend today at the #D23Expo! #OnceUponATime pic.twitter.com/2gCWaVKKnT
— ABC Publicity (@ABC_Publicity) July 16, 2017
At #D23Expo Talent Central, @colinodonoghue1, @AdamHorowitzLA, and Eddy are ready to take photos with Oncers! pic.twitter.com/Y2Rad10jEu
— Once Upon A Time (@OnceABC) July 16, 2017
I still think you guys have it wrong. I really think Hook, Regina and Rumple in Seattle ARE the same ones we knew, but cursed. The new Cinderella isn’t a carbon copy of the old Cinderella, but an entirely different version altogether. It’s like how there are different adaptations of all these stories throughout the centuries, and they even compared it to the Disney animated films vs. their live action remakes. They even said they would explain what happened to Hook in episode 2. I think this would also explain one of the biggest questions in the entire series: How were the events of stories Snow White occurring concurrently with 1970s/1980s Land Without Magic, when those stories had already existed in the Land Without Magic for a long time prior? The answer is that it wasn’t necessarily the 1st versions of those stories. Stories are retold and changed several times throughout history, after all. It’s a convoluted confusing mess, but I think there is some logic behind this.
I think if that’s the direction they are going then it’s fairly smart if really convoluted and messy at the same time. @dontstopbelievn was saying the same thing as I was reading her the news so you two might be on to something.
If there are multiple versions of the relams and stories it’s also potentially a way to give all the different fandoms a happy ending– so in one realm Neal never died. In another, SQ is canon. In another rumple gave up magic for belle early on, ECT ECT ECT.
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"“OK, so we need to make AdultHenry into Prince Charming 2.0, because then he’ll be just like his grandpa and folks will love that. #awwww.”
“But…we’ve run out of Princesses to pair a Prince Charming up with…”
“Maybe we can make a new, original Princess, we’ve made other orig-”
“I KNOW we just make a different Cinderella from an alternate Enchanted Forest! It’ll be like the multiverse in the DCTV shows, people love that stuff, so let’s do that, problem solved!”
Me: “This is not how you multiverse! Different versions of the same character from a parallel world, if they have the same name, will still have the same face too!” *headdesk*
The topic ‘OUAT at D23 2017 – Saturday, July 15th at 3:15pm (Pacific Time)’ is closed to new replies.