- This topic has 39 replies, 10 voices, and was last updated 10 years, 6 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
I guess Marian has been evil all along now, an agent of Nottingham sent to infiltrate mercenary bands and rival states.
[adrotate group="5"]Gaultheria's fanvids: http://youtube.com/sagethrasher
Yes strongly implied but we never saw it. So it’s now just speculation. I don’t intend to judge her over something that I don’t know. People tend to jump with pitchforks anytime they see an imagine that is out of context let alone something being strongly implied. I watch The Walking Dead and in that show if you don’t see someone die they ain’t dead so I am always questioning. To tell the truth I would rather see Robin with Marian since they have a child together same with Emma and Neal but they killed of Neal so there it is. For me she is hurting right now and that is all that matters. I don’t like triangles which is why I would rather she close him off completely maybe Henry can support her in this coming year now that she knows that she can love again so she does not end up an icicle queen.
I guess Marian has been evil all along now, an agent of Nottingham sent to infiltrate mercenary bands and rival states.
How did you get to that conclusion?
All magic comes with a price!
Keeper of FelixPoM, by that logic Belle shouldn’t be with Rumple because he was going to kill her father and was only stopped by Emma.
I guess Marian has been evil all along now, an agent of Nottingham sent to infiltrate mercenary bands and rival states.
How did you get to that conclusion?
They have to show that Regina is the right one for Robin. I think it’d be a good spy plot, too, with the Sheriff of Nottingham sent to extract his partner Agent Marian from danger once she’d accomplished her mission.
Gaultheria's fanvids: http://youtube.com/sagethrasher
PoM, by that logic Belle shouldn’t be with Rumple because he was going to kill her father and was only stopped by Emma.
Blame Regina for that one. Though it would have been nice to see Belle’s reaction to the revelation that Rumple had beat up her father. I’m guessing Belle does know though since she said Maurice had forgiven Rumple. Also when Rumple nearly killed Maurice, it was because he believed he had caused Belle to commit suicide whereas Belle was going to kill Marian just to make a point. So different motivation in those scenarios.
Also Rumple NEARLY killed Maurice, whereas Regina DID kill Marian. The two situations are similar but there are differences.
All magic comes with a price!
Keeper of FelixI will never buy the argument that he didn’t actually kill him so it’s okay. The intent was there. Just because he failed to kill the man doesn’t give him a pass for attempting it. Also, you blame Regina. Really? Did she hold a gun to his head? I’m sick and tired of the double standard between these two characters. You want to say that Robin shouldn’t be with Regina for killing Marian — something we don’t know actually happened and now doesn’t matter because it didn’t happen with the timeline change — but are happy to watch an extremely abusive relationship in the form of Belle and Rumple. I just don’t get it.
Yeah its Regina’s fault that Rumple beat Maurice cus Regina put the cane in his hand. Let’s not let Rumple take responsibility for any of his actions. And technically now Regina didn’t kill Marian where as Rumple still clobbered Maurice.
I will never buy the argument that he didn’t actually kill him so it’s okay. The intent was there. Just because he failed to kill the man doesn’t give him a pass for attempting it. Also, you blame Regina. Really? Did she hold a gun to his head? I’m sick and tired of the double standard between these two characters. You want to say that Robin shouldn’t be with Regina for killing Marian — something we don’t know actually happened and now doesn’t matter because it didn’t happen with the timeline change — but are happy to watch an extremely abusive relationship in the form of Belle and Rumple. I just don’t get it.
Yeah its Regina’s fault that Rumple beat Maurice cus Regina put the cane in his hand. Let’s not let Rumple take responsibility for any of his actions. And technically now Regina didn’t kill Marian where as Rumple still clobbered Maurice.
Regina described to Rumple in detail how Maurice had Belle tortured to the point where she committed suicide because she couldn’t take it any more. A lot of Rumple beating Maurice was because of Belle, because REGINA had told him a very detailed lie that haunted him. Rumple was WRONG for doing it but he wasn’t doing it to prove a point unlike REGINA planning to have Marian executed.
Also RumBelle isn’t abusive. See Screwball’s essay
Regina didn’t know she was dating the partner of a woman she had executed. She didn’t know that the reason Roland didn’t have a mother was because she murdered her. I feel sorry for Regina in that respect, because she had a chance to start fresh but her past has come back to bite her.
I wanted OQ to have obstacles, however this goes beyond an obstacle. They’ve not just brought Marian back, they brought back the executionee that Regina was going to have executed who just so happens to be Robin’s beloved wife.
Marian’s execution was going to be the next day, had Emma not been there, Marian would’ve stayed in the cell. She wouldn’t have escaped.All magic comes with a price!
Keeper of FelixNope. Don’t get me wrong I love Rumple and Regina equally. I cry when either one is hurt. Hence my username. But that doesn’t mean I turn a blind eye when they are at fault. Regina might have said those things about what happened to Belle but everyone needs to take responsibility for the actions they take including Rumple. He beat Maurice, Belle’s father. That was his doing, given Maurice is an ass himself and actions where derived from anger Regina caused, Rumple beat Maurice not Regina that was his actions by himself and he hasn’t even apologize for it even now, knowing that it wasn’t true. Everyone gives Regina slack and want her to apologize, which she has actually started to do and where the Heck are his apologies. Also no matter what you say to me I will keep doubt open on if she ever did kill Marian until I actually see it. Sorry not really sorry, it’s called tough love.
The topic ‘OutlawQueen Love Triangle’ is closed to new replies.