Paradoxes, Paradoxes what has been missed?

[Hook’s Girl]

2) Hook met Snow White in the enchanted forest. Wouldn’t that screw up the timeline for season two. Why didn’t Snow recognize Hook from the Enchanted Forest after she and Emma got sucked into the hat. Meeting him literally resulted in her being burned alive.

Remember that Rumple put Hook & Emma under a spell where they didn’t look like themselves so that Snow, Charming, Red & Regina won’t recognized them as Hook & Emma when meeting them in the future.

Hook may not killed the guards. Just injured them badly.

[Hook’s Girl]

1. Belle has seen Emma and Hook (I am assuming that a forgetting potion will have taken care of that)

Yeah, I bet Rumple gave Belle a memory potion before he showed up in front of Emma again and then drank memory potion himself.

Nothing is impossible on OUAT. Everything has a way of repeating itself. Keeper of the Keeper tread: https://oncepodcast.com/forums/topic/official-keeper-thread-3/#post-217924

[Hook’s Girl]

So, is it just me? Did anyone see where Graham would have fit in the finale? They said it would be obvious, but I’m thinking I need something to hit me over the head to see it.

I think he would have fit in as the Black Guard standing on the balcony when Snow went over the wall. Maybe he wouldn’t have shot after her, like the actual guard did. Or he could have been the guard who was protecting the prison cell. He could have freed Emma like he did her father in 1×22, would have been a nice parallel.

Nothing is impossible on OUAT. Everything has a way of repeating itself. Keeper of the Keeper tread: https://oncepodcast.com/forums/topic/official-keeper-thread-3/#post-217924

[truidia]

Hooks Girl: He put them under the disguisy spell just before the ball. Hook still looked like Hook when he hired Snow to steal the ring, otherwise Smee wouldn’t have recognized him with his changing vests.

PLOT HOLE!!!

[Hook’s Girl]

Interesting. Guess I was looking at a different scene.

Observation – In “Skin Deep”, you can see Hook’s hand on the pedestal left of the huge glass door cabinet in the great hall of the Dark Castle. In both great hall scenes in these episodes, you can see the same pedestal but Hook’s hand isn’t there. It’s missing. It may even look like there isn’t anything on the pedestal. The way Hook was looking around, if it was there, Hook would have seen it. That would have been an interesting conversation…

Nothing is impossible on OUAT. Everything has a way of repeating itself. Keeper of the Keeper tread: https://oncepodcast.com/forums/topic/official-keeper-thread-3/#post-217924

[Killian Jones]

So, is it just me? Did anyone see where Graham would have fit in the finale?  They said it would be obvious, but I’m thinking I need something to hit me over the head to see it.

 

I thought it was obvious he was the guard that Regina was talking too when she steps on the troll bug.

Hooks Girl: He put them under the disguisy spell just before the ball. Hook still looked like Hook when he hired Snow to steal the ring, otherwise Smee wouldn’t have recognized him with his changing vests.
PLOT HOLE!!!

 

That’s why he was hiding in the shadows on his ship so she wouldn’t get a good look at him.

[SaraTheHLess]

Here’s one that hasn’t been mentioned yet, Hook stopped Smee from killing a mouse/rat. As we already know, many of these are people in the EF.

Also, could just be due to the cold weather BUT, amongst Emma’s borrowed clothes was a pair of gloves. Rumple said he got them back before they were missed but….did he, really…or did someone just end up in an urn in a vault and not need them?

Edit: Nix that, Elsa emerges from the urn with a pretty sweet pair of baby blue gloves…then again, Rumple does like to dress people with magic…

"The Laws (of Magic) never bothered me anyway."

[JML]

“That’s why he was hiding in the shadows on his ship so she wouldn’t get a good look at him.”

Also why he had Smee bring her on board instead of getting her himself.

[JML]

Here’s one that hasn’t been mentioned yet, Hook stopped Smee from killing a mouse/rat. As we already know, many of these are people in the EF.

Perhaps.  But we don’t know whether Smee would have successfully killed the rat.  Given a battle between Smee and the rat, I’d have to go with the rat.

[Killian Jones]

Also why he had Smee bring her on board instead of getting her himself.

 

Exactly!

[Author]

Posts