Robin

[shiffydiffy]

Is it at all possible that Robin appearing in the Fake Universe is part of David’s wish? David wished that the evil queen gets what she deserves. Since Regina is connected tot he evil queen, I wonder if that wish could have fallen on her as well, and given her back Robin, or even just a fake one.

[sierraleone]

I was thinking the same think. Thought obviously the separate halfs can be treated different as far as wishes are concerned, since EQ didn’t end up in the Alternate Universe. But maybe Genie wishes only affects the “prime” doppleganger? However the process determines who is prime, it pretty clear it is Regina.

It is either take, and/or somehow Gideon was able to ride on the back of that wish somehow 😀

[RumplesGirl]

Is it at all possible that Robin appearing in the Fake Universe is part of David’s wish? David wished that the evil queen gets what she deserves. Since Regina is connected tot he evil queen, I wonder if that wish could have fallen on her as well, and given her back Robin, or even just a fake one.

Quote

I think there’s a case to be made that when the EQ got what she deserved (turned into a snake), Regina got what she deserved (Robin). The issue is that this is clearly NOT Robin. At least not the Robin that Regina loved as of two weeks ago.

"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"

[TheWatcher]

Regina got what she deserved (Robin). The issue is that this is clearly NOT

Also, shouldn’t Marian still be alive in this AU? I hope they mention this. Anyway, here is a copy/paste of what I am thinking about RH, EQ, and the wish charming made. It contains spoilers.

So here’s what I think. Charming made the wish with the intent of EQ getting punished for all her crimes, but his wording “to get what she deserves” is so vague that he probably should have been more specific. So the EQ is going to get what she deserves, which in OUAT logic is going to be….a happy ending….redemption…and love. This is where fake RH is going to come in as well as fake FTL and even fake henry. EQ, I speculate, at some point in this story is going to be forced to help the heroes and turn over a new leaf. She will reunite with Robin and go to live in the newly made FTL where she and he will raise Prince Henry and be rulers of the EF. I think this will happen because it would not be right to have real Regina live happily ever after with Fake!Robin. He’s not the real RH, not the one she knew and went through so much with, he is a copy. At least with EQ going off with him, its okay because shes not really real either. There has to be a reason for the scene at the start of the episode to take place with EQ at RH’s grave, talking about how she *used* to love him. I think its all foreshadowing. The fake realm being created, RH popping back up, Henry being alive in the realm despite all logic.

"I could have the giant duck as my steed!" --Daniel Radcliffe
Keeper Of Tamara's Taser , Jafar's Staff, Kitsis’s Glasses , Ariel’s Tail, Dopey's Hat , Peter Pan’s Shadow, Outfit, & Pied Cloak,Red Queen's Castle, White Rabbit's Power To World Hop, Zelena's BroomStick, & ALL MAGIC

[onceaholic]

No, Marian would be dead because in WWW EQ probably would have killed her.

 

I have answered the question as to why Robin was fate rather than the wish on a different thread.

Keeper of Regina's bravery

[sierraleone]

No, Marian would be dead because in WWW EQ probably would have killed her.

Or Rumple didn’t let Robin get away with stealing that medicine for Marian.

[Ariana Miller]

Is it at all possible that Robin appearing in the Fake Universe is part of David’s wish? David wished that the evil queen gets what she deserves. Since Regina is connected tot he evil queen, I wonder if that wish could have fallen on her as well, and given her back Robin, or even just a fake one.

Quote

I like this theory.

I don’t buy that the alternate universe is “fake.”  Regina kept saying that, but there’s no indication that it’s fake.  If it were fake, then it should have just “dissolved” or something as soon as Emma realized who she was.  Not that sweeping Emma off to an alternate reality was the most logical way to grant that wish, but anyway…

I think it’s a new world that was created as a result of the wish, and the people there are just as real as anyone in any other world, with all of their memories, etc.  And they will go on living and being real from here on out.

[Author]

Posts