- This topic has 16 replies, 10 voices, and was last updated 10 years, 1 month ago by
.
-
Posts
-
From what I’ve seen of the promo for 4:03 I think it’s safe to say that Marian will be in a lot of trouble in this ep. However, I don’t think they’ll get rid of her that quickly, since she seems to be vital in keeping Regina and Robin separate, and I doubt they’ll want her out of the way so soon into season 4.
So, I believe that Marian will be saved by Robin after her heart has frozen: by him giving her half of his heart. I know that only couples who are under the influence of True Love can do this (or so it would seem), and since Robin has declared his lack of love for Marion this would make the whole ‘sharing-a-heart’ thing seem unlikely to work, but I have a theory that the love doesn’t necessarily have to be between the couple who share the heart.
What if it is Robin’s love for his son that enables him to share a heart with Marian? Because who would stand by and watch as the mother of their child died, when there was something they could do to prevent their death?
Any thoughts?
[adrotate group="5"]"so there’s this new show….."
"there’s lesbians in it"From what I’ve seen of the promo for 4:03 I think it’s safe to say that Marian will be in a lot of trouble in this ep. However, I don’t think they’ll get rid of her that quickly, since she seems to be vital in keeping Regina and Robin separate, and I doubt they’ll want her out of the way so soon into season 4. So, I believe that Marian will be saved by Robin after her heart has frozen: by him giving her half of his heart. I know that only couples who are under the influence of True Love can do this (or so it would seem), and since Robin has declared his lack of love for Marion this would make the whole ‘sharing-a-heart’ thing seem unlikely to work, but I have a theory that the love doesn’t necessarily have to be between the couple who share the heart. What if it is Robin’s love for his son that enables him to share a heart with Marian? Because who would stand by and watch as the mother of their child died, when there was something they could do to prevent their death? Any thoughts?
Hmmm….In a sense that maybe it…but Fate would still want Marian dead, and if she shares a heart with Robin, that would kill Robin too….so Regina may split her heart with Robin to save him. Therefore…Regina and Robin still have a happy ending because they’ll be sharing her heart.
"If you go as far as you can see...you will then see enough to go even further." - Finn Balor
Hmmm….In a sense that maybe it…but Fate would still want Marian dead, and if she shares a heart with Robin, that would kill Robin too….so Regina may split her heart with Robin to save him. Therefore…Regina and Robin still have a happy ending because they’ll be sharing her heart.
Maybe fate decided to put Emma in the dungeon with Marian, knowing she would save her and ruin Regina’s happiness? Regina seems to think that fate is out to get her, and that Marian was a part of fate’s plan to undermine her only shot at True Love to come along since Daniel…
"so there’s this new show….."
"there’s lesbians in it"So, I believe that Marian will be saved by Robin after her heart has frozen: by him giving her half of his heart. I know that only couples who are under the influence of True Love can do this (or so it would seem), and since Robin has declared his lack of love for Marion this would make the whole ‘sharing-a-heart’ thing seem unlikely to work, but I have a theory that the love doesn’t necessarily have to be between the couple who share the heart.
I know Robin said his feelings for Regina are real, but I don’t recall him saying he didn’t love his wife. I think it’s more complicated than that, since in this instance, I think it’s possible for Robin to love two women at the same time. His love for Marian was very evident in the flashback we saw of when Robin saved her life with the fairy wand. I think Robin probably will always have a place in his heart for Marian, but that he has had to move on since her death and that he developed real feelings for Regina. But his honor, as well as his cherished memories of Marian, will help him keep his marital vow to her. Part of Regina’s continued growth towards being a hero may be realizing Robin is right to choose his wife. Regina may also finally start westling with a guilty conscience and become sorry for killing people like Marian in the past. Marian may die again the present day, but I don’t think Regina will have anything to do with it, and I think it would happen towards the end of the season. But if Marian lives, Regina’s happiness may not even include Robin, since in the end, she may realize a happy life with Henry is enough.
"I'm not bossy. I'm the queen." Elsa
It’s a bit complicated, and almost mean spirited that RH splits his heart not out of love for her but love for their son. Personally, I think its going to be the good old fashioned TLK that revives her. And this is going to further push Regina to wanting to get her own happy ending through changing fate.
"I could have the giant duck as my steed!" --Daniel Radcliffe
Keeper Of Tamara's Taser , Jafar's Staff, Kitsis’s Glasses , Ariel’s Tail, Dopey's Hat , Peter Pan’s Shadow, Outfit, & Pied Cloak,Red Queen's Castle, White Rabbit's Power To World Hop, Zelena's BroomStick, & ALL MAGICIt’s a bit complicated, and almost mean spirited that RH splits his heart not out of love for her but love for their son. Personally, I think its going to be the good old fashioned TLK that revives her. And this is going to further push Regina to wanting to get her own happy ending through changing fate.
I think this sounds just about right.
On the whole, I’m not thrilled with the idea of killing Marian (cause fate) just for OQ to work. It leaves a bitter taste in my mouth.
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"Hmmm….In a sense that maybe it…but Fate would still want Marian dead, and if she shares a heart with Robin, that would kill Robin too….so Regina may split her heart with Robin to save him. Therefore…Regina and Robin still have a happy ending because they’ll be sharing her heart.
Maybe fate decided to put Emma in the dungeon with Marian, knowing she would save her and ruin Regina’s happiness? Regina seems to think that fate is out to get her, and that Marian was a part of fate’s plan to undermine her only shot at True Love to come along since Daniel…
Then why is Fate still trying to kill Marian? First Marshamallow, now a Frozen Heart Let’s face it…it was that woman’s fate to die! And when Emma screwed it up, Fate has decided to play Final Destination with Marian, to kill her by whatever means necessary!
"If you go as far as you can see...you will then see enough to go even further." - Finn Balor
Then why is Fate still trying to kill Marian? First Marshamallow, now a Frozen Heart Let’s face it…it was that woman’s fate to die! And when Emma screwed it up, Fate has decided to play Final Destination with Marian, to kill her by whatever means necessary!
You could be right, but I still think it’s FAR too early to be killing Marian, since she kinda needs to be… ‘in the way’, for lack of a better term.
Besides, all the things you’ve named could equally be turned on their heads to show that fate doesn’t want Marian dead, since she was saved by Emma and then (just in the nick of time) by Regina.
"so there’s this new show….."
"there’s lesbians in it"On the whole, I’m not thrilled with the idea of killing Marian (cause fate) just for OQ to work. It leaves a bitter taste in my mouth.
I agree. Robin can still play an important part in Regina’s life, being the one that enabled her to open her heart to love again, however, I would prefer Regina to find someone different whose wife she didn’t murder.
All magic comes with a price!
Keeper of FelixYou could be right, but I still think it’s FAR too early to be killing Marian, since she kinda needs to be… ‘in the way’, for lack of a better term.
She’s always been in the way, since she and Robin met. Fate wanted Robin and Regina together, but Regina was chicken, so fate was all, “Fine be that way, your punishment is being the one to kill the one who took your place when no one should be around to take your place.” The only way Marian gets out alive is if she and Robin split up, simply because she’s in the way because pixie dust fate says so, so there’s no getting around it, one way or the other she needs to be removed from the equation.
If they’re gonna use Frozen logic, it’s not even a TLK, it’s just an act of TL. Roland could provide either of those.
I think this whole situation is a setup to prove that Robin doesn’t love Marian the same way any more, (which I don’t really like because it’s kind of a morbid way to prove it which would leave a nasty aftertaste IMO, better to just have him come to the realisation in his own time instead of, “LOLz you don’t have TL no more coz your kiss FAILED”).
The topic ‘Saving Marian’ is closed to new replies.