Snow & ….David?????

[surayya]

Ok, so I just got finished re-watching Broken (I wont lie- for the 3rd time 😉 ) & I noticed how Charming/James calls Snow,Snow but she on at least 2 occasions (in the sheriffs office, when he say’s the Wraith is Regina’s problem & again when she calls out to him in the court house after pouring alcohol over the railing) Calls James, David?????

I’m a bit confused, shouldn’t she be calling him James now???

I’m kind of torn on this because its not like H&K to mess up with something like this, but I’m also not sure why Snow would still be calling James by his cursed name unless she was a bit off with him for some reason 😕

Thoughts anyone?

[Killian Jones]

@Surayya wrote:

Ok, so I just got finished re-watching Broken (I wont lie- for the 3rd time 😉 ) & I noticed how Charming/James calls Snow,Snow but she on at least 2 occasions (in the sheriffs office, when he say’s the Wraith is Regina’s problem & again when she calls out to him in the court house after pouring alcohol over the railing) Calls James, David?????

I’m a bit confused, shouldn’t she be calling him James now???

I’m kind of torn on this because its not like H&K to mess up with something like this, but I’m also not sure why Snow would still be calling James by his cursed name unless she was a bit off with him for some reason 😕

Thoughts anyone?

Well when Charming is with Henry in Snow’s place he says that “Emma and Mary Margaret are alive” I think they’re just gonna use both names interchangeably. Either that or maybe David is his real name remember James was actually his brother’s name

[faux pax]

Well think about it this way, they have the memories of both lifetimes so Snow has spent just as much time being MM as she had being Snow. Charming on the other hand was asleep for all but a few months so he’s a lot less of David then Charming. Charming will always think of his wife as Snow, but Snow is just as comfortable thinking in Storybrook terms then FTL. Charming referred to her as MM because he was talking to Henry, who only really knew her as MM outside of the pages of his book. (if any of that made any sense).

[Killian Jones]

@Faux Pax wrote:

Well think about it this way, they have the memories of both lifetimes so Snow has spent just as much time being MM as she had being Snow. Charming on the other hand was asleep for all but a few months so he’s a lot less of David then Charming. Charming will always think of his wife as Snow, but Snow is just as comfortable thinking in Storybrook terms then FTL. Charming referred to her as MM because he was talking to Henry, who only really knew her as MM outside of the pages of his book. (if any of that made any sense).

That’s why it’s all gonna be tricky with them going back and forth on the names not saying I don’t like it but I just think it’s gonna be funny

[faux pax]

We’ll get used to it. Besides, if they use them interchangeably, then so can’t we. I don’t know about you but i wasn’t looking forward to having to write Snow/MM every time I got on the Forum. 😆

[Killian Jones]

@Faux Pax wrote:

We’ll get used to it. Besides, if they use them interchangeably, then so can’t we. I don’t know about you but i wasn’t looking forward to having to write Snow/MM every time I got on the Forum. 😆

Yeah I was already interchanging the names on here before anyway

[surayya]

@steliokontos1 wrote:

Well when Charming is with Henry in Snow’s place he says that “Emma and Mary Margaret are alive” I think they’re just gonna use both names interchangeably. Either that or maybe David is his real name remember James was actually his brother’s name

I thought that was because Henry has ONLY know EVERYONE by their cursed names.
I knew they’d use both names for everyone for a while, but I just didnt expect it to be so one sided between Snow & Charming I guess 😮

Good point with James name- but he told Snow it was James in FTL & that is what she called him in all the FTL flashbacks when she wasn’t calling him Charming during S1 …so yeah 😕

@Faux Pax wrote:

Well think about it this way, they have the memories of both lifetimes so Snow has spent just as much time being MM as she had being Snow. Charming on the other hand was asleep for all but a few months so he’s a lot less of David then Charming. Charming will always think of his wife as Snow, but Snow is just as comfortable thinking in Storybrook terms then FTL. Charming referred to her as MM because he was talking to Henry, who only really knew her as MM outside of the pages of his book. (if any of that made any sense).

Umm, but doesn’t that thinking work both ways 😕 David was John Doe until a few mths ago, so he’s much less David, than James/Charming ever was + David was the one who hurt her most while James saved her/brought her back & battled with her for their kingdom 😕 😆
I suppose they could swing that one either way 😉 I’ll get used to it- I just didn’t expect 2 true lovers not to use their original/true names with one another

[Killian Jones]

@Surayya wrote:

[

I thought that was because Henry has ONLY know EVERYONE by their cursed names.
I knew they’d use both names for everyone for a while, but I just didnt expect it to be so one sided between Snow & Charming I guess 😮

Good point with James name- but he told Snow it was James in FTL & that is what she called him in all the FTL flashbacks when she wasn’t calling him Charming during S1 …so yeah 😕

When they first met he said his name was James but at that point they had just met so maybe that’s why he said that at first. I think this season Snow will meet Charming’s mother though and we’ll find out his real name for sure probably during this meeting. We haven’t seen much of what happens after legendary kiss and the wedding so maybe Snow started calling Charming by his real name after?

[bluerose]

This confused me too. Yes, they have memories of both their fairy tale land and Storybrooke lives, but Snow was overly excited to see James when the curse broke and called him “Charming.” Maybe there are underlying issues that make her view him as “David” for now.

[Josephine]

Well, Eddie and Adam have addressed the question of what Charming’s real name is by stating “keep watching”. So evidently it’s something important. Even Regina called him David and acknowledged the fact that Charming was an imposter. So maybe she ended up giving him his shepherd’s name. She’s twisted and might think it’s funny that the powerful Charming is once again known by his peasant name.

I think it’s funny that Eddie and Adam refuse to tell us Mr. Gold’s first name, too. They had the same response of “keep watching”. I just want to know both of their real names.

Keeper of Rumplestiltskin's and Neal's spears and war paint and crystal ball.

[Author]

Posts