- This topic has 54 replies, 17 voices, and was last updated 11 years, 11 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
By taking the money from Emma he made sure that she grew up with means of obtaining her own money and not
Just have it given to her. If August gave her the money then she would know that Neal still cared for her and she would want to find him.[adrotate group="5"]I didn’t like August after The Stranger and now, I really do not like him. I had a thought if August is still a wooden puppet in Storybrooke and confronts Emma about what he did, she should have fire handy. But wood burns.
If August gave her the money then she would know that Neal still cared for her and she would want to find him.
As true as that may be, that’s not why he kept it. If you pay attention to the way Eion played it, you know he was just trying to justify it to himself. And besides if Emma knew that Neal still cared for her, it would make their reunion too easy… 😉
@obisgirl wrote:
I didn’t like August after The Stranger and now, I really do not like him. I had a thought if August is still a wooden puppet in Storybrooke and confronts Emma about what he did, she should have fire handy. But wood burns.
This made me think… if August was so desperate for Emma to believe in the curse… instead of saying: “hey, I was the boy who found you! I’m Pinoccio!”, saying the truth would help more, something like: “You know, I was ‘friend’ of Neal, he believed, this is how it all happened…” Maybe keeping some details -as, 20 000$ or “he left you because I ask him to” – but I think it would be an unanswerable proof in her eyes.
Besides, it gives hope and motivation to Emma, as Neal was still waiting for her to broke the curse to meet her again. Even if she doesn’t want him in her live after all, at least she would want an explanation.And if Emma goes crazy and kill August in the proccess to broke the curse, bad luck Pinoccio: at least you honored your promise.
I really think that the show is setting Neal and Emma up to be OTL’s (god, i hope so). Ignore the keepsakes they both have kept, Neal waited for TEN YEARS for that postcard and even after getting sent to prison and believing Neal took off with the money, Emma still spent two years in Tallahassee looking for him.
And they were so close to each other, one in Boston, the other in NYC. That’s only a 4 hour drive apart. So close, and yet so far.
@bfilipe wrote:
August gave her the money then she would know that Neal still cared for her and she would want to find him.
First of all, August kept that money because it was a temptation and apparently he’s bad at saying no.
Second of all, even without 20 grand in her pocket, Emma still went looking for Neal when she got out.
@Schmacky wrote:
@bfilipe wrote:
August gave her the money then she would know that Neal still cared for her and she would want to find him.
First of all, August kept that money because it was a temptation and apparently he’s bad at saying no.
Second of all, even without 20 grand in her pocket, Emma still went looking for Neal when she got out.
Which is why Emma stayed for two years in Talahassee she was hoping he’d be there. August took the cash for not her reason but to take a trip to Phuket!
If he was truly her “guardian angel”, “big brother”, when he already found her, why not wait till she got out of jail and took care of her? I take that he couldn’t full fill his promise taking care of her when he was 7, but at that time, he was freakin 26-28. Why didn’t he full fill his destiny as her guidance? His father bargained to get him to this world just for him to do the thing that Snow+Charming didn’t have the change to do: take care of the savior. He didn’t seem to care about breaking the curse as he claimed to be. He stole the money and ran to Phuket. Not until years later, when Emma finally arrived to SB, his legs went wack, and he started to come to SB to did the lame *** job. and it wasn’t succeed. She believed in the curse because of Henry 😡
@bfilipe wrote:
By taking the money from Emma he made sure that she grew up with means of obtaining her own money and not
Just have it given to her. If August gave her the money then she would know that Neal still cared for her and she would want to find him.It’s good to see people on here do have a brain. Not to mention, the last thing you do for your prison pals, especially ones locked up for stealing, is send them money through the mail. They would have been even more suspicious of her, having 20 grand sent to her in the mail. And, we still don’t know if August did indeed steal the money, or maybe he just hid it for her, in case of a rainy day.
The topic ‘The BASH Pinocchio/August Thread!’ is closed to new replies.