- This topic has 12,956 replies, 132 voices, and was last updated 7 years, 11 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
My crack theory is that Bae never should have left the EF. He blames the EF forest for his misery in life because magic exists in the EF, but LEAVING the EF is what really caused his life to be miserable. Bea’s second chance is returning to the EF where he belong’s. Bae’s TL has never been Emma – there whole relationship was orchestrated by Pan. If Bae was never supposed to leave the EF, he True Love is still IN the EF. Now that Bae has spent time in other places and is being sent back to the EF, he has a 2nd chance to see what life is really like there – without being clouded by the judgement of a pre-teen who feels like his father is choosing power and magic over him. He has the opportunity to act like a Fairy Tale hero himself. I am wondering if one of the reasons Hook is sent back for Emma and not Neal is that Neal needs to accomplish something in the EF in order to get his 2nd chance. It could even be his 2nd chance to rescue his father in the EF since he was unsuccessful the first time.
I personally don’t think this is as “crack” as you think 🙂
I too found it interesting that his “Believe in Second Chances” poster was released before this episode – the episode where he lost his father.
I agree that his journey is to go back to being Bae – but that can’t happen without Rumple. We’ve all said at some stage that Neal’s journey this season is not about Emma, it’s about Rumple. I definitely think the two are intertwined, much like you’re saying.
I think that Neal has told Killian to bring Emma to his apartment. That’s the only explanation for why they would be there. It doesn’t matter IMO what Neal thinks – that Emma may not respond well to him – because he’s still not fighting for her. I also think that Neal is going to go on a rescue mission to #SaveRumple lol, because neither have been seen filming. Neal has only gotten EF scenes but we KNOW that they’re coming back to SB. So yeah, I think that Neal is fighting for Rumple, not Emma. I could be wrong but that’s what I’m thinking at the moment.
[adrotate group="5"]Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
Colin makes me OBSESS over CS. I am a grown, happily married woman with 2 kids and Colin as my phone screen saver… I didnt even do that when i was young and single. …
I’m happily married with a baby girl. Join the club ! 😉
My tumblr page is http://cs-in-tn.tumblr.com/
After the events of home I think it’s quite clear that Hook and Emma are true loves and we’re gonna see it.
Just think guys whatever the reason that Hook was the one to appear they planned it. We’re gonna see everything that happened within the year he was away from Emma.
I’m willing to bet he believes it’s true love because it’s likely he had to use some kind of magic or pixie dust to find her.
Regardless this is it, this is the story.
The triangle has officially died.
@Jennifer So you and I are kindred spirits!! You can add me to the club of happily married grown women with children who have Hook as their screen saver!!
And yes, Colin does ‘own’ Hook. In interviews he is kind of shy or quieter and more reserved – nothing like Hook. There is obviously truth to it when he says that when he gets that leather coat on he becomes Hook.
I never really cared about Emma much until Hook came along. I mean I didn’t dislike her but she was always just kind of ‘there’ for me. And I honestly could not picture her in a relationship with anyone until Hook showed up then – WOW!! I couldn’t wait for any and every CS scene from that point on.
Never knew who Colin was before, no idea if I would like him in anything else but, as Hook, I am sold!!!
I just want to restate I am not on this shipping stuff, I prefer Emma with someone her own age if she needs to have a man. But I think just finding her family Snow and David could be Emma’s Happy Ending not everyone has to have a man to make you happy.
I just can’t stand that guy that plays Neal if they had someone else playing his part that had a personality or some emotion I might feel different about Neal but for all intentional propose I guess Hook is better then Neal !!!
After the events of home I think it’s quite clear that Hook and Emma are true loves and we’re gonna see it. Just think guys whatever the reason that Hook was the one to appear they planned it. We’re gonna see everything that happened within the year he was away from Emma. I’m willing to bet he believes it’s true love because it’s likely he had to use some kind of magic or pixie dust to find her. Regardless this is it, this is the story. The triangle has officially died.
I agree!!! With regards to finding her… I’m REALLY hoping there’s a bean involved somehow. I know A&E said there weren’t any left, but maybe there is somewhere 🙂 Honestly I can’t see how he got to the real world any other way (unless he used red Dorothy shoes lololol) because it took Rumple hundreds of years to do it.
The pixie dust – I don’t think that’s going to come into play. When Tink used it to find Robin for Regina the path was lit with a green glow. Plus I don’t think there’s any pixie dust left? Idk.
I really want – NO NEED- to know how he became convinced that it’s TL.
@Sarah_TN, @rumplegoldfan, @Jennifer – so happy to have mothers aboard the ship!!! It’s so great because I remember reading somewhere that all CS fans are giggling teenagers who don’t have any idea what a real relationship is supposed to be like. So the fact that the three of you are married with kids and still ship CS…. I LOVE IT! I feel so young though lol.I mean I didn’t dislike her but she was always just kind of ‘there’ for me.
Emma is my favourite, favourite character. Like EVER. Like JMo, I fell in love with her straight away. I think it just depends on who you can relate to though. I identify with Emma in a lot of ways.
but for all intentional propose I guess Hook is better then Neal !!!
We’ll take it!!!! Lol. A begrudging CS shipper is better than a CS hater!
Guys you should go comment in the captainswanfire thread. I made a really good post.
It IS a very good post.
I won’t be commenting though, I’m sorry, I’m staying away from that thread. I’m not mature enough to not get into an argument I’m afraid. That thread is not good for my mental health. Mostly because I cannot deal with the idea of Swanfire as a viable relationship at all, especially now that CS are all but cemented as TL. And also because I cannot deal with the Hook-bashing, which it nearly always degenerates into.
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
So is that Neverland spin-off happening or not? Usually if the articles give scoop like this, it probably means yes… that would mean more Hook backstory!
BUT.
How would Colin manage to film both shows? Hook is pretty much the second most important character in the story, and we haven’t got almost ANY backstory of Neverland. He’s a regular on OUAT so he can’t be away for a long time, but he could be in only some Neverland episodes, like Robin – except that Robin isn’t a regular in any of the shows (OUAT or WOnderland).
So… will something bad happen to Killy by the end of season 3? 😮 They could plan to off his character in the present, only to have him in a flashback spin-off. Do you think so? 🙁
So is that Neverland spin-off happening or not? Usually if the articles give scoop like this, it probably means yes… that would mean more Hook backstory!
I don’t know! It’d be exciting to get some though 🙂
How would Colin manage to film both shows? Hook is pretty much the second most important character in the story, and we haven’t got almost ANY backstory of Neverland. He’s a regular on OUAT so he can’t be away for a long time, but he could be in only some Neverland episodes, like Robin – except that Robin isn’t a regular in any of the shows (OUAT or WOnderland).
I would say he would maybe have a recurring guest star role 🙂 I mean, in Wonderland the Mad Hatter is one of the most important characters, and we never get to see him!!!
So… will something bad happen to Killy by the end of season 3? They could plan to off his character in the present, only to have him in a flashback spin-off. Do you think so?
I’m going to go with no lol. They aren’t going to kill Killian, he’s been a part of the show since 1×01, whether he was there in the flesh or not (although we see his hand in Rumple’s castle in season 1 lol).
Hook is incredibly popular and brings in a lot of viewers – look @Jennifer, she was going off the show until Hook came into it! It would be show suicide to kill him off OUAT to put him into a spin-off. And Colin wouldn’t necessarily agree to it either, I mean, OUATIW wasn’t a success, not at all. It would be extremely risky to give up a permanent, regular role in a popular series for one where your footing will be far less sure. He has a family to think about after all.
So to answer your question: no worries! LOL
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
LOVE all the gifs guys!
1 I dont hate Neal… I like Neal… just not for Emma.
…Maybe I shouldnt write posts at 1am lol, but thats actually what I meant- I always say “No” to Hating him & No to even if he was played by someone else, I wouldnt ship SF, because it isnt Neal’s looks that are the problem, it is his actions.
Like it or not, there is a large portion of SF fans out there who firmly believe that CS’ers only ship CS, due to Colin’s looks (Many CS’ers left groups up until a mth or 2 ago, because CS’ers kept having these so called facts (CS’ers hate Neal & only ship CS because Colin is hot) thrown at them & never listened too when they said ‘that isnt true’ )- for me looks are just icing on the cake, like you say Colin has NAILED Hook & he comes vividly to life- I love the character in his own right (he’s easily my fav TV character, yet there are other actors I think are ‘hotter’ than Colin, but I like their characters less, so… *shrugs*) & Emma hasnt been emotionally destroyed by him- repeatedly, so I am happy to be on the CS ship.
I dont know if another actors take on bring Neal, would bring him to life more (IMO) or not & we’ll never know, but it doesnt matter anyway, because it was what Neal put Emma through, not who he is, that I whole hardheartedly object to (IF Neal had gone to Emma on bended knee, with cap in hand, when the curse was broken, I would have been more forgiving of him wanting yet another chance with her, but he didnt & then he continued to slam even more nails in the SF coffin after that IMO). I want Neal to get his HEA, as much as I want the others to get their’s, but I dont think Emma’s HEA is with Neal & I dont think Killian’s HEA is with anyone but Emma. *shrugs*
The topic ‘The Captain Swan thread!’ is closed to new replies.