- This topic has 24 replies, 12 voices, and was last updated 7 years ago by
.
-
Posts
-
Guess 99.9% of us were wrong! Alice is probably Roger’s daughter if the final scene of them playing chess is any indication. Now the theories begin: how were they separated? Who is Alice’s mother? Will there be any conversation about Alice being gay?
Did you like this reveal or are you bummed Alice isn’t a Rumbelle baby/granddaughter?
[adrotate group="5"]"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"Did you like this reveal or are you bummed Alice isn’t a Rumbelle baby/granddaughter?
I am okay with her not being Rumbelle’s baby or granddaughter, but why did they reveal this so soon. I would have liked more mystery.
Did you like this reveal or are you bummed Alice isn’t a Rumbelle baby/granddaughter?
I am okay with her not being Rumbelle’s baby or granddaughter, but why did they reveal this so soon. I would have liked more mystery.
It was also rather clumsily done. “Oh a random chess board! In a hospital! Gee this must be a clue!”
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"I liked the reveal. At first I thought the chess board was a red herring but when the shot paned close to the black rook, I thought, “Nope, she’s definitely Rogers’ kid.”
Personally I don’t think Rogers will care if Alice is gay. She’s his baby girl and I believe he’ll be happy to have finally found her after being separated for so long. Just as casually as Alice herself mentioned in the episode that she used to have an ex-girlfriend who worked for Belfrey, Rogers could have a casual line about Alice going on a date and asking how it went with the gal or something.
Just as casually as Alice herself mentioned in the episode that she used to have an ex-girlfriend who worked for Belfrey
That line made me wonder if it was Drizella.
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"Just as casually as Alice herself mentioned in the episode that she used to have an ex-girlfriend who worked for Belfrey
That line made me wonder if it was Drizella.
Hmm, that would be an interesting idea.
Bummed. Definitely bummed.
I just think it would be such a richer story for Alice to be Rumple and Belle’s daughter, trying to wake her father up and find a way to help him break his Dark One’s Curse. It would be such a full circle for Rumple.
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"I just think it would be such a richer story for Alice to be Rumple and Belle’s daughter, trying to wake her father up and find a way to help him break his Dark One’s Curse. It would be such a full circle for Rumple.
Not to mention
– She looks a lot like Belle/Emilie.
– One of Belle’s biggest desires was to see the world, and Alice herself is an adventurer who has explored several places.
– Belle would totally name her daughter after a literary character.I just think it would be such a richer story for Alice to be Rumple and Belle’s daughter, trying to wake her father up and find a way to help him break his Dark One’s Curse. It would be such a full circle for Rumple.
Not to mention – She looks a lot like Belle/Emilie. – One of Belle’s biggest desires was to see the world, and Alice herself is an adventurer who has explored several places. – Belle would totally name her daughter after a literary character.
I agree. And it is for all those reasons that I am bummed.
Why should she be WishHook’s daughter anyway? Because she’s blonde like Emma? Emma isn’t even the mother here unless they want to create another Wish Realm where there is another Emma he could meet in the past before his realm existed.
Maybe they’ll put one final twist in the Once family tree and have Alice be the child of Gideon and RealHook+Emma’s as yet unborn (on the show) daughter? Thus making Hook and Rumple co-grandpa’s to complete the weird Once family circle (if your family tree does not fork…you’re probably a character on Once). It would screw up the timeline of course, but since when has that bothered them? Or maybe just simplify that theory and keep the timeline intact by having Gideon marry crazy Alice. Hook and Rumple as in-laws would be an amusing send off for Once.
The topic ‘The Daughter’ is closed to new replies.