- This topic has 25 replies, 14 voices, and was last updated 7 years, 8 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
The daughter is probably Rapunzel. The rook (castle tower) gives it away. A more interesting question is who the mother of Wish Hook’s daughter is. Is she Wish Milha?
[adrotate group="5"]"That’s how you know you’ve really got a home. When you leave it, there’s this feeling that you can’t shake. You just miss it." Neal Cassidy
The daughter is probably Rapunzel. The rook (castle tower) gives it away. A more interesting question is who the mother of Wish Hook’s daughter is. Is she Wish Milha?
I mentioned this in another thread, but Wish Hook said that his life went the same as regular Hook’s up until the curse. Wouldn’t that imply that Wish Milah died just the same hundreds of years prior? I suspect that Wish Hook met somebody new and had his daughter after Regina failed to cast the curse.
I suspect that Wish Hook met somebody new and had his daughter after Regina failed to cast the curse.
Yeah I suspect it’s not Milah.
crack pot theory: it’s Emma Booth’s character, The Witch. I know WishHook said that his daughter was captured by the witch and held prisoner but what if they are one and the same
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"Wouldn’t that imply that Wish Milah died just the same hundreds of years prior?
Not exactly, because like now, Wish realm time was never explained, and one mistery for that is the fact that Emma and Bae still meet and had Henry, maybe in that realm, those things happened only few years apart, they never explained that in the show, so if time in EF2 can move faster, if in NVL didn`t move at all, and if in Black witch realm moves even faster, maybe in Wish realm, the timeline are of dozens of years, making Bae and Emma birth only a few years apart and not centuries.
I dont write this show and even i can find some explanations if she was Milah daughter( i dont believe she is), like she was in Neverland, and then Pan sent her away in a trade with some witch, we do know his connection to fairies, witchs and stuff, connecting in a way past seasons.
But in the end doesn`t matter if makes sense or not, if the writers want and if for them makes sense, even if is not explained, they will do it and then they will say in interviews that will be explained later, but in the end will go to the list of plot/black/unexplained holes of this show.
by the way i saw people online before this episode suggesting Lady tremaine was old Rapunzel, which would fit on her hate to magic, and would be a change, where the daughter is older than the father and where she is a villain and the father, an ex villain will have to help her change o a good person
"I offended you with my opinion? Ha, you should hear the ones I keep to myself".
Yeah I suspect it’s not Milah.
crack pot theory: it’s Emma Booth’s character, The Witch. I know WishHook said that his daughter was captured by the witch and held prisoner but what if they are one and the same
I was thinking the same possibility.
The topic ‘The Pirate's Daughter’ is closed to new replies.