The Ultimate OUAT Episode Showdown

[hjbau]

I am still going with Manhattan for the win, though i like A Land Without Magic better. Though, i have never done one of these where Skin Deep didn’t win, so there is that.

[RumplesGirl]

🙂 voted!

"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"

[bibliophile]

I voted yesterday and since I’ve never gotten to participate in any Once episode poll before I’m pulling for my favorite episode Skin Deep to win regardless of how many other polls it has apparently won in the past.

But in any case this has been a fun way to spend the first part of the off season and it’s not as if there were any bad episodes left. Though one of them isn’t actually in my personal top 30. The other six are my 1, 2, 8, 12, 14 & 22 to be ridiculously precise.

Maybe we could do a new poll of some kind when this one is finished? Best twist in Once/Worst twist in Once or favorite one episode character or favorite scene/piece of dialogue. Favorite quip maybe?

[ry4christ]

Maybe we could do a new poll of some kind when this one is finished? Best twist in Once/Worst twist in Once or favorite one episode character or favorite scene/piece of dialogue. Favorite quip maybe?

I like this idea. If we did favorite twist, scene, or quote we’d have to have some kind of nomination/suggestion process somehow.

* Also, 20 people have voted in Round 8 so far and there is currently a 3 way tie for the episode with the lowest number of votes! If you haven’t voted yet, make sure you do by 7 PM Central tomorrow night!

[bibliophile]

I like this idea. If we did favorite twist, scene, or quote we’d have to have some kind of nomination/suggestion process somehow.

Sounds like another rewatch for many of us. I knew I should’ve been writing all these quotes down. Twists should be easier on the memory, but you’re still right that a nomination process of some kind will have to happen.

[ry4christ]

The Round 8 Poll is now closed!! There were 23 eligible voters this time, and we have what may be an upset for some. We must say goodbye to the episode that brought us a man turning into a rose, Regina’s prisoner in the hospital basement, and the famous chipped cup – 1×12 – Skin Deep.

7th Place: 1×12 – Skin Deep
8th Place: 2×04 – The Crocodile and 6×20 – The Song in Your Heart

The Remaining Episodes in Random Order:

1×01 – Pilot
1×22 – A Land Without Magic
2×06 – Tallahassee
2×14 – Manhattan
3×11 – Going Home
1×08 – Desperate Souls

Please feel free to discuss and predict below!!! Vote for only your top 3 favorite episodes this time. Happy Voting!

Round 9 Vote: https://goo.gl/wT4w5v

[hjbau]

I cannot believe that Desperate Souls beat Skin Deep. Those were definitely the bottom of the list for me, so i am okay with these going.

[AKA]

7th Place: 1×12 – Skin Deep

WOW!!! That is unbelievable that Skin Deep would be anywhere but in the top 3 if not #1.  It was definitely my number 1.  I guess I now hope my #2 wins.

[RumplesGirl]

7th Place: 1×12 – Skin Deep

Well this is a first. I’ve never been a part of a poll where Skin Deep didn’t win. It’s still my all time favorite. Guess I gotta hope for #2 now.

Please feel free to discuss and predict below!!! Vote for only your top 3 favorite episodes this time. Happy Voting!

Well this just got waaaay tough. My personal #2 and #3 are there as is my # 4 but man that’s rough.

Voted!

"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"

[ry4christ]

I’m very, very surprised “Skin Deep” is already gone. It is such a well-loved episode. It’s one of my favorites but doesn’t quite make my personal Top 4 – apparently others felt similarly.

[Author]

Posts