- This topic has 20 replies, 9 voices, and was last updated 10 years, 11 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
Wow, more separation…..unbelievable, lol. I just can’t ……………..I’m so upset that I don’t even know why I should watch the reunion. Adam and Eddy don’t want to write for Rumbelle; as beautiful as their scenes are, all they are are scenes. We don’t get the development of a relationship – how can when when not even 3 seasons in they’re separated yet again?
That’s what’s considered reassurance? ‘Some reassurance. Great, the same world. I’m in the same country as my brothers, but I’m not together – I’m in NY, they’re in Florida. An extended period? That means Gold is in another world at the beginning of the season, most likely.
I don’t want 24/7 fluff, but I want balance. These two never have any real happiness – not for more than 5 minutes at a time. They can’t break them up in the traditional manner, so Adam/Eddy take another cliched route…….more separation.
[adrotate group="5"]Wow, more separation…..unbelievable, lol. I just can’t ……………..I’m so upset that I don’t even know why I should watch the reunion. Adam and Eddy don’t want to write for Rumbelle; as beautiful as their scenes are, all they are are scenes. We don’t get the development of a relationship – how can when when not even 3 seasons in they’re separated yet again?
It’s not separation. In fact Eddy says it’s not. And Eddy is clearly saying with that last bit: “they are going to be in the same world for an extended period of time.”
Nowhere does it say separation again. You’re reading into it based on your own fears.
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"betsypaige24 wrote: Wow, more separation…..unbelievable, lol. I just can’t ……………..I’m so upset that I don’t even know why I should watch the reunion. Adam and Eddy don’t want to write for Rumbelle; as beautiful as their scenes are, all they are are scenes. We don’t get the development of a relationship – how can when when not even 3 seasons in they’re separated yet again?
It’s not separation. In fact Eddy says it’s not. And Eddy is clearly saying with that last bit: “they are going to be in the same world for an extended period of time.” Nowhere does it say separation again. You’re reading into it based on your own fears.
Eddy didn’t say that, he said something about the state of their relationship, whatever that is….. their relationship will be explored. That’s not the same thing as saying they’re together….. Their relationship was explored in some of the last episodes in NL/SB, but they weren’t together. Take it with Adam’s comments and it’s certainly a separation. Bobby hasn’t filmed at all with Emilie – he’s not filmed with much of the main cast at all, actually, not that I can tell.
We disagree, clearly, on the meaning of Adam’s words. They can be in the same world and not be together…….If they were together, he’d have said that. I don’t expect others to agree with me, but this is how ONCE rolls……..
Eddy didn’t say that, he said something about the state of their relationship, whatever that is….. their relationship will be explored. That’s not the same thing as saying they’re together….. Their relationship was explored in some of the last episodes in NL/SB, but they weren’t together. Take it with Adam’s comments and it’s certainly a separation. Bobby hasn’t filmed at all with Emilie – he’s not filmed with much of the main cast at all, actually, not that I can tell.
And you don’t know what it means to be explored. It could mean engagement. Or baby. Or a host of other things.
You do not know what Bobby is doing. For all you know he’s there in the same world with Emilie but doing something else, like trying to defeat a big bad. It could mean he’s inside his shop and shes’ coming to see him. It could be literally anything. You are reading into this what you want to read into it based on your preconceived notions that X must happen.
Taken with Adam’s comments that they are going to be together in the world for an extended time coupled with Eddy’s “if your a Rumbelle fan then the second half…” yadda yadda yadda actually sounds really hopeful. But you’re so convinced that you know what’s going to happen based on random pap pics and not seeing Bobby just becuase no one has gotten a picture of him (and lord knows that man does a host of indoor green screen work) that you’re ignoring what A and E are actually saying: it’s a positive Rumbelle spoiler.
If they were together, he’d have said that. I don’t expect others to agree with me, but this is how ONCE rolls……..
No. He wouldn’t. Since when has Adam EVER said anything upfront when it comes to spoilers. THEY TEASE. It’s what TV show runners do. They hype and tease in order to get people to tune in. When was the last time on Twitter you honestly saw Adam give out an honest to god for sure, no teasing, spoiler? He’s not going to say “Rumbelle are going to be together forever and ever in the same universe” because that doesn’t create conversation and buzz. Their job is to make sure people tune in by creating suspense and drama.
Also
Don't fret #OUAT fans, every season Robert Carlyle gets an extra couple weeks off to go back to Scotland to spend holidays with his family
— Lindsay B (@lemon_buzz) December 5, 2013
SO just because you haven’t SEEN BOBBY doesn’t mean Rumple isn’t *there.* Bobby gets to go home before everyone else.
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"It’s really a waste of energy and unproductive to get all worked up over speculation about episodes that haven’t aired yet.
I don’t think it’s necessary to play armchair psychiatrist. I’m not reading into things; I’m entitled to my opinion as you are to yours……. If I wanted, I could say that you were reading into their comments, since there is absolutely nothing in what they said that indicates they are together.
I’m not hung up on Eddy’s comments and I very well believe there will be a proposal. That doesn’t mean much to me when I believe they’re going to be separated yet again.
Adam did not say they would be together in the same world, he said they would be in the same world…….I’ll stick with the analogy I posted above about my brothers.
I’m not ignoring what Adam and Eddy are saying at all.
I don’t think this conversation is going anywhere since you think I’m imagining everything…………
We’ll just have to agree to disagree. If I’m still watching by the time the 2nd half starts, I guess I’ll find out what they mean
Family Monarch/Grams Regina, Mama Snow, Daddy Charming, and Baby Emma…this is the Charming Family! Can we just have them become on big family please!
"If you go as far as you can see...you will then see enough to go even further." - Finn Balor
A Rumbelle engagement would be lovely! 🙂 Maybe after Neal meets Belle and they get along really well, Rumple will start to believe that maybe they can be a real family, and he’ll pop the question.
And I am not liking the word ‘goading’ being used because I feel like that implies something bad and Neal didn’t do anything bad when he told his dad to help David because it was the right thing to do. He didn’t want Emma or her family owing his father anything and IMO he’s right. Rumple should be willing to give this one thing away to show Neal that he means enough to him to do one task debt free. I’m gonna try to trust the writers with this one but they’re on thin ice with me about suddenly making a deal come out of that scene. 🙁
Yeah, I’m with you there. Other people’s posts about how it could play out in a not so horrible manner are making me feel better about it though. It’d be such a massive step back for the Rumple/Neal relationship if he goes and makes a deal anyway, after promising he’d do it for free because it was the right thing to do and his son asked it of him.
The water can’t be lake Nostos water because we’ve seen Snow drink the water in FTL in Lady of the Lake. It didn’t kill her if she left FTL.
Yep, that.
A Rumbelle engagement would be lovely! 🙂 Maybe after Neal meets Belle and they get along really well, Rumple will start to believe that maybe they can be a real family, and he’ll pop the question.
Curls up in a ball and sobs forever
Yeah, I’m with you there. Other people’s posts about how it could play out in a not so horrible manner are making me feel better about it though. It’d be such a massive step back for the Rumple/Neal relationship if he goes and makes a deal anyway, after promising he’d do it for free because it was the right thing to do and his son asked it of him.
Yup. I really think the deal is going to be initiated by Charming
"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"I have a feeling that Neal and Rumple may have another falling out. (The writers won’t let Rumple be happy for too long and since we know him and Belle will be together for an “extended period of time” (yay!) Neal makes the most sense)
We know Rumple agreed to Neal’s request to cure Charming free of charge. However, Charming would feel that he owes a debt to Rumple and he’d like to repay that as soon as possible because that’s the kind of guy Charming is.
Charming would insist on repaying the debt until Rumple agrees just to get Charming to leave him alone. However, Neal hears that Charming owes Rumple a favour and will jump to the wrong conclusion: That Rumple went back on his agreement with Neal not to charge Charming for the cure thus Rumple and Bae’s relationship will take a step backwards.
All magic comes with a price!
Keeper of Felix
The topic ‘TVLine Dec 5: Charming/ Rumbelle’ is closed to new replies.