TVLine OUAT Spoilers 221/222!

[RumplesGirl]

1) Milah and Jones meet, she runs off with him.
2) Bae jumps in the portal.
3) Rumpel meets Milah and Jones, kills Milah. “Hook” is created.
4) Bae in Storybook London (technically has no magic, but is in flying distance of world that does, Neverland).
5) Bae goes to Neverland.
6) Hook goes to Neverland.
7 ) Bae and Hook meet
8) Bae leaves Neverland
9) Hook leaves Neverland for FTL, invades Regina’s castle, sent to Wonderland etc.

Yes I agree with this timeline, though I don’t rule out Bae being in NL before FictionalLondon (or in my latest crackpot theory…Bae was separated from his shadow and his shadow is in NL being mischievous as Pan’s shadow was wont to do)

[HappyEndings]

Question: Since Bae was on his own do you think he went looking for his mother and that is why he has a photo of his mother in his hand ❓

[RumplesGirl]

@HappyEndings wrote:

Question: Since Bae was on his own do you think he went looking for his mother and that is why he has a photo of his mother in his hand ❓

Bae thinks Milah is dead because that’s what Rumple told him. I think, if that is a pic of Milah, he finds out from Hook what really happened between Milah/Hook/Rumple.

"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"

[HappyEndings]

@RumplesGirl wrote:

@HappyEndings wrote:

Question: Since Bae was on his own do you think he went looking for his mother and that is why he has a photo of his mother in his hand ❓

Bae thinks Milah is dead because that’s what Rumple told him. I think, if that is a pic of Milah, he finds out from Hook what really happened between Milah/Hook/Rumple.

Remember Bae question his father about his mother after the guard told him what happened that Milah had left Rumble and all Rumble said was that she was dead to him

[Phee]

@KFChimera wrote:

8) Bae leaves Neverland
9) Hook leaves Neverland for FTL, invades Regina’s castle, sent to Wonderland etc.

When you say that Bae leaves NL, do you that that’s when he comes to our world?

Judging by the birthdate on Neal’s wanted poster, (which obviously can’t be an actual birthdate, but it’s the only guide we have for his perceived age in our world), he was 24 and Emma was 17 at the time they met.

How long after Rumple going Dark One do we think the beanhole happened? Rumple went Dark One on Bae’s 14th birthday. Let’s give Rumple at least a year to build up his reputation, making Bae around 15 when he went down the beanhole.

24 (his perceived age in our world) – 15 (the approx age he was stuck at) = 9 years he was living in our world aging, by the time he met Emma when she was 17. She’d been in our world 17 years, he’d been in our world about 9. Which means he had to come here at some point after the curse was cast, right?

But Hook was back in FTL before Curse Day, so he must have left NL before Bae did. Yes? Or no? It’s 2:30am and I don’t like math even when my brain isn’t half asleep, so I’ve likely messed something up here. 😕

[Phee]

@HappyEndings wrote:

and all Rumble said was that she was dead to him

Rumple did not say she was “dead to him”, he just said she was “dead”…

Baelfire: And Mother? Did she leave you like the knight said? You told me she was dead.

Rumpelstiltskin: She is dead.

[RumplesGirl]

Didn’t we establish based on his WANTED sheet that Neal came to our world around 1991 because he was 14 when he came and his year of birth was 1977?

"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"

[Phee]

@RumplesGirl wrote:

Didn’t we establish based on his WANTED sheet that Neal came to our world around 1991 because he was 14 when he came and his year of birth was 1977?

If he arrived in our world in 1991 at age 14, that means he’s only been in our world and aging for 10 years by the time they meet when he’s 24. Emma’s been in our world and aging for 17 years when they meet. So he arrived here 7 years after Curse Day. Right?

[RumplesGirl]

@Phee wrote:

@RumplesGirl wrote:

Didn’t we establish based on his WANTED sheet that Neal came to our world around 1991 because he was 14 when he came and his year of birth was 1977?

If he arrived in our world in 1991 at age 14, that means he’s only been in our world and aging for 10 years by the time they meet when he’s 24. Emma’s been in our world and aging for 17 years when they meet. So he arrived here 7 years after Curse Day. Right?

…yes? Ouch. Numbers.

"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"

[Phee]

Ouch indeed. 😆

So if we assume that Bae went from NL to NJ, that jump was made 7 years after Curse Day. But Hook had already left NL for FTL before Curse Day. So Hook left NL before Bae did?

Or do timey wimey differences between different worlds negate this whole argument?

[Author]

Posts