"What I Really Want Is You"

[dayna157]

I know it can’t be Jack because we found out Jack died in the Giants home so I think he’s Peter Pan when Neal asked where to move to and she said Neverland just a thought of Peter Pan

[dayna157]

I really love Neal and Emma the store robbery scene was genius I really thought she was pregnant faking labor cracked me up when they got to the car, it really broke my heart when August showed up and ruined it for them. I love their chemistry. I like that Emma received the pendant that she wears along with the keys to the car at the end really sweet but sad.. can’t for these two to reunite

[antbee]

So many things to respond to in this thread, if I can ever get my feelings under control again.

@Lil’Red wrote:

I’m starting a club: Hugs for Baelfire! Might even make a list of members on the first post of this thread (or do I need to calm down and wait for Bae-Neal confirmation?)
We might also need to start raising money for the therapy sessions – not sure if they’ll be for us or for him yet. 😆

I so need this though. We should just call it Group Hug Thread for Bae or Prayer Circle for Bae or something like that.

^^^ Bae is definitely the producers’ punching bag. If I could attend one of public conferences the writers go to (like Comicon or Paleyfest) I would wear a shirt that says STOP HURTING HIM. Lol.

He better get his happy ending.

I just realized that Emma spent two years in Tallahassee after she left prison. She was probably still waiting for Neal.

😥 That might be all my heart can take tonight! But so true! She made his gift into a necklace she always wears, kept his car – I bet she tried to track him down and waited for him in Tallahassee. So – why did she tell Henry she has nothing to remember him by? Is it just too painful to talk about it since she’s never found him but also never let go

I know! Every time I think I can get a grip, someone mentions something else that gets me all emotional again. Like I saw a gif where the name Henry is on a keychain in the scene where Bae/Neal and Emma rob the store together, and I was like, oh no not again. 😥

[eastofthesun]

I really loved Emma and Neal together they have great chemistry, (did not expect to be so invested with them with just one episode) but I am…I LOVE EMMA, and seeing her SO happy and in love with him, makes me just all fangirly!! and then so sad with their doomed fate, their story just breaks my heart 🙁 Also the fact that she still has the car and the swan keychain/necklace makes me hopeful that their story is not over, she still has feelings for him…of course she will hate him at first for leaving her, but i hope a nice confrontation will get the truth out in the open and she could eventually forgive him.

I hope Neal has a FTL identity, nothing in the episode confirmed it 100% for me but I think it would not seem quite right or be as dramatic if he was just a regular guy….it is possible he is Baelfire…for me this would be amazing, and would tie all the main characters together through henry! There were also nods to neverland, so could he be Peter Pan? (imagine a Hook-Emma-PeterPan triangle) OMG!! lolz 😆 or even Robin Hood with the stealing??

[Phee]

These two were so sweet together, real kindred spirits, both being thieves but neither of them doing it for any other reason than to scrape by in life. It’s nice to know that he didn’t really screw her over, because that leaves it open for them to reunite easier. Mind you, even if he tells her what really happened, she could still be all, “So you just abandoned me instead of trying to find a way for us to stay together?! You can’t have loved me THAT much, then!” Neal believed August and went along with what he said after a single meeting. Emma thought August was a delusional liar no matter how much he tried to convince her. So I don’t think forgiveness and a reunion will be an instant thing.

If he is Bae, I was kinda hoping that Bae would have had a slightly darker edge to him after all his time in our world. So on the one hand, it’s a bit disappointing that he’s still such a good guy, but on the other hand, it’s nice that he didn’t get corrupted.

Dunno how much stock to put in the blatant shoutouts to Peter Pan, just because we know that the blatant shoutouts to Wizard of Oz were pure misdirection on the part of the writers last week, so they could have pulled the same stunt here too. Unless that’s what they want us to think and he will end up being Peter Pan.

Anyway, whoever he is, he’s gotta be from a magical world of some description, or there’s no way August would have been able to convince him.

@TinkerBellReturns wrote:

4) He doesn’t know about Henry. If he turns out to be Bae, then poor guy is likely to have a heart attack when he gets to SB?

“So, who is that talking to my father? My stepmother? Oh, I see. And the guy yelling at him? My father-in-law? What the–? Ok, nevermind, what about the kid?” —-> “My WHAT?” *drops dead*

😆

@AntBee wrote:

I know! Every time I think I can get a grip, someone mentions something else that gets me all emotional again. Like I saw a gif where the name Henry is on a keychain in the scene where Bae/Neal and Emma rob the store together, and I was like, oh no not again. 😥

Will have to keep an eye out for that when I re-watch.

[lilred]

To appreciate what a nice guy MRJ is – and apparently not easily scared by the world of fandom- I offer up these:
[attachment=0:3q6zcoc5]tumblr_md8pneiDJr1rnf3pxo1_500.png[/attachment:3q6zcoc5]
[attachment=1:3q6zcoc5]tumblr_md8ppo5din1rnf3pxo1_500.png[/attachment:3q6zcoc5]

Can they just make him a main cast member already???? 😀

[antbee]

@Lil’Red wrote:

To appreciate what a nice guy MRJ is

I loved how he said he shipped us all; although, I sort of worry too because there’s some crazy people out there that could take him seriously.

He does seem like such a sweetheart. I know a couple of weeks ago he wished forum poster, OuaterBox, a Happy Birthday on Twitter, but I haven’t seen her since that time to congratulate her.

Can they just make him a main cast member already???? 😀

Yes! Of course I want to see Neal/Emma, but right now I just want MRJ back on OUaT or at the very least like to know when he’s coming back. I thought he filmed in Vancouver when they were filming episodes 8 or 9, but it could have been for another project.

After we get our Baelfire episode, I bet they’ll make him a regular.

[naomi]

^Agreed. Whether or not he’s Bae, I’m dying to see him and Robert Carlyle exchange lines. I think their scenes together would be…incredible.

And I have to admit, the fact that MRJ tweets with impeccable grammar and punctuation just kills me. 😀 ^ I wonder if he knows his “ship” is SwanThief??

Also: I couldn’t resist. NOT MINE, these are from:
http://nerdalek.tumblr.com/post/35141475997

I’m also curious about his filming schedule…I’m wondering if the filming he was doing in Vancouver during episodes 8 and 9 were actually that last scene with August at the end of Tallahassee. Or maybe he was filming a couple Neal-by-himself scenes for later episodes that don’t really coincide with the rest of what the cast is doing in Steveston.

[midnight dreary]

Aww, MRJ is so adorable! I love his tweets. Poor thing has no clue what a shipper is. 😆

And I agree, his scenes with Robert Carlyle are going to be mind-blowing.

[antbee]

I love that .gif set Naomi! I can’t wait to see MRJ back on OUaT.

This literally made my morning! (Of course, he and I have a different definition of soonish though because to me that means next episode and not next year, but I’ll take it.)

[Author]

Posts