WHAT IF ? . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .

[rpalmpinoy]

PETER PAN IS THE ORIGINAL DARK ONE?

neverland is a land without time and for all we know peter could be centuries old if not millenniums
what if he created neverland?
something went down with him and someone and they killed him?
since hes the dark one and the original one he cant REALLY be kill or at least not his soul which would be that shadow that goes around looking for bodies to posses? and it probably took him a few millenniums to find the right body

idk i just like the idea of ORIGINALs and stuff cause i watch the vampire diaries (great show just sayin) and there was the originals, which were the first vampires, turned into vampires by their witch mother at first for protection from the wolves, (1000 and something years ago) and the only thing that could kill them is if they were stabbed in the heart with a steak made from the white oak tree

yea sorry that was my little rant on the vampire diaries (u should watch it if u dont already)

[heyimbatman]

dude thatd be very interesting . . . and i watch the vampire diaries 2. not many men watch these shows cause they think its gay and only for women but i say bull…. to that anyways thats my rant

o and for the vampire diaries i think that KLAUS will be that “unexpected hero” person in this week’s finally on thursday and yea to all those who dont watch it . . . . u should get on netflix and start with season 1 episode 1
so theres my rant =)

[jollyrogermate]

I totally agree with you on this theory!
I’ve just rewatched this amazing episode and I came up with a theory which is extremely similar to yours 🙂
Here it is:

What if the Shadow/PP (Peter Pan) is looking for the right boy to be his host for good?
Peter maybe learned about the prophecy about Henry being “the Dark One's undoing”, so he might need Henry to get rid of Rumple! And here comes the question: why PP has it in for Rumple??
So i thought… what if PP is the original Dark One and now he wants his power back? you know, he has quite of a dark one/ominous/disturbing look; he is a black (and maybe immortal) shadow, he rips people soul… so there's a possibility that he could have been a Dark One in the past.
During this episode, I noticed two clues:
1- When Hook heard from Bae about the “dagger”, he seemed quite astonished. Probably because he already knows the story of the dagger? Maybe because he knows the story of PP being a former Dark One?
2- At the end of the ep, when the Charmings, Regina and the others sail with the Jolly Roger through the portal, Snow asks Rumple for who Greg and Tamara work, and he says something like “for someone we should all really worry about”…. what if Rumple already knows that PP is his own predecessor? what if THIS will be his undoing?
In effect, eventually,THIS could be Rumple's undoing: Henry, united with PP's shadow, could be able to kill him as the Dark One and steel all the magic power from him.

THAT’S ALL.

(sorry if i’ve made some weird mistakes, i’m from Italy and english is not my first language… so it’s likely that i’ve made some XD)

[HappyEndings]

@JollyRogerMate wrote:

I totally agree with you on this theory!
I’ve just rewatched this amazing episode and I came up with a theory which is extremely similar to yours 🙂
Here it is:

What if the Shadow/PP (Peter Pan) is looking for the right boy to be his host for good?
Peter maybe learned about the prophecy about Henry being “the Dark One's undoing”, so he might need Henry to get rid of Rumple! And here comes the question: why PP has it in for Rumple??
So i thought… what if PP is the original Dark One and now he wants his power back? you know, he has quite of a dark one/ominous/disturbing look; he is a black (and maybe immortal) shadow, he rips people soul… so there's a possibility that he could have been a Dark One in the past.
During this episode, I noticed two clues:
1- When Hook heard from Bae about the “dagger”, he seemed quite astonished. Probably because he already knows the story of the dagger? Maybe because he knows the story of PP being a former Dark One?
2- At the end of the ep, when the Charmings, Regina and the others sail with the Jolly Roger through the portal, Snow asks Rumple for who Greg and Tamara work, and he says something like “for someone we should all really worry about”…. what if Rumple already knows that PP is his own predecessor? what if THIS will be his undoing?
In effect, eventually,THIS could be Rumple's undoing: Henry, united with PP's shadow, could be able to kill him as the Dark One and steel all the magic power from him.

THAT’S ALL.

(sorry if i’ve made some weird mistakes, i’m from Italy and english is not my first language… so it’s likely that i’ve made some XD)

Hey, I agree with you JollyRoger because the writers stated that we would learn about the history of the dagger and this makes sense to me and why the BF stated it didn’t belong here in FL

[Snickerdoodle]

@JollyRogerMate wrote:

I totally agree with you on this theory!
I’ve just rewatched this amazing episode and I came up with a theory which is extremely similar to yours 🙂
Here it is:

What if the Shadow/PP (Peter Pan) is looking for the right boy to be his host for good?
Peter maybe learned about the prophecy about Henry being “the Dark One's undoing”, so he might need Henry to get rid of Rumple! And here comes the question: why PP has it in for Rumple??
So i thought… what if PP is the original Dark One and now he wants his power back? you know, he has quite of a dark one/ominous/disturbing look; he is a black (and maybe immortal) shadow, he rips people soul… so there's a possibility that he could have been a Dark One in the past.
During this episode, I noticed two clues:
1- When Hook heard from Bae about the “dagger”, he seemed quite astonished. Probably because he already knows the story of the dagger? Maybe because he knows the story of PP being a former Dark One?
2- At the end of the ep, when the Charmings, Regina and the others sail with the Jolly Roger through the portal, Snow asks Rumple for who Greg and Tamara work, and he says something like “for someone we should all really worry about”…. what if Rumple already knows that PP is his own predecessor? what if THIS will be his undoing?
In effect, eventually,THIS could be Rumple's undoing: Henry, united with PP's shadow, could be able to kill him as the Dark One and steel all the magic power from him.

THAT’S ALL.

(sorry if i’ve made some weird mistakes, i’m from Italy and english is not my first language… so it’s likely that i’ve made some XD)

A couple of things…
When talking to Bae in season 1, the BF did say that the Dark one’s magic did not belong in “this world” meaning FTL. So that begs the question, where does it belong? Neverland?

I also have to question whether Henry could be dark since so many assume he too is a product of “true love.” To those of the dark, power is strength, but to those who know true love, love is strength; and we saw with Emma that true love is stronger than magic’s power.

[craxyfox]

on board this theory!

[thelonebamf]

I like the connection between the Dark One and PP, but I don’t think it’s that he is the original Dark One, but perhaps he created the Dark One’s Curse? It just seems like it would break a lot of rules for the power to have left PP without him dying.

Actually, we may be making a jump from assuming PP is in charge. What if he is the “dragon” (tough and strong guard dog for the real power) and the real power is Tinkerbelle?

"Nothing is easier than to denounce the evildoer; nothing is more difficult than to understand him."

[thebassgal]

Never considered Tink as being bad. Could be. Maybe Tink created the Dark One’s curse and was banished to Neverland and she cast it on Peter Pan , hence why Blue Fairy knows the Dark One’s powers do not belong in FTL. OR maybe Tink is really Nova. We know that their love affair made Dreamy become Grumpy. Not sure how the timing works on her being Nova. But I believe the shadow is akin to the dagger in FTL. Whoever controls the shadow controls the DO. In this case, I think Tink is controlling the “Pan.” I don’t think there is an actual “Peter Pan” anymore, just “Pan.”

[darkones1fan]

Hello their I am new to these forms I actually joined right after watching this epic Season finale. Anyway. I do like the idea of Pan being a Dark One. But I kind off hope that he is just that A Dark One not THE FIRST DARK ONE. I have since day one of its discovery have been obsessed by discovering the history of the dagger and the Dark One’s powers. Because I have been a big advocate of the first Dark One being the famous Disney Villain Chernabog from the hit Disney movie Fantasia since he is basically the “Dark One” an incarnation of all things evil! So I would personally think he would be the first Dark One. He could be working through Pan sort of like a puppet or figurehead. I mean after all the Home Office new about Henry hundreds of years before he was born that’s some pretty powerful stuff and also if you notice Neverland has a somewhat of a mountain in the center of the Island. (Could be something to take note of) Well those are just my two cents on the topic. Hope to post more soon.

[heyimbatman]

i think that the shadow thing is just one of the shadows that peter ripped out of someone

[Author]

Posts