Who is Neal Cassady? theories

[elle]

I doubt Neal is the White Rabbit–if he had magic before the magic bean incident, he would have taken hi father with him without going to the Blue Fairy. 🙂

And if he became the White Rabbit after his father didn’t come with him, how would he learn how to jump between worlds? He was sent to A Land Without Magic–he couldn’t have learned how to jump between worlds?

[clockwatcher]

Is everyone assuming that Neal is Bae?

I am one of the people who thinks Neal is Bae, but if we automatically assume that he definitely is Bae, we’ll be blocking other possibilities. And if the writers trick us and Neal is JUST the White Rabbit, or JUST a realm jumper, or -even worse- a NORMAL person 😮 , we’re going to have a lot of disappointed people.

[tiara_rose]

I mean I am too fixated on the theory about Neal is Bea, but as far I see the show have great stories. So even if he is not the Bae or the white rabbit. I am sure that they have another very good story for him.

If you asked at the beginning of the show. I would never have thought that the little imp (Rumple) in the cell will be the crocodile, the Beast from the Beauty and even the fairy godmother of Cinderella. That I would like the evil queen and want for Regina that Henry like her, but everything in this show fits and in the End I think we fans will have our happy ending. 😀

Heros don't get their Happy Ending!

[gypsy]

I agree.

I fully believe Neal is Bae and I’m really hoping he turns out to be Peter Pan, too…there is a lot of evidence supporting it, but, ya never know and nothing is certain with all the twists.

If he is not Bae, or not Peter Pan, or neither, I won’t be disappointed, because, I’m sure his story will be interesting and K&H will not let us down.

[TheGoldenKey]

I also believe that Neal is Bae and hoping that he is Peter Pan. While there are lots of clues supporting this theory, there are several things that are also countering the theory. His age as well as the fact that K&H have said we won’t see Peter Pan this season at all. Still, I’m hanging on to hope 🙂

As for Bae being a Lost Boy, I can’t see it. Either he’s Peter Pan or he has no relationship to Neverland. No way would they make him only a Lost Boy in Neverland. He would be the ultimate hero there and nothing less in my humble opinion.

Keeper of Pandora's Box & The Yellow Brick Road.

[clockwatcher]

@TheGoldenKey wrote:

As for Bae being a Lost Boy, I can’t see it. Either he’s Peter Pan or he has no relationship to Neverland. No way would they make him only a Lost Boy in Neverland. He would be the ultimate hero there and nothing less in my humble opinion.

I’m Clockwatcher, and I APPROVE this message 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆

[TheGoldenKey]

@Clockwatcher wrote:

@TheGoldenKey wrote:

As for Bae being a Lost Boy, I can’t see it. Either he’s Peter Pan or he has no relationship to Neverland. No way would they make him only a Lost Boy in Neverland. He would be the ultimate hero there and nothing less in my humble opinion.

I’m Clockwatcher, and I APPROVE this message 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆

Clockwatcher, you just made me spit out my hot cocoa! 😆

Keeper of Pandora's Box & The Yellow Brick Road.

[maryrose d.]

I think Neal is Bae / Peter Pan and there is a lot of evidence to prove that he is, but more so there are no reasons or holes in this theory which is why I think it will actually play out in the show.
If he is Bae and Peter it would explain a lot, like why he is on his own and results to stealing to get what he needs to live. The whole without a doubt believes in magic and leaves Emma to go to jail because of something he saw inside a wooden box, ( it must be a picture of the knife or something along the lines of the Rumple/ Bae story), it would also explain why he has waited so long to go to Storybrooke, if he has waited and the writers aren’t going to be like, oh yah he’s just been hiding the whole time, because he is not just facing Emma and what he did with her but also his father, which would be like well lets just say to very interesting reunions to watch.

Also if Bae is Peter it would explain the timeline because unless Rumple gave Bae a potion to live forever in a land without magic, Bae should be dead by now. But if after he got trapped inside a land without magic and tried to make his way back, and maybe instead of landing in the enchanted forest he landed in Neverland, and then continuously went from Neverland to our world, only truly leaving Neverland after Hook mysteriously left, he came to our world, and started to age again, but a little slower because the magic was still in place. Or maybe he continued to stay the same age until he ran out of fairy dust, we have still yet to learn the reason why people do not age in Neverland.

Finally if Neal is Bae it would one make for an awesome story. It would change peoples relationships a lot like Henry and Regina. And it is the only way to give Henry a more messed up family tree than he already has.

Keeper of Swanfire's dream catcher, the Blue Fairy Plot Device, the contact name "Her", the lanyards, the trigger, the Netherworld room and necklace, Charming's quote on Thanksgiving, and PP's pic of Henry

[clockwatcher]

@TheGoldenKey wrote:

@Clockwatcher wrote:

@TheGoldenKey wrote:

As for Bae being a Lost Boy, I can’t see it. Either he’s Peter Pan or he has no relationship to Neverland. No way would they make him only a Lost Boy in Neverland. He would be the ultimate hero there and nothing less in my humble opinion.

I’m Clockwatcher, and I APPROVE this message 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆 😆

Clockwatcher, you just made me spit out my hot cocoa! 😆

Haha, this has been brought to you by your neighborhood… you know 😉

😆 😆 😆

[maiqu20]

I’m probably the only one who doesn’t think Neal is Bae…ohh well…my theory is that he is the white rabbit or a regular guy

[Author]

Posts