- This topic has 28 replies, 14 voices, and was last updated 11 years, 10 months ago by
.
-
Posts
-
Okay Schmacky, how about Emma Vs. Neal? Emma Vs. Regina? Emma Vs. Granny? 😉
In Emma Vs. Neal, I see Emma winning. Neal curled up into a little ball as Emma destroys him…
[adrotate group="5"]HAHA I can’t stop laughing thinking about Regina and Emma fighting again. You know what’s funny about them? Even though Regina threw the first punch in their first fight, I don’t think she knows what to do in a fist fight. Like, after she threw that punch Emma punched her and then physically moved her over to the wall and Regina just went with it. I really don’t think she knows what to do when she can’t use magic to fight hehe.
Emma and Granny… it could be a toss up. I think they’re both “dirty” fighters.
In fact, I think Granny could kick a lot more butt than most people might give her credit for.
Okay, here’s my knock down, drag out results:
Belle vs Cinderella – Part of me wants to say Cinderella because Belle has become the whipping boy, or girl in this case, of the show. But I think in an ultimate battle royale, Belle would thrash Cindy. With her spikey high heels that were mentioned on another thread, she’s got a major weapon there. Plus, I’m hoping she’d borrow Gold’s “Cane of Feelings”. Like others have said, Cinderella didn’t try to change her own life, despite Rumple’s warnings. Belle gave in for the greater good of he people, Cinderella wanted to go to the ball.
Neal/possibly Bae vs Charming – I think Papa Charming would have the upper hand. Neal might not put his all into it becaues it’s Emma’s father.
Snow vs Blue Fairy – The Blue Fairy’s may or may not have her magic, but I wouldn’t want to come up against Snow in any fight. She’ll open up a can of whoop…well, a can of something we know…on her.
Regina vs Cora – Cora. Regina is too messed up right now to tackle her mother.
Rumple vs Hook – Rumple. I can’t dignify the rest with a reasoning. He is the man…or the imp, or the Dark One. 😆
August vs Jefferson – Jefferson’s a bit insane. I’ll pick the insane one any day in a fight.
Red vs Mulan – Ohh, this one is hard. Mulan is a fighter, but then Red can wolf-out. I’m picking Red, just because I like her more.
Granny vs Gepetto – Granny, of course. I think she really needs to be the next mayor of Storybrooke.
Aurora vs Nova – Aurora. She may be scrappy, but she’s been through a lot more than Nova.
Grumpy vs Whale – Grumpy’s got this one. He may be a dwarf, but I wouldn’t want to come up a against him in a fight.
Phillip vs Thomas – Phillip would win. Like others mentioned, Thomas ran to Charming with his Rumple problem.
Keeper of Rumplestiltskin's and Neal's spears and war paint and crystal ball.
This is a lot of fun. 🙂
1). Belle vs Cinderella–gonna have to give it to Belle. She seems to be much more braver and stronger in personality. While I did admire Cinderella’s struggle to keep her child in Storybrooke, her complaints in Skin Deep made it pretty clear that she cannot fully make it on her own in forced to. Belle not only willingly sacrificed herself for her village, but she was willing to tell her True Love how wrong she thought he was. She stood up to him instead of letting him take care of her.
2). Neal/possibly Bae vs Prince Charming–Prince Charming. The guy has more experience with a sword and with a gun–the scene where he pointed one at King George comes to mind. 🙂 Physically he is not only in shape but strong–the only person that seemed stronger than him with a sword (so far, though we still have Emma and Captain Hook as well) was Rumpelstiltskin, and the latter probably used more magic for that fight. Plus, Prince Charming is a father. I think he has some idea of the pain Emma went–they probably will be talking a bit more and he’ll learn more about her. I have no doubt that he’ll be angry at Neal at first.
3). Snow White vs Blue Fairy–gonna go with Snow White on this one. That Blue Fairy does not have her magic at the moment, nor does she have much experience with a sword. Snow White is a woman that was forced to go from princess to bandit. She fought trolls, ogres, and even Cora, and still managed to hold her own. She is determined and strong enough to go against anyone. 🙂
4). Regina vs Cora–Cora. Hands down. Regina has never ben really stable mentally. She attacks out of anger, spite, and jealousy. Cora is more manipulative and calculating. And she knows Regina–she knows which buttons to push, not to mention her knowledge of magic probably overshadows Regina’s by a good amount, I think.
5). Rumpelstiltskin vs Hook–this one is difficult. On one hand, I think that Rumpelstiltskin’s magic would give him the upper edge, but on the other hand, we don’t really know what Captain Hook has up his sleeve. but I’m gonna go with Rumpelstiltskin–I know Captain Hook is manipulative and a good schemer, but Rumpelstitlskin is not only more powerful, but I think he may actually have a few allies on his side.
6). August vs Jefferson–Jefferson! No doubt! The guy has been making hats for close to thirty years, he worked closely with Rumpelstiltskin and Regina. He has traveled numerous worlds and had been in trouble with the law–We Are Both mentions this. I think he can hold his own against August, who doesn’t seem to have much experience.
7). Red Riding Hood vs Mulan–This one is a tie. On one hand, Red Riding Hood is a wolf, and he can easily tear anyone apart. One the other hand, Mulan has been a warrior all her life. She also managed to hold her own against Cora. She fought beside Prince Philip for years. Gonna have to go with a tie.
8). Granny vs Gepetto–Granny! 🙂 This woman has fought werewolves, soldiers, and who knows who or what else with that crossbow of hers. She doesn’t at all seem afraid of either Rumpelstiltskin or Regina. Gepetto dosn’t seem to be a fighter–more of an inventor.
9). PrincessAurora vs Nova–Princess Aurora. 🙂 Despite what others think, I find her to be strong, determined, smart, and loyal. She willingly went into the scorching dreams for Snow white and Emma. She stood up to Cora and refused to accept any deal with her, and she willingly let herself be tied up so that she would not harm the others. Nova is cute and nice and strong in her own way, but I don’t think she has much experience. 🙂
10). Emma Vs. Neal–Emma! She spent time in jail, traveled to different states, worked as a bailbondsperson, quickly learned how to us a sword, knows how to use a gun, can fight dirty is she needs to, and has magic. I love Neal, but I doubt he would stand a chance. 🙂
11). Emma Vs. Granny–Gonna go with Emma. She has gained a lot of skills since her stay in Fairytale Land. 🙂
12). Grumpy vs Whale–Grumpy. With just his bare hands he could beat Doctor. Whale into a pulp. With his axe he could shatter all his bones. 🙂 Plus, Dr. Whale has never really seemed strong physically, nor does he have any magic.
13). Emma Vs. Regina–A while ago I would have said Regina, since she has magic and all. Now that Emma herself has magic, and shehas learned how to fght like her father, plus her experience before she came to Storybrooke, I’d say they may be close to a tie. Since Emma doesn’t fully know how to use her powers and all, she still is at a disadvantage.
14). Phillip vs Thomas–Prince Philip. The guy had been fighting for years. He seems experience with a sword, and Mulan respected him and a warrior (as well as being romantically attached). Prince Thomas didn’t seem to be a fighter. He went to Prince Charming with his problem. Nor do I remember him even carrying a weapon with him.
Belle Vs. Cinderella:
I actually think Cinderella would be the most aggressive in this fight – she did supposedly grow up with evil stepsisters. Probably wouldn’t be the first “cat fight” she’s found herself in. However, I think Belle could easily outmaneuver and outsmart Ella and win the fight. I might be combining the character of Belle to how strong Claire could be in Lost….I’d still go with Belle!
@PriceofMagic wrote:
Just a little bit of fun since the hiatus is way too long. Who do you think would win in the fight and why?
Belle vs Cinderella
Neal/possibly Bae vs Charming
Snow vs Blue Fairy
Regina vs Cora
Rumple vs Hook
August vs Jefferson
Red vs Mulan
Granny vs Gepetto
Aurora vs Nova
Grumpy vs Whale
Phillip vs Thomas
You can pick any fight you want or add any characters not listed. The only rule of the fights is that a character cannot enlist another character to help them.
Belle vs Cinderella – Belle. This girl has seen some scary things in her time. Ogre wars, strange impish magic men, evil queens, murderous pirates. I think she can handle her own.
Neal/possibly Bae vs Charming – In a fist fight, Neal. In a sword fight, Charming.
Snow vs Blue Fairy – All Snow has to do is just snatch away Blue’s fairy dust and this fight is over.
Regina vs Cora – I want to say Regina, because I want Regina to defeat Cora. But at the moment, I’m going to say Cora. Cora is ruthless on an entirely different level.
Rumple vs Hook – Rumpel has proven to be quite competent with a sword and he has the dark forces of the Dark One on his side. So, I’m going to with Rumpel.
August vs Jefferson – Jefferson. He managed to kidnap two women and hold them hostage all in one day. This dude lets it all hang out.
Red vs Mulan – Red would eat Mulan alive.
Granny vs Gepetto – Granny values the second amendment like nobody’s business. 😆
Aurora vs Nova – Neither. They’d just spend the rest of eternity scratching and mean mugging each other.
Grumpy vs Whale – Grumpy would smack Whale over the head with his liquor bottle. Game Over.
Phillip vs Thomas – Meh…
Belle vs Cinderella – Belle – she seems a lot smarter and more independent.
Neal/possibly Bae vs Charming – Neal – He has a lot more street cred then Charming that’s for sure and he looks like he has been in a few fights (human to human that is) charming knows how to use a sword, Neal knows how to use his fist and his wits.
Snow vs Blue Fairy – blue fairy – if she has magic, she cannot possibly lose that one.
Regina vs Cora – Regina – as a general rule, the next generation is smarter then the previous
Rumple vs Hook – Rumple – hook lacks maturity and experience
August vs Jefferson – Jefferson – I’m not sure why…
Red vs Mulan – Mulan – red’s outfit are not made for combat
Granny vs Gepetto – Granny – she is just an all around badass
Aurora vs Nova – Nova
Grumpy vs Whale – Grumpy – He has an ax and knows how to use it
Phillip vs Thomas – Philip – thomas looks a bit sheltered…
Neal Vs. Charming:
I actually don’t believe Neal is much of a fighter. From what we’ve seen of his character so far, he seems more likely to use his cleverness to evade the fight or try to talk himself out of the situation. He also apparently has a scar from a knife fight – so I’m guessing that didn’t work out in his favor… 😕 Yeah, kind of get a pacifist vibe from Neal.
If a fight broke out, I’m thinking Neal would try to get out of it – but, in contrast, Charming is known to have a one track mind. 😀 Charming will probably not be derailed by Neal attempts of misdirection and ultimately win. Neal will probably win a new scar.
The topic ‘Who would win in a fight?’ is closed to new replies.