Will Hook Tell Emma?

[RumplesGirl]

Does anyone else wonder if Peter Pan might tell Emma? He does love his games. He could tell Emma that Neal is alive and someone in her company knows and kept it from her. Peter might want them divided amongst themselves because then they are fighting each other and not looking for Henry.

[Josephine]

I could see Peter doing that too. Give Hook enough rope to hang himself by and then step in and tighten the noose. That would be twisted and so totally Pan.

Keeper of Rumplestiltskin's and Neal's spears and war paint and crystal ball.

[Killian Jones]

Does anyone else wonder if Peter Pan might tell Emma? He does love his games. He could tell Emma that Neal is alive and someone in her company knows and kept it from her. Peter might want them divided amongst themselves because then they are fighting each other and not looking for Henry.

 

see that’s why I think Hook will tell her he of all of them knows most about how Pan operates he’ll want to get out in front of this before Pan can use it against him.

[Slurpeez]

I could see Peter doing that too. Give Hook enough rope to hang himself by and then step in and tighten the noose. That would be twisted and so totally Pan.

I could see that happening, too. Did anyone else catch the look that Peter Pan gave Killian Jones when they first met on the beach of NL in the flashback? Robbie Kay is an amazing actor, and he gave Killian a sly look like he knew what part Killian would play eventually in the Baelfire-Emma saga.

"That’s how you know you’ve really got a home. When you leave it, there’s this feeling that you can’t shake. You just miss it." Neal Cassidy

[RumplesGirl]

Josephine wrote: I could see Peter doing that too. Give Hook enough rope to hang himself by and then step in and tighten the noose. That would be twisted and so totally Pan.

I could see that happening, too. Did anyone else catch the look that Peter Pan gave Killian Jones when they first met on the beach of NL in the flashback? Robbie Kay is an amazing actor, and he gave Killian a sly look like he knew what part Killian would play eventually in the Baelfire-Emma saga.

Yeah he took one look at Killian and was like “ah. You’ve arrived. Right on time. Good lad.” Somehow that boy knows things.

RumplesGirl wrote: Does anyone else wonder if Peter Pan might tell Emma? He does love his games. He could tell Emma that Neal is alive and someone in her company knows and kept it from her. Peter might want them divided amongst themselves because then they are fighting each other and not looking for Henry.

see that’s why I think Hook will tell her he of all of them knows most about how Pan operates he’ll want to get out in front of this before Pan can use it against him.

but will he tell her in time? From the promo next week we see that Regina catches up with Rumple who obviously knows that Nealfire is alive. Will Rumple tell Regina who tells Emma just before Hook does?

"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"

[AllThatGlitters]

slurpeez108 wrote:

Josephine wrote: I could see Peter doing that too. Give Hook enough rope to hang himself by and then step in and tighten the noose. That would be twisted and so totally Pan.

I could see that happening, too. Did anyone else catch the look that Peter Pan gave Killian Jones when they first met on the beach of NL in the flashback? Robbie Kay is an amazing actor, and he gave Killian a sly look like he knew what part Killian would play eventually in the Baelfire-Emma saga.

Yeah he took one look at Killian and was like “ah. You’ve arrived. Right on time. Good lad.” Somehow that boy knows things.

Stelio Kontos wrote:

RumplesGirl wrote: Does anyone else wonder if Peter Pan might tell Emma? He does love his games. He could tell Emma that Neal is alive and someone in her company knows and kept it from her. Peter might want them divided amongst themselves because then they are fighting each other and not looking for Henry.

see that’s why I think Hook will tell her he of all of them knows most about how Pan operates he’ll want to get out in front of this before Pan can use it against him.

but will he tell her in time? From the promo next week we see that Regina catches up with Rumple who obviously knows that Nealfire is alive. Will Rumple tell Regina who tells Emma just before Hook does?
 

 

Unless Regina breaks off on her own and meets up with Rumple

Find me on tumblr: http://allthatglittersonce.tumblr.com

[Killian Jones]

That is the conundrum, personally I think his best bet is to jump out in front of this before it blows up in his face. Hook is good at protecting himself and his best chance is to tell her now. He’s smart enough to know it’ll get back to her one way or another.

[MatthewPaul]

Does anyone else wonder if Peter Pan might tell Emma? He does love his games. He could tell Emma that Neal is alive and someone in her company knows and kept it from her. Peter might want them divided amongst themselves because then they are fighting each other and not looking for Henry.

I could see him doing that, just like he spilled the beans to Neal about Rumple’s prophecy.

[kfchimera]

I agree with Stelio, that Hook will tell. This is exactly the mistake Hook made with Bae. He didn’t tell Bae that he knew who he was, that his mother Milah CHOSE to run away with him, and that he had at first sworn vengeance on the Dark One for her death, until he met Bae. So then it blew up in his face when Bae found the drawing (and I still think Smee put it there! I’ll keep suggesting seaky mutineer Smee, the dirty rat! It is traditional for Smee to mutiny, and I still wonder where Hook’s crew went….but I digress). Point is, Hook will have no character growth if he doesn’t do the honorable thing and tell, and really, even that aside, why shouldn’t he? He’s a man who likes to fight for what he wants, thinks highly enough of his appeal so would he even consider it a risk? I don’t think so.

“If I had a world of my own, everything would be nonsense. Nothing would be what it is, because everything would be what it isn't. And contrary wise, what is, it wouldn't be. And what it wouldn't be, it would. You see?” -- Lewis Carroll, Alice's Adventures in Wonderland & Through the Looking-Glass

[Killian Jones]

I agree with Stelio, that Hook will tell. This is exactly the mistake Hook made with Bae. He didn’t tell Bae that he knew who he was, that his mother Milah CHOSE to run away with him, and that he had at first sworn vengeance on the Dark One for her death, until he met Bae. So then it blew up in his face when Bae found the drawing (and I still think Smee put it there! I’ll keep suggesting seaky mutineer Smee, the dirty rat! It is traditional for Smee to mutiny, and I still wonder where Hook’s crew went….but I digress). Point is, Hook will have no character growth if he doesn’t do the honorable thing and tell, and really, even that aside, why shouldn’t he? He’s a man who likes to fight for what he wants, thinks highly enough of his appeal so would he even consider it a risk? I don’t think so.

If Nealfire is alive he has to deal with him in order to be with Emma there’s no way around that. It’s just better for him to tell so at least he can fight for what he wants. Of all the people on the island I think Hook is the best equipped to beat Pan in the head games department. He’s the one that knows Pan the best, how he thinks and how to match wits with him. He won’t let him get a mental advantage like that.

[Author]

Posts