Wish Rumple

[bibliophile]

It’s almost as if the writers didn’t think this whole ‘wish realm’ subplot out very thoroughly isn’t it? 🙂

[hjbau]

They really should have just had the wish realm go away. There is just no situation where this young Henry who watched Snow and Charming be murdered and Emma be stolen by our Regina, there is no way that works. If this is real then our Emma is actually the wish realm Henry’s mother, as well as, our Henry’s mother, and that is so problematic. Regina actually murdered a real Snow and Charming and really left this Henry an orphan.

This is just emotionally and characterwise a complete mess and nothing they have anyone say on the show to this Henry is going to fix it.

[thedarkonedearie]

Yeah, I am glad that it is Rumpel rather then a random. I think having our Rumpel stab fake Rumpel and that breaking the dark one curse and killing Rumpel would be a good enough ending for that story.

I definitely do not want this.  Zozo would have done this if he could have….stabbing himself.  He needed someone else to kill him.  Rumple killing Wish Rumple should not work.  And I don’t want the guardian story line to be forgotten like Facilier.  I want the guardian to be Henry still.

[hjbau]

I actually agree. Rumpel should have to change to break the dark one curse. This is better then a lot of ways it could go. At least, it is better if it is just about Rumpel taking then just the mechanics of it.

I think they could have done a lot better with the “redemption” arcs then what they did. For all the villains.

[bibliophile]

I wanted Rumple to choose good and become The Light One instead of The Dark One. But since that would (I assume) leave him immortal once more and thus separated from Belle still.

I agree that having our Rumple stab wishy with his dagger doesn’t sound like enough. He might have to pull the magical double stab ala Peter Pan’s death. But..then wouldn’t he just go back to the vault like the last time? That doesn’t sound Belle heaven. When The Apprentice purified his heart (for lack of a better description) the darkness escaped and looked for the next darkest heart it could find (Regina again?) so that didn’t work. Maybe they’ll have to go back to the hat and sacrifice Hook (Rumples ‘oldest’ friend) to capture the darkness for good. Fine by me.

or they could do what I read here earlier and have Alice take it through her weird guardian powers and maybe turn it back into the grail somehow.

[RumplesGirl]

Zozo would have done this if he could have….stabbing himself.

Zozo didn’t have his dagger, though. We don’t know at what point he lost it to the Duke, but it could be that it was servitude to the Duke–not necessarily servitude to the Darkness-that exhausted Zozo so much.

 

"He was a lot of things to me" "The only conclusion was love"

[Author]

Posts