Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Hello guys.
Well first I just want to send you all tons and tons of hugs and all my love because this just… I have no words.
I haven’t seen the episode yet, I live in Europe, but when I woke up at 4AM I couldn’t resist checking the forum quickly, because of that spoiler that left us worried for a long while. Well I ended up not going back to sleep and I honnestly felt devasted and speechless, unable to even understand correctly.
When ONCE was first annonced, I was really excited… a show about fairy tales, well that could get cheesy but that also could be wonderful… I’m, like many, afteral a Disney movie addict who thinks they are indeed a good remedy in time of sadness and stress.
I quickly fell in love with ONCE… especially quick because the show also offered a good role to the awesome Robert Carlyle. Season 1 Graham died and I should have remembered that. I wasn’t especially in love with Graham, I wasn’t cheering for Gremma, though they didn’t annoy me either but when he died I felt a bit terrible about it : the guy was a good guy who really had a shitty deal in my eyes. Years and years of slavery is the price he paid for comiting a good deed by saving Snow; the guy finally remembers who he is, falls in love and BADABOOM!
Honnestly I felt really sad for Graham and I guess it was just foreshadowing.
Neal I won’t dwelve long because you all said it : he was a great guy, brave and selfless, devoted to others. He wasn’t perfect and that’s also what made him so damn lovable. And I guess, because he was so human, Neal embodied us viewers a bit : if Neal, after having had to face so much s… in his (LONG!) life could find hapiness, that means maybe we could all, that it’s worth fighting for. On a more personal level I was also cheering for SwanFire like mad because Neal and Emma’s story has echoes of my own.
I think I’m done with the show. I can’t watch a show where bullies, mass murderers (and I do like Regina, a lot) gets redemption and a shot at happiness while the good guys gets screwed over and over again. The world has a tendency to be unfair enough as it is. I thought I was watching a show about fairy tales, about love, forgiveness and second chances… oh yeah, that’s right, let’s give a second chance to the fandom “eyecandy” and screw over the good guy.
I had a fucking shitty year, I’m heartbroken, I work in “legal dispute” (which is not easy everyday) and I didn’t need this #@! show to tell me happiness and good things only belong to bullies.
Sorry for the vent, the bad grammar as well <3
[adrotate group="5"]lisas wrote: Can I just say what the HECK ? First how can they forget everything in the last year in the EF ? How can Hook evade this memory loss of the year in the EF and he remembers everything unless he is working for the WWW who I have no doubt is the one who can’t be trusted I hope Adam is prepared for people being upset
Hook is not working for the Witch. OMG why would the witch want Emma to come back to SB. She’s the curse breaker. There are other methods Hook could have used to escape the curse. Like his enchanted ship for instance. Adam and Eddy even said the answer is not why Hook escaped it’s when and how he did. He escaped before the witch cast her curse which would send everyone to SB. The one whom can’t be trusted is likely Rumple seeing as the witch has him under her control with the dagger. I think you guys expecting Hook to be this ultimate betrayal are in for a very rude awakening.
I just want to add that some people do hope to see Hook as a villain again because they enjoyed season 2 Hook way better and do enjoy the iconic villain. It is their right. It’s not a bias but for them Captain Hook should be a baddy.
(I for one dislike Hook for many reasons that are my own so I won’t comment personaly on this post)
I’m glad RC is back, but to be honnest I was never worried about him : he’s so precious, I can’t think how, unless he asked, a show would let go of him. Don’t get me wrong, I love Lana, I love Emma and most of the cast but RC is special.
I was hopeful about Neal but tonight I am so depressed. And to the CSers lurking, please don’t take this bad , I am only stating MY opinion, wich only belong to me.
I’m depressed because if Neal dies, and yup, I actually might end up stoping to watch : how can you KILL someone who kept always trying to do good for others, it’s aweful for a show about fairy tales.
And when I see Hook, it’s true I never liked Hook to start with, to me he is a bully… But serously, killing Neal and keeping Hook when Hook never showed regret for what he has done? If there’s a “nice cosy scene” with Hook and Henry I’ll totally be done. I don’t wanna sound bitter but killing Neal is one thing, but stop with puttin Hook on a piedestal. Rump and Regina have disserved their redemption, Hook hasn’t. And seriously if these things happens, well this show will do on me the exact opposite of what DInsey movies are supposed to do : it’ll make me super sad. Im’ naive, but in my world generosity and thoughtfullness should be awarded. Not vileness.
Sorry guys, this just depresses me. I’m depressed about a show, that’s scary ^^
It’s just idotic to say that. As much as I’m sometimes tired with CS, it’s true, some people are very loud sadly, I feel like I can disagree with you guys and be intelligent about it, I do totally think the way they wrote Hook in season 3 is wrong, but that’s MY opinion, and I’ll take any of you rather than “haters” who put crap on any character, I like debates but as long as they remain intelligent. It’s interesting to debate with people with a different opinion actually. But both sides must remain objective and it doesn’t happen often. And saying “I’d rather be a hater than a Hooker” is just idiotic I believe.
Oh well, good nioght guys and sorry for my venting =) Ty for making this forum a nice little place, even though we do get heated sometimes, but it remains quite nice and quite able to talk to each other. Whatever happens on the show… Oh well. The SFer in me would be sad but… Thank you for you guys remaining nice =)
I send you tons of hugs! =)
I said I wouldn’t spam you guys anymore, but this is sad. Sometimes I disagree with Adam but saying “better be called a hater than a Hooker”… it’s just sad.
Sorry I didn’t want to bring bad things. I’m bad at it. I actually think the same, the whole fandom is going into fire more because of the PA’s words than the spoiler. And I don’t know the girl, it’s just words. I am saying this especially because she said the person was unhappy. But am I silly but it seemed to me MRJ is happy on set? He seems good friend with JMO for instance. God this spoiler sux, they dropped a bombshell. And yes : time for pretty stuff =)
annwyn wrote: Anyway this new spoiler sux and whatever comes of it, I hope we won’t be at each other throat. And also, I’m gonna be honnest, I see a lot of CSers “not so nice shippers”. I’m not talking about you, please just forgive me for tis one, it’s why I was stupid and got all sad. Just sometimes, some are the minority but the “loudest”. But it doesn’t apply here, so thank you for being sweethearts. I mean it. I hate the spoil because I’m scared of the drama that may come. I may get a “no forum reading break” =)
While we’ve been saying that it’s Neal who will fall victim to death, we have also been saying that we don’t want ANYONE to die. I have seen the majority of CS shippers saying this. I have said it several times since last night. I don’t want any death. Unfortunately it’s not up to us
The fandom could really have done without this. *sigh* I also wish that because really, if it’s either Neal or Hook, it sux to “get done with the triangle this way”. Sorry but I don’t think it’s intelligent writing. When I said in SF thread “I thought Hook because I think he’s been only revolving around Emma. That’s only my opinion. Though I am dispointed there wasn’t more flashbacks, while we were in NL, with Hook Tink+Bae. We may be sail different but Hook+Peter+Tink is the tale. I put Bae also into this because of his time inNL. I’m so disapointed we didn’t have flashbacks on their time there.
Okey, so now I leave you guys, i just wanted to apologize, please no bad feelings about the “I think it’s Hook”, it is only my opinion, and is prolly biaised, I just wanted to apologize, not putting oil on fire. Whatever happens, if Neal or Hook , it’s sad to end it this way because they both disserve a chance at happy endings. Can I get some CSer hug? =)
And thank you <3
PS : Edit because I forgot the tags again =)
Nah it was here, I wasn’t insulting, I don’t think so or RG would have gently kicked my sorry ass, but to be honnest I was, well in a bad place in real life, super sad of the drama in the fandom, let things got to me, and I shouldn’t have posted in your thread to debate. The fandom really can get ugly sometimes, really. Anyway this new spoiler sux and whatever comes of it, I hope we won’t be at each other throat. And also, I’m gonna be honnest, I see a lot of CSers “not so nice shippers”. I’m not talking about you, please just forgive me for tis one, it’s why I was stupid and got all sad. Just sometimes, some are the minority but the “loudest”. But it doesn’t apply here, so thank you for being sweethearts. I mean it. I hate the spoil because I’m scared of the drama that may come. I may get a “no forum reading break” =)
Well in all honnesty, the reason I thought “Hook” first is because I don’t see his purpose anymoere, appart from being Emma’s love interest. It’s not character bashing, maybe writing bashing though because I do think they could have done so much better with him. And to the person bringing up the all media focus before killing him, I did think of that too. Before reading her post. As for Neal, and really trying to be objective, if it’s him, then they should have let him die at season two finale. But apparently it’s also about an actor being fed up with his character so I don’t know. Though I guess we have to be careful with the PA’s words. Anyway, character wise I wouldn’t understand if Neal was killed. But once again, maybe I’m just biaised
