Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Something VERY interesting I just stumbled upon. Over at the TVGuide FB page they are doing their JEERS OR CHEERS for the Death of Neal on OUAT. Almost every comment is “JEERS!!!” A lot of viewers seem to be very against this.
That is interesting.
[adrotate group="5"]"We were happy."
"Because... it was born out of true love."Ugh. You are killing me with the feels RG. But I’ll live. 😉
"We were happy."
"Because... it was born out of true love."How did we go from a brilliant theory about Neal being Dorothy to him dying in Emma’s arms?
*sigh* I don’t know what happened. I just wonder if I’ll ever stop being bitter over this.
I know. I shouldn’t be this heartbroken over the death of a fictional character, I know. But it’s not even that he’s dead–it’s how it was done and the message it sends. I think watching this show from now on will be radically different for me.
I think it will be too if I can even muster the energy to watch it. Right now it feels too hard. I can’t even care about what else is going to happen on the show but we’ll see how I feel Sunday.
"We were happy."
"Because... it was born out of true love."How did we go from a brilliant theory about Neal being Dorothy to him dying in Emma’s arms?
*sigh* I don’t know what happened. I just wonder if I’ll ever stop being bitter over this.
"We were happy."
"Because... it was born out of true love."I’ve had a headache since I woke up. I’m angry. I’m sad and I think I’m all cried out. At some point I have to resurface and be a Mod.
This thread will never die.
I refuse to let it.
Thank you for today, guys
I’ve had a headache too and an upset stomach.
And thank you too.
At least we still have each other.
And our crafting thread. 🙂
*HUGS*
"We were happy."
"Because... it was born out of true love."I feel like they retconned a lot of stuff in 315. I mean I just read marty’s thread about What’s wrong with Neal and I had forgotten that Neal all of a sudden is still mad at his dad. Um what? Didn’t he forgive his dad and had this great moment on the Jolly Roger on the way back from NVL because his dad came back for him? I thought they had moved past all that. I don’t know. It’s just so inconsistent. Blah. I can’t believe some people thought this episode was so well written. I did not think so at all. It was well acted but not well written. I don’t blame the actors at all. It’s the writer’s fault imo. She didn’t seem to know Neal at all or what he had just been through in 311.
"We were happy."
"Because... it was born out of true love."Adam responded to me, while I was in tears started up again by reading the whole MRJ tweet sequence…(those made it more personal for me because I’m also being severed not by will from my work family) Said he hopes I find what I’m looking for in the coming episodes in response to my asking if Neal’s death would make more sense in their context. I dunno what to make of it exactly, though I am flattered that he answered.
Imo, it means that they really don’t have anything else to say about Neal’s death but hope that you continue to watch and figure it out for yourself.
I really don’t see anything else that they can do in the show to make his death make sense. But that’s just me. Maybe someone else can find some meaning or sense.
Can I also say that I am really mad that some people are saying that since Belle is the one to tell Neal that the Swan keychain was born from true love that it’s not confirmation that Neal and Emma had true love. Apparently since Belle isn’t an authority on Neal or true love, her statement doesn’t count as true love. So not only is the way paved clear for CS, now SF isn’t true love so it doesn’t matter. I feel so done, right now.
"We were happy."
"Because... it was born out of true love."What did you say RG? I must have missed it. Since when are we not allowed to opinions?
I tweeted something to Adam about how I didn’t understand the message and then someone from our site here tweeted me back telling me that not everyone gets a happy ending. I’m pretty resentful of people telling me that.
Well, the showrunners were the ones that touted that this was a show about hope and happy endings so I think it’s a valid question. You didn’t ask why he didn’t get a happy ending, you asked what the message was or that you didn’t understand. People sometimes.
I don’t listen to what other commenters say, especially in regards to Life’s a b*** motto. Yeah I know that but not what they forced feed us in this show until now apparently…. You can tell Neal is not their favorite character so of course they’re not as heartbroken as we are. You’re allowed your question and it’s a valid one, after everything they spoon feed us with the dialogue.
Neal’s “This isn’t over I’ll see both of you again.”
Rumple’s “I came back to make sure you had a happy ending.”
Robin’s “Everyone gets second chances”
They all seem very hypocritical statements at this point.
They sure do. And empty. No meaning.
"We were happy."
"Because... it was born out of true love."What did you say RG? I must have missed it. Since when are we not allowed to opinions?
I tweeted something to Adam about how I didn’t understand the message and then someone from our site here tweeted me back telling me that not everyone gets a happy ending. I’m pretty resentful of people telling me that.
Well, the showrunners were the ones that touted that this was a show about hope and happy endings so I think it’s a valid question. You didn’t ask why he didn’t get a happy ending, you asked what the message was or that you didn’t understand. People sometimes.
"We were happy."
"Because... it was born out of true love."
