Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
If Charming was asleep so that Snow could go on the girls night out, who was looking after baby Neal?
Probably Zelena, she’s Snow and Emma’s BFF now…
[adrotate group="5"]"All your questions are pointless"
That’s exactly how it was framed and not a distorting made by people.
"All your questions are pointless"
Love stories always start with finding your love hiding under a pile of bodies he either killed or stood by and watched, oh and rape threats as well…
"All your questions are pointless"
Of course Emma and Neal were ment to end up together. They had thematic connection which Emma and Hook lack.
Emma and Hook’s was born out of Hook’s growing popularity and because some fans wanted to see them together, which was a huge mistake because it changed the entire dynamic of the characters.
They had no build up and no foreshadowing at all. And no, Tallahasse doesn’t count, it wasn’t about Hook and Emma, it was about Emma’s trust issues and how she is able or unable to trust other people including Snow, Mulan, Anton and Hook. She had interaction with each that involves her trusting or not trusting them."All your questions are pointless"
I still think their original planned ending for the show was Going Home and they had to make it sooner because of KillEmma. It just seems like seasons 1-3A had different attitude from the writers than the rest of the series.
"All your questions are pointless"
Lol. I’m craughing. Couldn’t they introduce just one object and say “this will do whatever you want if the plot needs you to do it”.
"All your questions are pointless"
I’d be very grateful to watch Once without Emma in it. I would be happy with just Regina. However, I think I am in the minority amongst the viewers.
I agree.
"All your questions are pointless"
When was the last time Emma cared about anyone who wasn’t Hook or Regina or a fan favorite?
"All your questions are pointless"
Forget the fact that Belle is an innocent person, and Emma should care about those because she the savior and all. Belle helped her with Zelena, she went to Camelot in order to help her, she babysits Neal, she even babysits him when they decided to go to that family vacation in the Underworld, so yeah she deserves much more from Emma and Snow and the rest of them…
"All your questions are pointless"
Really, because I remember an Emma who stood up for the truth and backed others even when it was detrimental to herself. I remember an Emma who would never have blackmailed others and would have tried to help Gideon after his explanation instead of threatening to kill him. This was the Emma of season 1-3.
Yeah I agree, that’s the Emma we all came to know and love in the first 3 seasons. Many of us see her “character growth” since then to be negative as she seems to place Hook above all else. Here’s how I see it: Gideon has tried to kill her, taken Hook away, and is now threatening Emma – it’s in character for her to punch him then. But after Gideon implies he was abused and explains how so many, including children, are depending on him, Old Emma would have had a moment of realization that this guy needs her help. Then we cut to Black Fairy abusing a child. I realize Emma isn’t completely aware of the extent of Black Fairy’s evil, but from a writing standpoint, why would you show your hero punching someone in the face, and then immediately show the Black’s fairy’s abusiveness toward that same someone?! Emma punches Gideon, then abuse scene, then Emma with Snow telling his parents she’s happy to fulfill his “death wish.” And then, by the end of the episode we find out Gideon isn’t at fault for any of his actions! If the writers were trying to make Emma look bad, they succeeded.
This reminds me of an episode where they tried to make us sympathize with Regina and in the same episode we get a flashback when she had her guard slaughter an entire village. Same with Maleficent.
"All your questions are pointless"
