Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
I just hope it’s a Gold episode; it’s hard to believe that he might go a whole half season without any centric….
The only thing I can come up with is that it’s the title of Scottish singer/songwriter Amy McDonald’s recent album and she recorded it at Paul Weller’s studio. I don’t know who he is, but I know he’s friends with Bobby………..so maybe it is a Gold episode, lol
[adrotate group="5"]Happy 2nd Anniversary to Skin Deep and happy birthday Rumbelle! I see Bobby tweeted about it, but failed to include Emilie on it, which is disappointing to me as there is no Rumbelle without her
Alrighty. GLITTER BOMB This conversation has gone on for like several pages now to no avail. I stepped in early this morning just as a reminder to keep it polite. Please bear this in mind. And maybe move the conversation to another topic?
Yeah, no problem with that. I tried to do that earlier by talking about Belle’s storyline, but that went nowhere fast, lol
Excuse me, WHAT are you talking about, lol? I was not being sarcastic and I have no idea why you took my comments as such. Everything I said, I meant…..it’s my opinion and I was being completely straighforward.
LOL Oh wait, the comment about me being President? Sorry, but not sorry – that’s how I feel. IMO, there’s no way this is ever happening; if you don’t like what I have to say, I don’t know what to tell you. I was making a very specific point.
TheGoldenKey wrote: Yes, Rumbelle is TL, however, that doesn’t mean that if one half of TL ceases to exist that the other wouldn’t or couldn’t move on. Right now, one half believes the other half is dead & gone.
That’s true. But I don’t think Belle will move on within the span of a year–and certainly not with her TL’s son.
Not ever, IMO (I think she and Gold (or Snowing) would (on their own) live their life, but they wouldn’t move on with someone else……I firmly believe that. Gold mourned her for 30 years and chose to forget (the curse) for 28 in large part because he couldn’t handle the grief, the pain, the sheer agony of Belle’s death. I think Belle would feel the same way……..
As to Neal, if this ever happened, and I think there’s a better chance that I become President, I’d become an ex-Rumbeller. and an ex-Belle fan. I could never support Belle ever again as a character and I would want better for Gold. I think most, if not all, Rumbellers, would be absolutely disgusted.
I wonder if Bobby is frustrated having little to do………Also, if they are going to explore Rumbelle, they really need to at least have Bobby and Emilie filming together a bit. I mean, seriously? An entire half season without them together in any way, with any story, except for a scene in episode 16? Brutal
RG, of course……that wouldn’t ever enter their minds. It was brought up, so I responded, but yeah there are a million reasons why this would never happen.
In the meantime, I am looking forward to Emilie’s performances – Adam specifically mentioned how fantastic she was (she always is, but to say that they are some of her best work ever…….), so I just have a feeling she’s been given extremely emotional material to work with. I kind of think Gold’s “death” is going to change her…….not in her basic way, but I think (well I hope) that she will be more of an active participant in town life, that she will finally let loose her anger about her loss, the fact that she and Gold never had a shot thanks to certain people, etc.. If Gold is being controlled by the WW, I want her to save him…well I want her to help him save himself. Who knows, though, lol
Even if this were HBO, just……..no. I think it’s SO wrong and even thinking about it makes my stomach turn (that’s my personal opinion; I’m not judging anyone for thinking it could happen). Rumbelle’s love for each other is epic and undying and that will never change even if the other really is dead…….and for me, whether they THINK the other is dead is meaningless. Belle would dishonor her love for Gold and dishonor his memory by having a relationship with his son. Of course since I think she thinks of him as family anyway and since I don’t think she’d ever, no matter how many years pass, have another romantic relationship, it’s moot
Slurpeez, agree completely about relationships….Oh and if they EVER went there with Neal and Belle? I think they’d truly anger Belle fans, Rumbelle fans and other fans who just hate that idea. I think there would be an exodus of fans, honestly; there is nothing at all interesting about that story and worst of all, it would destroy an epic and remarkable love, tainting it permanently.
RG, yes…..and I think that will happen, though I think it sucks that they’d forget about their experiences in SB. On the other hand, I’d like to think that their hearts would remember
I do sorta wanna give my two cents, though. I don’t think Belle would ever be involved with Nealfire just because he is Rumple’s son. She doesn’t even view him as Neal, she calls him Baelfire—a name Neal doesn’t even use for himself until the very end of S3A. In her mind, he is the little lost boy that Rumple was trying to find for 250+ years. I don’t know if she views him as a step son or not (I think EdR and MRJ view their characters that way but it has been more or less vague on screen) but what she does view him as is Rumple’s son. And I think she knows that’s a giant red X.
YES……..and besides that, whether it’s with Neal or anyone else…..no. Much as Rumple/Gold would never love anyone else and would mourn forever, so would that be with Belle. It’s the same as with Snowing. This is never going to happen; I just think we have to allow for people to bond and become close without thinking that things are going to happen. Belle and Bae need each other and they will be good for each other.
Harley, I’m sorry, it’s just that I’ve had issues on Tumblr and so it’s easy to become defensive. I’m sorry!
