Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
I like how one of MRJ’s photo’s has his hands behind his head, on his hair, much like one of Emilie’s photos
[adrotate group="5"]The Belle/Gold ones are gorgeous (Bobby looks much more natural), but it just feels weird seeing promo photos for an old arc. It makes no sense…………
I’m not going to speculate as to when the death takes place because I have no idea……….. anyone can say anything and then basically not have to face anyone if/when what they say proves to be false
If this person who is being killed off is really unhappy, then A/E have no choice but to kill the character….and I wouldn’t blame them for saying it’s for storyline purposes (why should they out someone for being unhappy). We’ll never know……until it happens.
We know that it can only be one of 3 characters who dies (this idea that any of the Charming family will die is pretty “out there” – there’s no way that’s happening) and there are only 2 whose deaths would provide huge storyline: Bae or Belle. Personally I think it makes more sense for it to be Belle. For one thing, we saw at the end of S2 finale that, with Belle by his side, Gold could handle Bae’s death. Of course he’d be shattered and we’d no doubt have seen (had things not fallen apart) them have very emotional moments together as he dealt with this, but at least he’d have Belle to support him. If Belle were to die, he’d be all alone. Bae is not his emotional center, his anchor, and even his love for his papa wouldn’t be enough. Gold, IMO, would suffer a complete breakdown if she were to die. Plus, they never intended Belle to be a real part of his life……..Of course, given how the made Emilie a regular based on how popular she and Rumbelle were, it makes no sense to kill her off and possibly lose two huge chunks of fan base. Plus, if Em were unhappy with her air time (which, though I would be, I don’t think she is), I can’t see A/E killing Belle off and making it impossible for her to ever return and have a HEA with Gold. There are other reasons I don’t see Belle being killed – not just because Disney probably wouldn’t allow it. Killing Belle also undercuts Gold’s sacrifice, it destroys all hope (she’s practically the symbol of hope, especially to him) and it would be the end to the most tragic life imaginable. We talk about Gold’s suffering, but good god, how about Belle? Locked away for 30 years, then not long after is shot/loses her memories/cursed, then loses her TL….How fair is that?
If the death is for story reasons, Hook is the one least connected…..but he’s also the one whose death would have the least emotional impact (not for his fanbase of course, but overall).
There are valid arguments for why each of these characters will or won’t be the one…….I’m starting to think that this person IS unhappy and if the rumors are true, then really there is nothing A/E can do and I respect Adam’s refusal to throw this person under the bus by revealing that the death is due to creative differences (ie: personal reasons)
betsypaige24 wrote: I’m confused, lol…it’s been a long day. I should understand this, but it’s not clear to me.
I have no idea either, reading it back. Smee was human at the same time Hook was in town from 209-212. Hook, at that time was either alone, with Cora or in the hospital. So for them to be together it must be present day
I was referring to it possibly being a FB to the past……. Also, I’m still unclear on your point, but FYI, Smee was turned into a rat in the Outsider……,211
betsypaige24 wrote: Smee is probably filming for a FB
I’m not so sure. With Emma and Henry on set (maybe filming alongside) it seems like it would be present day since FlashBack Human Smee would have been before Manhattan and that’s when Hook was in the hospital or all “must kill Rumple”
I’m confused, lol…it’s been a long day. I should understand this, but it’s not clear to me.
Well we don’t know that Smee was filming with all of these people – maybe just Hook., It could be present, but I don’t think I’d like that. There’s no reason for Gold’s magic to have reversed itself…..and then if that happens, then what about other magic he and Regina used? Sounds annoyingly chaotic, frankly, and why bring him back? Is Smee going to be a regular? I’m not saying you’re wrong – knowing this show, you’re probably right.
betsypaige24 wrote: Hm, someone tweeted me that he got Em’s autograph in Vancouver on Saturday, so that leads me to think (since she didn’t go home) that she’s filming soon…….I hope so. Of course, that doesn’t mean she’s in 17 – they’re nearing the end of that, I think – next couple of days
I was just about to say that. I think they must be almost finished with 317, so Em probably stuck around for 318 to begin. Of course we don’t know if she has been filming inside all this time too.
Well if she wasn’t filming last week at all, she probably went to LA……….but it seems odd for her to have come back on a Saturday if she wasn’t filming until at least Tuesday.
I’ll repeat the comment I added to my previous post : the 2nd half of S3 is going to have hardly any Bobby. What a waste.
Hm, someone tweeted me that he got Em’s autograph in Vancouver on Saturday, so that leads me to think (since she didn’t go home) that she’s filming soon…….I hope so. Of course, that doesn’t mean she’s in 17 – they’re nearing the end of that, I think – next couple of days
Boy oh boy, the 2nd half of S3 is going to have hardly ANY Bobby…….what a waste.
It all depends on if it’s true, which it may very well be not, that MRJ is unhappy.
The thing about this death spoiler is that it is so FINAL; it’s clear that the charcter/actor will not be seen again even in FB. So, even if it were for storyline purposes, why would Adam/Eddy shut the door so loudly on possible return in some way?
If Emilie wanted to leave because she wasn’t working enough, there’s no way they’d kill Belle – they love Emilie, so they’d keep her alive so they could bring her back in case Em wanted to return. Same thing with anyone……. I’m starting to think that whomever IS getting killed really is unhappy and has no desire at at all to return
