Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Oh I think it’s totally possible because anything on this show is now possible. From Hook2 standpoint, sure why not. He has no history with Regina at all, but from Regina’s standpoint…eh. He might be Hook2 but he’s still (some version of) Hook, a person Regina has quite a history with and it’s not exactly…good. I think they’ve set it up, but I also think they’ve set up Hook looking for his baby’s mama and getting back together with her (crack theory: it’s the “Witch” who kidnapped his daughter). Or who knows. Maybe we can find Ariel2 and @phee and I can finally get our Hookriel
I doubt that. For one if the baby mama was relevant Hook would have brought her up, but all he did was bring up the daughter. To me that is significant, it means they’ve setup that his daughter is his TL. The mother is either dead or abandoned both of them.
[adrotate group="5"]About Hook and Milah – were they really true loves? I don’t think there was ever solid proof of that and let us not forget that most cringy of lines… “You lasted longer than I expected. If you’d fought me with such vigor back in the day, I might have returned your wife to you. Soiled…but returned” (Hook to Rumple in season 5, ‘Broken Heart’). Granted that’s just one quote from when Hook was The Dark One (for a hot minute) and I’m sure someone who really wanted to could compile a list of every time Hook has referenced Milah to try and figure out how he really felt about her…but really when was the last time this show was consistent anyway? My take on Hook and Milah at the moment is that they were both unhappy selfish humans who found kindred spirits in each other. Sort of a Rumple and Cora thing. That doesn’t mean he didn’t love her, but I think this ‘true love’ concept from Once seems like a higher less selfish love or something? Like Rumple would absolutely give his life for Baelfire and Belle (cause he did), Charming and Snow would give their lives for one another ect. …but would Hook? Would Milah? Has anyone ever really outlined what True Love really is in Once?
Wish Hook said that his life was the same as regular Hook until the curse was supposed to happen. So based on that, Milah still died. I’m guessing he found somebody else, after Regina failed to cast the curse, and he had his daughter with her.
That someone likely died or abandoned him with his daughter cause all he does is mention his daughter not another woman.
Ratings are in for episode 702 “A Pirate’s Life” Demo: .7 Live viewers: 2.78 million That is flat from last week.
I know you said that live viewing figures don’t really matter (or someone else said that) but that is still a massive drop in live viewers from last week.
Indeed it is, next week will be interesting.
Compared to those ideas the WishRealm Hook idea really is the better option. I know it’s not ideal, but the time-traveling thing and the clone thing and impostor thing would have been a million times worse. So basically we ended up with the best of a bad choice. So that’s something.
True, they really had no options that would actually make sense. As annoyed as I am by the ridiculousness of how we got to this place, I am frankly glad to have a NewHook. Back in S2, when he first showed up, I liked the character. He seemed complex, and dark, and flawed, with an emotionally charged history with Rumple and Bae, and I was looking forward to what they were gonna do with him. Then they ended up ignoring his darker elements so they could simplify him into a woobie puppy who followed the female lead around. They barely even gave him anything to do in Neverland. Captain Hook was given barely any story when they spent half a freaking season in Neverland!!! As with SO MANY characters and stories and elements in this show, they squandered a great opportunity to do something really interesting. So now we have NewHook, who said that his story was the same as the Hook we knew, up until the point where in his realm Regina’s Curse didn’t happen. They’ve basically hit the re-set button on Hook. All that history with Rumple, all his time in Neverland, apparently still happened, but we’re getting a do-over from the time of the Curse. And as someone who was underwhelmed by their first attempt at the character, I’m actually curious to see if they have something more interesting planned this time around.
You mean for the one season they get of this flop reboot before they’re cancelled? I doubt that especially when they have to rush towards an ending.
As I said, for the time being I’ll keep watching. However, we, (the fans), really need to get into contact with Adam & Eddy, over social media or where ever, and let them know that the timeline stuff and no aging stuff needs to be explained, ASAP.
They’ve been quoted in a recent article saying that it will all make sense by the end of the season (although I fear that for a lot of people, that will be too late).
Nice save I was about to add if anybody will still be watching by the end of the season.
The thing that frustrates me to no end is these writers have said multiple times WR was not real. So how the heck are we using it once again here?
You can watch OUAT S7 without watching OUAT S1-S6 we say this as we introduce a main character for this new season as one from a S6 episode, lol. They just need to stop talking.
Stop saying Wish Realm is not real. Cause if so Regina murdered WR Snowing, why isn’t that brought up? Why isn’t the WR Henry whom is an orphan and if he wants to kill Regina he literally has all the right too is told he isn’t real? But WR Hook is? It’s just so dumb and convoluted.
You can tell how JMO not coming back for S7 as a regular royally effed their plan.
They were not confirmed to be true love’s on the show ever, but you are not going to change my mind and i am not going to change your mind, so let’s just let that be.
It isn’t a matter of opinion. It was said on the show multiple times, and stated. Whether you choose to accept it or not is up to you.
