Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Just putting it out there that the Apprentice’s/Sorcerer’s fake publishing company was called “Star Publishing”.
[adrotate group="5"]Speculate: where did Emma go?
The Vault of the Dark One.
And why did the Quill chose him? Just because he wrote well?
Because he wrote the truth, rather than what people wanted to hear/read, maybe?
He’s the Author, with or without the quill. Isaac didn’t have one for years when he was trapped in the book. But it’s not like he has any special powers, though.
Can he do anything as the new Author without the quill? is it just an empty title now?
He can do…. the magic writing thing, maybe? You know, how Isaac didn’t have to touch the paper, just wave the quill in midair?
But other than that, probably not. The Authors’ only real power is using the quill and ink to change reality, and they’re never even supposed to use it.
He’s the Author, with or without the quill. Isaac didn’t have one for years when he was trapped in the book.
But it’s not like he has any special powers, though.
The AU was….nice. Henry was the star….AT LAST HENRY HAD SOMETHING TO DO! Quick question…how did the villains win when Rumple was the only one happy?????!!!!!!!! Regina and even Hook were miserable….it’d have been better if it was just flat out said Rumple was only in it for himself.
Zelena was happy.
Maybe Mal too, but for some reason we didn’t see her AT ALL.
So excited for this. Emma is the only one whose “dark side” we haven’t really seen and having a new Dark One is gonna be fun.
As I’ve said before, for all we know, there may be another author out there who is writing Isaac’s story, everyone’s complete story.
There’s only one Author at a time, the “mantle” passes on when they die.
But, if we go with your supposition that Neal’s death was never recorded in any book, that only supports that his death can be undone for the very reason that it was never recorded in the first place. Thus, the original quill & ink that created his past, most certainly could rewrite his outcome.
Uh, no? The quill and ink can only change the past they’ve created. Thus, if Neal’s death wasn’t created with them, it can’t be changed. And again, emphasis on CREATED. Are you for some reason assuming that the whole Rumple and Bae story was caused by an Author’s meddling?
At this stage of the game, we should all know to read between the lines and to pick up key things that are said. Isaac is on record saying that a quill and ink can change any past it’s created. That makes it canon and canon makes for a good theory. I get that you and others don’t agree that we’ll see Neal/Bae again, but it doesn’t change the fact that Isaac just made that possibility canon. It’s an official loophole in a show that is all about loops.
You’re reading too much into it. The reason Isaac said it was so that A: They can undo the Heroes and Villains book. and/or B: They can swap the darkness back to Emma, which even the Sorcerer couldn’t do. And yeah it’s not a loophole because, once again, Neal’s death was not created by an Author.
