Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Also, Neal’s “crimes” are that he left Emma because he was afraid of his father finding him because his father is the dark one and abandoned him. He left Emma after being told he was bad for her and that he would keep her from her destiny. He didn’t know she was pregnant. He tried to leave her the money with the car. There is no proof of some huge age difference. They made Neal’s back story complicated and Emma is still in love with him and they have Henry which complicates it even more.
The villain’s crimes are much more cut and dry. They are murderers and rapists, killing children and their only family members, wives and husbands and parents, as well as the parents of the heroes, as well as the attempted murders of the heroes. And those things happened like a few months ago for some of these characters, maybe a year ago, not ten years ago like for Neal.
I think what Neal did was wrong and messed up and it would take a lot of talking for him and Emma to get back together. I wasn’t really there when he died, but there is no amount of talking that makes it make sense that Emma would date Hook or be friends with Regina.
[adrotate group="5"]That is exactly it, Rumpelsgirl. There is no way to know what Adam and Eddy might do because they are terrible writers, so they may do the worst thing imaginable. They already have done so. Also, if Jennifer and Ginny and Josh and Robert all want off the show then well, they might kill some of them. The ending isn’t going to be good at this point, no matter what they do, but these writers thinking making random splashy things happen is good writing, so killing Emma is on the table.
And yeah, we have no clue what is going on with these negotiations. They may be done and they are using them to keep the fandom talking. Most of the actors could have made a decision already and one be holding out. It could be about money or producer credits or less episodes or promises that the show ends after seven. It could be lots of things and because outside factors are effecting what might happen in the plot, on top of Adam and Eddy being just bad at writing, that means Jennifer might leave and so Emma might die.
After all, Emma said, “I’m fated to die and i will die, but not today.” She might actually die.
The end should be all them returning to the Enchanted Forest and being happy together, but Emma is talking about dying and i no longer care whether she lives or dies. It will ruin the show, in my opinion, to kill her off, but that doesn’t mean these writers might not do it.
Charming had feelings, but the entire episode was pretty much set up to reveal that Hook killed Charming’s father. I don’t think anything else that happened is going to come back into the story again except for that. They even sort of implied Charming’s father was resolved because he disappeared.
I would like this twist if it led to the natural conclusion of finding out your boyfriend murdered your grandfather which would be breaking up, but it won’t. Instead it is going to lead to a wedding. I have thought Hook killed Charming’s father, but i don’t think this was as interesting as it could have been. It was just done randomly at the end and it was about Hook’s feelings more then about Charming’s. This entire episode felt more about Hook’s feelings then Charming’s because what was going on with Charming was all filler.
There is no evidence so far that a savior actually has to die. Aladdin didn’t die. I think Emma could die just because she said she was going to die. At this point though, if Emma is going to marry Hook, i don’t really care if she dies or not either.
Rumpel knew that it was Snow and Charming’s child that would be the savior. He didn’t just need any random true love baby, he need hairs from Snow and Charming specifically. Rumpel has visions. There is no grand plan with him. He sees the future and is making it happen.
They really did do a bad job with Hook’s reaction. He didn’t even seem to care that he just found out he murdered his supposed friend’s father. All he seems to care about is how it might effect his relationship with Emma. He doesn’t seem to be giving any thought to how David might feel about it. I just don’t get how this show can have a flashback to someone murdering another character’s father and then expect us to feel sorry for the murderer. That is really what the show seems like it is trying to sell.
I very much doubt they are going to end this show with Emma and Hook going on a honeymoon. That would just be nothing to do with anything. There is a reason that the wedding is going to be in 620 and that is so they can actually finish off the plot in the last two episodes. Something else is going to happen with the actual main characters of the show in the last two episodes and it isn’t going to be about their wedding, it is going to be about whatever is going on with the Black Fairy or Gideon or Jafar or just whatever is going on there.
I don’t get it either. Do they want us to like Hook? They have him be a murdering, serial killer who lies to Emma all the time. Who hides his past and has tried to murder the entire family. None of Emma’s family really thinks well of him. Then they have an episode where they pretend like he is helping Charming and then at the end he finds out he killed Charming’s father and he lies about it again.
Nothing will come of us, but this is why i say the most logical thing to happen is for Emma and Hook to just talk about all the stuff between them and for them to then break up.
