Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
I definitely agree that Eddy and Adam have no respect for their fans or their audience and have no respect for our intelligence. They seem to think we don’t understand what is going on, when the show is just so inconsistent there is just nothing to understand. That is why we can’t bring in deleted scenes. The canon scenes are inconsistent enough without adding in deleted scenes which were cut for reasons. There is nothing to dissect, no details to try and figure it, nothing that happens has any special meaning for the future, literally anything can happen, because the show is just completely inconsistent from one moment to the next, nothing that happens has any meaning.
[adrotate group="5"]@rumplesgirl, maybe u can confirm, but i guess that line about not cannon from Adam comes, after some CS fan complain how deleted scenes contradict the show, bc she says that one of her friends got the DVd already and says one of the scenes, Emma says to Regina that Neal supported her going to the UW, when the scene on 512 didnt show that. If that is really on the scene, so maybe being caught in a retcon of a previous scene, may have made Adam saying that the scenes are not canon, bc having Emma saying” Neal`s greatest gift was giving his blessing to find hook in UW”, when was the opposite of what he said, im actually happy that was deleted and is not canon. Also, means that in previous DVd, many CS and hook scenes besides the jello are also not canon.
I am so glad that scene was deleted as well, if that is what was actually said. I am not sure if that is what was said. People seem to be saying different things. I am glad the writers got their head out of the sand and realized how frustrating it would have been to Neal fans to have him somehow pass the buck to Hook. I was so glad they didn’t do that and i hope that they just leave it alone now. I would rather never see Neal again then have a terrible scene like that. Either bring him back for good or just leave it alone.
This is why the writers don’t get to decide what is canon. They just don’t. The aired episodes of the show are canon, nothing else ever is. This is one of the reasons why. What the writers say is inconsistent. They change their mind. I haven’t seen half the scenes you just mentioned and i get on a board about this show. The general audience has never seen this scenes. They are not canon. They never have been.
It is annoying for the writers to change their mind, but it was annoying for them to try to hoist their cliff notes onto the show as well. I shouldn’t have to watch deleted scenes or interviews or read their tweets to understand the show.
I think she just taught like fourth grade, not a subject. Though she was Henry’s like sixth grade teacher as well. There was a bird on the chalk board. The might not be learning normal things.
I am so glad that it seems like Emma might be grappling with some of her issues. It might only be one episode, but at least it is something. I am not sure about this whole there is more then one savior thing, so she can never be happy. I would rather them do more with she doesn’t know how to be a family.
As far as i am concerned this show has never killed a main character. The huntsman was hired on with the intention of killing him off at episode seven. He was not a regular according to the press releases. Robin while he was a regular, was barely in episodes. Most of the time when he was, he would just stand around. His death will not effect the show at all. Even Regina, in my opinion, who is supposedly his true love. Baelfire is obviously the most main character because his story is so connected and has been part of the show since the beginning, but even he didn’t appear as Neal til Season 2 and was never given a lot of focus either.
If they kill Emma, Snow, Regina, or Rumpel then it might matter. The rest can go and it won’t matter.
The sets don’t mean anything. The reuse of sets is very common. Especially a large location like this. They may not even show the house or any of the location that was used for Alice’s house. There are a lot worse set issues then this. I remember that time August got attacked at the sheriff’s station and then in the next scene staggered out of the town hall. That made no sense.
I sort of think any of the regular minor characters could die. I think it is pretty unlikely because the writers, write scared, and i think it is unlikely they will do it. I would say Hook and Belle, a well as Zelena, could always die. They serve no purpose and their removal from the story would change nothing. I think it is pretty unlikely Belle is going to die because she is pregnant. If any of the actors want off the show too; they could die because of that.
Josh doesn’t know anything about anything. I bet they added the question after they got the quote. It seems pretty unlikely that they are going to kill anyone that is left at this point.
Nick, most people didn’t guess any of that stuff. There is no real information here. The question is suspect. We can’t know anything. It is okay to be wrong, Nick. There is no reason to be rude about it.
