Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Okay, so I’m ruling out Lacy being Rumple’s name because I think its more likely that we’ll learn his SB name in Welcome to Storybrooke. I don’t think it the mysterious HER because for some reason I think ‘HER’ is initals or something like that.
So, I’m waffling between a town name or it being Belle’s SB name. They have been very careful to have Belle say “who is Belle?” or some variation every time but yet never have her reveal a name sooooo…..
The theory of it being the town where Neal/Bae showed up is pretty sound though.
I still think it’s hysterical that he ended up in the ’10th Kingdom’ though, haha.
[adrotate group="5"]@Charlie Francis wrote:
I know this is a pointless wish given that this show basically tells us “biological family trumps all,” but I hope the show doesn’t think Neal has any rights whatsoever in regards to Henry.
I’m sorry, I just don’t see where you are getting that.
Ruby/Red: raised by Granny
Jimminy/Archie: Seems to consider Gepetto more family then his con artist parents
Graham: Was raised by wolves and LOVED them
Rumple: Isn’t even 100% sure his son is really his son…..doesn’t care. Would move mountains to find him.Now if we’re referring to Regina. Well, lets be honest she (as well as Rumple) has done a lot of things to call into question her ability to be a good parent. Even so, While Emma and Snow have been gone Charming extended an olive branch to her (Regina) and gave her the opportunity to spend time with Henry when he had zero reason too.
So, I really myself can not see how anyone is pushing a’ biological family trumps all agenda on the show. If anything the thing I’m taking away from OUAT is that, family is/are the people you love and cherish. It dôesnt matter if you share blood with someone.
@mujie wrote:
I just came up with a theory. Well, barely. Speculation. An idea. I was thinking in horror movie terms and that people aren’t always who they think they are. If Doctor Whale being Frankenstein was too easy, what if it wasn’t? I can’t remember if Rumple called Whale victor in Storybrooke, but if he didn’t? What if Whale is not victor, but his brother? Whale is he monster. He killed his brother. They’re twins. Whale is tricking everyone.
Gold Definetly called Whale “Victor” in the pawn shop at the end.
@Faux Pax wrote:
Keie, wether or not that’s right, your theory is adorable. Maybe I’ve just seen Puss in Boots one too many times…
Thank you! Haha, my sister and I were talking about it this morning and wracking our brains for a FTCharacter who would possibly be messed up so much that he sort of looks like a jigsaw puzzle who would be put back together. Then while I was a work later on the nursery rhyme just popped into my head, and I was like HUMPTY DUMPTY!
I think Whale’s brother is Humpty Dumpty, actually. You know, the guy who ‘couldn’t be put back together again’ by ‘all the kings horses and all the kings men’. I think Whale figured out a way to do it.
@CSSandiego wrote:
@zlfh4 wrote:
So just a thought, technically Pinocchio was a lost boy as well so maybe they both ended up in Neverland and that is when August tells Bae about the curse and they both decide to come back to the real world together and Peter decides to stay until the curse is broken because he knows his father will be looking for him there..
Pinocchio used another portal (the wardrobe) and we already know he rescued baby Emma right when she got to our world. Not enough time to make him go to Neverland, do whatever and take another portal to our world.
It’s podsible they ran into each in NY though. I mean after August did all his running around as an adult.
@CSSandiego wrote:
@zlfh4 wrote:
So just a thought, technically Pinocchio was a lost boy as well so maybe they both ended up in Neverland and that is when August tells Bae about the curse and they both decide to come back to the real world together and Peter decides to stay until the curse is broken because he knows his father will be looking for him there..
Pinocchio used another portal (the wardrobe) and we already know he rescued baby Emma right when she got to our world. Not enough time to make him go to Neverland, do whatever and take another portal to our world.
It’s podsible they ran into each in NY though. I mean after August did all his running around as an adult.
Okay, so I think what the writers are doing with Rumple makes sense. Last season was all lets see how far we can take things with Regina and still have people love her. This season their doing it with him.
At this point, does he deserve redemption? Does he deserve to have his true love and his son? Or have his past and some present ones pushed him to a place where he doesn’t deserve his happy ending? In my mind the writers are laying out the facts and saying,”Okay audience, how you like him NOW?”
As far as Milha goes….no I don’t think she deserved to die. I also think I would have truly hated her if the storyline had been different and she HAD taken Bae with her. I think she realized a pirate ship was no place for a child! I think she also realized that had she taken Bae, Rumple would have had nothing left to live for…..honestly that one action, NOT taking Bae changed the entire course of fairy tale history in their world. (Rumple would have had no one to protect. Regina would have had no one to influence her to turn to magic. The curse never would have happened…..
So in conclusion: Thanks a lot Milha! This is entirely your fault! Lol
I think and this is just my theory on the whole thing….
The beginning starts with Belle in the blue dress. I think she goes to her dads and they have an argument, “He beat the hell out of me! You can’t be with him!” “Don’t tell me what to do!” She goes to the diner (still the blue dress) and has her talk with Red….and proceeds to get kidnapped again.
The mine cart stuff happens and Belle is rescued. Her and Rumple make up he gives her the library and she goes to thank Red for her help (all the red and blue dress).
The next time we see her she’s in the nighty watching him spin. Next day, the other dress. He gives her the necklace. (For the record I think he’s going to have spelled the necklace in some way so he can always find her, you know since she has a habit if disappearing on him, lol).
