Forum Replies Created
-
Posts
-
Captain Eala wrote: So, my question is, can we infer from that statement that Emma is UNCONCIOUSLY using magic all the time? Breathing is unconscious after all.
Yes, I think so. She made the clock tick way before she even remotely believed in magic.
Hm, just my opinion, but I would have thought that was the curse weakening due to her presence (I think Rumple and Regina discussed that at some point?).
What i’m thinking is that she is using it all the time, since she appears so familiar with it that she compares it to breathing. The question is: what is she doing with it?
I’m possibly over-analysing this too much in the absence of new material 😉
[adrotate group="5"]Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
Very interesting points slurpeez. It’ll be interesting to see the prices of magic for this season.
I was rewatching season 2 again, and in ASOTM Emma states that the power of the failsafe “feels like the oxygen is being sucked out of the air”. Regina says “Not the oxygen. The magic.” Maybe it’s been said before, but it has just struck me that the statement Emma made is very telling. Not only does she CONSCIOUSLY feel that magic is being sucked from the air, but also that it’s like being suffocated. The opposite of suffocation is, obviously, breathing. So, my question is, can we infer from that statement that Emma is UNCONCIOUSLY using magic all the time? Breathing is unconscious after all.
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
Ok, thanks both of you! I’ve never heard that Adam said that.
Related question, has Adam ever stated that, apart from the Sleeping Curse, there are other ways to definitively prove TL?
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
I’m freaking out!!! Abc have got an article on their site – 7 reasons why the crew had better listen to Captain Hook. http://abc.go.com/shows/once-upon-a-time/blogs/storybook/7-reasons-why-the-crew-had-better-listen-to-captain-hook
This is what it said under the first reason:
She may have been Rumplestiltskin’s wife, but Milah was Hook’s True Love, and the vengeful sorcerer took her from him. If anyone knows how important it is to save Henry, it’s Hook.
Was Milah really Hooks TL??? Has this been confirmed by A+E? And, most importantly, can you have more than one TL?
*whimpersob*
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
I wonder if Emma may end up with neither Neal or Hook in the end. CaptainSwan and SwanFire fans are very passionate about their ship so one ship can’t be end game without upsetting the other ship with outcries of “the signs were there!”. By having neither ship be endgame, fans would be sad that their ship wasn’t successful but they would also be happy that Emma hasn’t ended up as part of the other ship.
This is very true. I am a die-hard CS shipper, BUT, if the writers develop Neal sufficiently, redeem him and make him Emma’s perfect counterpart – then I would be happy to accept him as Emma’s TL, though I would be pretty devastated. They need to make either couple easier for the other ship to respect. As it stands though, Hook is showing himself to be the Charming/Rumple to Emma’s Snow/Belle 😉 IMO anyway!
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
I looking yesterday for a gifset of something Eddie and Adam said in regards to CS at PaleyFest. Couldn’t find it but I’m pretty sure they’re as excited as we are to explore a romance between them.
Eddie remarked at CC: It’s only been a couple hundred of years. what they actually said at PaleyFest. Eddie with a devilish grin: I’d like to see it. Adam smiling, clearly fanboying: It could happen.
We’re going to see it happen. No need to worry about that.
*Happy sigh* 😉
Did you make this pic???? I love it!
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
Regina’s horse…See, it is canon that she thought it was what she loved most because she killed it for the curse, before she had to kill her father! (It’s a joke….of course).
Ha thanks for that. I was so confused! 🙂
Neal is a series regular. I like him a lot, and I like Hook a lot and feel they both have quite a bit of depth to their stories, that goes beyond Emma. I don’t like everything they have each done, but that’s true for most of the characters in the show that there’s flaws and strengths, and a journey ahead and more story to tell.
Sorry, just looked it up and saw that he was promoted to regular for season 3. I feel like we have a lot of Bae’s backstory/youth, but with Neal, we don’t really know anything about him. For instance, in the first scene of Broken he was wearing a suit and it looked as though he was coming home from work. But what does he even do for a living? And how was he able to just drop everything and come and stay in SB? I’d just like to know more about him. I don’t hate him or anything. But he is a boring character to me – his adult self has no real depth. We know far more about Hook 🙂
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
Wishing death on a fictional character is pointless and fruitless. Let’s just watch, yeah? Ok. That was me doing my job, not actually correcting anyone outright. I really just wanna say that we are all so polite around here that it makes my heart happy. Coming off Twitter and Tumblr sometimes I feel dirty and shaky about the future of mankind. I <3 you all. [/quote]
Thanks RumplesGirl! Sorry about that, I wasn't technically WISHING for his death but speculating that maybe they will. He really hasn't been developed all that much, and he isn't a series regular (yet!) like Hook is. I'm not a member of Tumblr, I wouldn't know how to make all those gifs and write fics, but I really admire the people who do. The people who try to be haters all the time, well I try and look at them in a new light. They obviously feel threatened in some way, or have crappy lives/issues of their own, and it makes them feel better to be hating on something rather than focus on their own misery. That's my take on it anyway. Though I do admit, the hate gets exhausting for those of us who just want to enjoy our bit of escapism....
[quote]Yes, we’re good. I’m glad you clarified what you were saying Captain Eala, and discussions don’t have to be heated, though they can be lively![/quote]
If I get a bit heated in some of the debates i'm apologising in advance!! We're all obviously very passionate about our ships 🙂
[quote]Though some are just crack for the sake of it (RegalHoof, I’m neighing at you!).Though…if Gus the mouse could become a person…oh dear. What might have been![/quote]
I have never even heard of RegalHoof! Who is the Hoof part?
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
I think this needs to be said: it’s ok if people have different opinions on things. I’m a bit of a multi-shipper, but have backed off posting in this thread because there’s such a difference in how I see the underlying characters and their emotions. That ought to be ok, but when you visit another thread and then come back to react in a sort of “us” versus “them” way about it, it’s kind of off-putting.
I’m sorry you feel that I was trying to do that, but I genuinely wasn’t, your opinion on the subject genuinely concerned me and I just wanted to get some thoughts on that. If you look at the way I phrase my questions, you can see that i’m not trying to be inflammatory, just trying to get other views on your opinion, if you know what I mean.
I wrote that post about crossing lines, and to me, it was about Hook’s character and desire to honor his relationship with Milah, and affection he might have for her son, despite the sad way things ended between them. Its ok if you think of it completely differently, that is why I didn’t express those thoughts on the CS thread. It’s just the way you wrote about visiting the thread, as well as your reaction to the existences of a Hookriel thread, Captain Eala, that troubles me a little. Around these forums, its generally a ship and let ship kind of thing, not a “we’re right and they’re wrong” all out war.
That’s why I wanted another opinion, because your take on the subject struck a chord in me. I just needed a place to reason it out, that’s all. As to my reaction to the existence of the Hookriel thread, that was only in response to the fact that there are a lot of forums/fans out there who think that Captain Swan isn’t a viable couple AT ALL. I was merely pointing out that there hasn’t been any visible interaction between Ariel and Captain Hook and yet there was a lot of pages discussing a possible relationship, which puzzles me because CS have had some VERY significant scenes together.
I’d like it to stay that way, and if you ever disagree with the reasoning of my posts, I’m up for a conversation. I warn you though–it can turn into novella length discussions as it has with MysteryKat. She still loves CS more, and I still lean SF more right now–but everyone is basing our opinions only on the first 2 seasons of the show. I’m more than ready to revise what I think about the ships themselves based on new episodes and reveals on the characters. We poke holes in speculation on non-ship all the time and for me, it is ok if a shippy theory gets poked a little. If you don’t feel comfortable on a different ship thread though, to state your view, fair enough. Just be aware my oppinion is MY opinion, not the view of a “Ship” and it is ok if you disagree, whole or in part.
Sorry about that, when I was saying what the Swanfire thread was talking about I meant in general. I would be happy to have novella length discussions with you 🙂 but not right now, as there is no new material, and it feels like going around in circles sometimes.
Again, sorry! Wasn’t trying to be inflammatory or anything!!! 😀 I look forward to heated debates!!
Keeper of Captain Swan's first kiss
