Forum Replies Created
-
AuthorPosts
-
lisas
ParticipantJo, that’s where my cynical feeling comes in to think that’s what they’d do. There’s a neat article with Chris Lowell who played one of two guys in a triangle with Veronica Mars, and he basically says he’s rooting for the other guy “for survival reasons”. It’s a pretty funny quote, because he’s basically saying it should be a no-brainer that his character is the good guy, but the majority of the fans can’t let go of the “bad boy” who had a rocky history with Veronica. Sometimes, the story has to go where the fandom has its heart, not where the character’s heart might be if written as being in character.
I would hate to think that the CS fandom has become that big and vocal that they now speak for everyone else in the OUAT fandom. They sure don’t speak for me. I hope A&E don’t let the fans influence their vision and story that much because that is how shows die off or get cancelled (seen it happen many times). If they decide to change things up for whatever reason, that’s their prerogative but it darn well better be THEIR idea and not because they got influenced by anyone else.
/end minor rant
Hi Heather you and I are agreed on this because like you I hate to think that the CS fandom has become that big and that vocal that they believe they speak for everyone else in OUAT Fandom which is certainly not the case. Because I have my own voice they DO NOT speak for me. I hate to break to to the CS Fandom but not everyone is enamored with Hook or CS. I know in the beginning back in Season 2 I liked him as a bad guy but when ABC started overpromoting Hook in favor of other characters and then shoving CS in my face almost every single day my resentment towards the character and that particular ship kept growing but to be be clear I never resented Colin because I’m sure none of that was his fault at all. I hope that Adam & Eddy are decent enough fellows and have enough integrity to not cave to all of the fan pressure and influence of CS to completely change their story and vision for the show because that would be a real shame and very real travesty to actors involved with the show as well as the fans of each of the characters if they changed their story due to outside influences. If they do that to Neal after everything in season 2 & season 3A then Adam & Eddy will never ever convince me that it was was story driven.
But I am remaining on my course that this so called “evidence” is nothing more then a huge misdirection and that Neal will survive and that Emma & Neal will reunite move forward and that Neal will reunite with Henry. After All the them e of Season 3B is Home which is something that both Emma & Neal have always wanted. Emma’s home has always been Neal & now Henry and her parents Snow White & Prince Charming after a life time of searching for them. Vice Versa Neal’s home is Emma and Henry and also Rumple & Belle. Emma, Neal and Henry are what binds all of these fairytale characters together and makers them a family despite their dysfunction.[adrotate group="5"]lisas
ParticipantIf they are pics of Henry then it is possible they are from Neal’s apartment, and if that is indeed the case then I’m thinking it’s highly possible that the pictures that Emma has in her hands could very include Neal in them if she did go to Neal’s apartment in Manhattan as we suspect she does. Then if that is the case then The Dreamcatcher & the photos could very well be her talismans in order to for the potion to work.
The questions still remains about Hook
1.)Why is it Hook that came after Emma & Henry and not Neal after all Hook IS NOT their family Neal is ?
2.) Why is that Hook is the only one who remembers the year in the Enchanted Forest and not anyone else ?
3.) Are we absolutely sure that Hook can be trusted ? Is actions honorable Or has he reverted back to his old self that he was back in Season 2 when he used to switch sides for his own personal gain as he did with Cora, GOAT.
4.) Is Hook working for someone else ? Did this memory potion come from the BF or did it come from the WWW herself ?lisas
Participant[quote=243927]The way they set up that piece of the interview was odd. Hook being a major focus; Hook in modern clothing; switch to the death spoiler–and this very brief “Neal’s character will be explored.” But what struck me was that they said sometimes people go back to their old ways because their current path isn’t working. Might they be referring to Hook?[/quote]
I got that impression as well RG I don’t think they were referring to Rumple I think they were refering to Hook. I still believe that he will be working for the WWW. Hook been known to switch alliances in the past we know he did that back in season 2
lisas
ParticipantI can’t believe with theme being Home which we know is something both Emma & Neal want I can’t believe that Adam & Eddy would do that it makes zero sense I believe that it will be Hook that goes NOT Neal
February 9, 2014 at 10:38 am in reply to: Once Upon a Fan Interview with Adam and Eddy (NOW UP) #243917lisas
ParticipantDiane: But can you answer that we’ll see Hook’s character grow more
Adam: We sure hope so—he’s not going anywhere
Did Adam just pretty much confirm that Hook is 100% safe from the spoiler-which-shall-not-be-named?
Did Adam just pretty much confirm that Hook is 100% safe from the spoiler-which-shall-not-be-named?
I did a double take at that too! But would he really be so careless as to give that away?
I did a double take on that too but somehow I don’t believe Adam or Eddy would give something that major away. But Phee I have feeling that those CS are going to take those words as absolute gospel and run with them I can already see it happening, despite the theme of the season 3B which is Home is a theme of SWanFire
lisas
Participant@MsKt86 – Beautiful video and love your work!
@KFChimera – As far as the theme of home is concerned in S3B , I think it’s a pretty sure indicator that SF is how this triangle is going to be resolved. Too many hints have been dropped along the way –Emma ended up in NYC, waking up at 8:15 to “Charley’s Girl”–those are sure nods to SF. Hook’s attempt to insert himself into the dynamic with Emma and Henry will, I believe, ultimately be futile since Emma loves Neal, not Hook. I’d prefer for Hook and Tink to end up together, that’s for sure, but sadly I think Hook’s supposed “willingness to risk his life for love” will ultimately end with him sacrificing himself for Emma. It’s what I call foreshadowing, if ever I’ve seen it. I think Tink and Hook do share a romantic history, but she did seem offended that he would make a druken pass at her when she suspected he had feelings for Emma. Tink basically said it was beneath her dignity. However, they do share a very long, and complicated history together; they were the only adults in NL, and both of them very attractive. I think it’s obvious they hooked up. I do still see a chance for Hook to realize he was misplacing some of his feelings for Emma and seeing a missed opportunity with Tink; maybe he’ll realize at the last moment that she was always there in front of him, if only he’d been able to see past his need for revenge earlier.
[/spoiler]
[quote=243868]
I’d prefer for Hook and Tink to end up together, that’s for sure, but sadly I think Hook’s supposed “willingness to risk his life for love” will ultimately end with him sacrificing himself for Emma.
actually, I think if Hook does sacrifice himself for love, he’ll do it for Nealfire instead of Emma. That’s my hope.[/quote]
I have to agree with RG & Slurpeez about Tink & Hook I think it was fairly obvious that they were attracted to each other in Neverland an most likely were together the chemistry between the two of them was definitely there.
I do believe that Hook will sacrifice his life in order to save Neal, Emma or even Henry for that matter. I think despite everything Hook does see that Neal suffered greatly because of his & Milah’s relationship and that he may not want to see that past repeated when it comes to breaking up a family as did to Rumple, Milah &Baelfire/Neal 300 years prior.
I believe after 312 Hook is going to start to realize that Emma looks at him as a friend nothing more and nothing less and will see that Neal is the man she really loves
lisas
ParticipantI agree with Slurpeez: connected to Neal and Emma. I think TVguide was wildly speculating. As they do
I agree with RG & Slurpeez
You are the magic You’re right where I want to be -From the song “Sweet Freedom” most famously sung by Michael McDonald
Neal fits as the heart of things. Neal is hope.Agreed
lisas
ParticipantHe used to tell me that there are no coincidences. Everything that happens, happens by design, and there’s nothing we can do about it; forces greater than us conspire to make it happen. Fate, destiny, whatever you wanna called it, the point is… maybe we met for a reason. Maybe something good came from us being together.
[x]
Good. Lord. This post.
FATE. IT WILL LEAD THEM HOME.
#BOOM
lisas
ParticipantAlmost Home —> Going Home —> No Place Like Home
Preach It Slurpeez
lisas
Participant“Home” is such a massive thing for both of them, not just together, but individually. Emma never had a home, was constantly moved around. Bae had a home and lost it, and longed to find one again. That’s why their Tallahassee dream meant so much to them both, not just as a couple, but as individuals. It was the fulfillment of a long held dream they both had. So if “home” is gonna be a big theme for S3B, I’d say that SF coming back together by season’s end would fit rather perfectly.
I have to agree with you Phee
-
AuthorPosts